Put your big boy pants on like you dad would have done. If the Pens even had a half ass decent record this year. You would have never posted this and you know it. It's the same for every team so quit playing the victim.
I had a little tourney cash to use so I tried a bunch of putters and settled on the odyssey two ball face balanced tank. I absolutely love it. Distance control is incredible with that thing and the ball comes off great. It's worth a peek. Let us know what you decide to roll with. See what I did there?
I have an old Wilson Black Jack putter that I have had for YEARS. I have tried Scotty's, White Hot's, Ping's etc...the old Wilson is still in my bag. My last 9 hole round was 17 putts, no 3 putts. And I was not always close :) I can say for me, it is definitely more about confidence than some mythical spendi-name putter. My only concession was to put on a mid-size Winn grip, which is plenty large for me, to help prevent over-gripping.