I'm with Phil on this one, @FireDragon76. You can't just try one swing method or another to see if it works for you. You're doing those methods and yourself a great disservice. In all likelihood, you're swinging the club the exact same way you've always been swinging, just thinking about doing things differently each time. In order to make tangible changes to your swing, you have to make a concerted effort to change. That takes time and practice.