Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Bullitt5339

Question about cutting a driver down and swingweight

15 posts in this topic

I must start out by saying that I have noone around here within a reasonable distance that I can really trust to do this correctly for me.

I am 5'5" tall and have a fairly steep swingplane.  My irons which were custom fit, and I hit beautifully,  ended up being 1.25" shorter than standard, 2.5* upright. My current driver is 46" long and has a D5 swingweight and has the standard Callaway grip which weighs 55g.  With my height and fairly steep swingplane, I am having a lot of problems with this driver.  I want to have it cut down to 44.5" to pick up some consistency, which is where my old driver was, but I'm concerned with changing the swingweight too much and screwing up the driver.  (been there, done that).

If I cut 1.5" off the driver and regrip it with my standard Winn Hero grip that weighs 25g, approximately how much weight should I add to the head of the driver to maintain a reasonable swing weight?  And where would be the optimal place to place the lead tape assuming I have a reasonably straight ball-flight?

Thanks for any advice in advance.  If I can get more consistent off the tee, I can start shooting in the 70's... assuming I hit the irons as good as I have been lately.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

Originally Posted by Bullitt5339

I must start out by saying that I have noone around here within a reasonable distance that I can really trust to do this correctly for me.

I am 5'5" tall and have a fairly steep swingplane.  My irons which were custom fit, and I hit beautifully,  ended up being 1.25" shorter than standard, 2.5* upright. My current driver is 46" long and has a D5 swingweight and has the standard Callaway grip which weighs 55g.  With my height and fairly steep swingplane, I am having a lot of problems with this driver.  I want to have it cut down to 44.5" to pick up some consistency, which is where my old driver was, but I'm concerned with changing the swingweight too much and screwing up the driver.  (been there, done that).

If I cut 1.5" off the driver and regrip it with my standard Winn Hero grip that weighs 25g, approximately how much weight should I add to the head of the driver to maintain a reasonable swing weight?  And where would be the optimal place to place the lead tape assuming I have a reasonably straight ball-flight?

Thanks for any advice in advance.  If I can get more consistent off the tee, I can start shooting in the 70's... assuming I hit the irons as good as I have been lately.

First of all, I'd say don't bother with lightweight grips unless you like them. And I'd cut your driver even shorter, maybe as short as 43.5" if you're playing irons that short. Consider 44", I play a driver at about C8/C9 and 44.5" and I'm 6 feet tall. I could add about 4-6 grams to get it into the D range, but it's not that big a deal, especially when it's shorter. I'd imagine a low swingweight is more problematic at 46" than 44".

This tool should let you see what kind of numbers you're looking at, I can't comment on where to put the weight but you might be able to get away with replacing the weight plugs or tip weights if there are any.

http://www.hirekogolf.com/hireko/graphics/orderportal/modules/swingweight.html

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I don't care about the weight of the grip that much, it's just that I'm partial to the Winn Hero grips.  As a disabled veteran, I like the camo and the money that goes to charity, plus they feel great.  I am a novice at club weights, but very willing to learn.

I just want my drive to be consistent....... lol

I will try to find all the numbers and use that calculator you posted and post the numbers to see what people think.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You lose three swingweights for every half-inch you trim from a club's shaft. So, you would lose 9 swingweights from trimming 1.5" off the shaft.  You can increase the swingweight by going with a lighter grip - a clubfitter who understands balance ratios could figure out what a  25-gram grip would do.

Also, some swingweight machines contain small trays you can insert above the head and butt. You would then put any weights or grips into the trays to get a good estimate on how much a grip would increase or decrease the swingweight.

Many traditional standard-size grips weigh in at 58-60 grams.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Well, I found out this morning that when the Pro Golf closed here in town, the club fitter, along with all of his equipment are now at one of the courses on Ft. Bragg.  So I went during lunch and dropped my driver off with him to have it shortened, new grip installed and the swing weight verified.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In theory you could compensate for the loss in swingweight and increased stiffness by adding lead tape to the clubhead.  You have a really nice driver, so I would be hesitant to do it.  My advice would be to have some place ship it back to Callaway and have them do the work for you.  You should be able to tell them what length, swing weight, and frequency you want.  They may suggest reshafting though.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got the driver back this afternoon, and he showed me that without adding any weight, with just the grip change the swingweight is now D1.  I swung it a few times, and didn't notice a big change in the perceived weight of the driver, so I held off of adding any weight to it and will take it out for a test run tomorrow.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, the results are in, and looking promising.  I noticed absolutely no distance loss from going to 44" and actually hit 2 of my longest drives on holes today.  I would suspect that's from making better contact with the shorter driver.  Here's my round today, and the driver wasn't bad.  About half of the missed fairways were just off the fairway, still in easy play and one was because I went straight through a dogleg left. My irons started off a little rough, but I really picked it up near the end of the round with them.  My putting sucked as it has usually lately, and cost me quite a few strokes.

scorecard1.jpg

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by Bullitt5339

Well, the results are in, and looking promising.  I noticed absolutely no distance loss from going to 44" and actually hit 2 of my longest drives on holes today.  I would suspect that's from making better contact with the shorter driver.  Here's my round today, and the driver wasn't bad.  About half of the missed fairways were just off the fairway, still in easy play and one was because I went straight through a dogleg left. My irons started off a little rough, but I really picked it up near the end of the round with them.  My putting sucked as it has usually lately, and cost me quite a few strokes.

That looks like a pretty good card. No penalties, only the one bad score on one of the easiest holes on the course... Just need to polish that iron play and get more GIR and tighter approaches. If you got down to 30 putts, which would be pretty freaking good, you'd be down to single digits. Eliminate the 3 putts and hit the green on #10, same deal. Driving honestly looked pretty good and you're at almost 70% accuracy with the driver alone.

Quite the test run, I should say.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Yeah, typically I'm really good at #10, but the pin was forward today and the tees were forward, so it was playing about 130 yards.  I hit a flubbed 9 iron, and then bladed a wedge over the green, then hit a mediocre 3rd on a tough green and 2 putted.  It was just one of those holes.......... lol  Typically my irons are pretty good for my handicap, but I just wasn't hitting them crisp today.  Heaven forbid I hit driver and irons well in the same day.............. lol

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by Bullitt5339

Yeah, typically I'm really good at #10, but the pin was forward today and the tees were forward, so it was playing about 130 yards.  I hit a flubbed 9 iron, and then bladed a wedge over the green, then hit a mediocre 3rd on a tough green and 2 putted.  It was just one of those holes.......... lol  Typically my irons are pretty good for my handicap, but I just wasn't hitting them crisp today.  Heaven forbid I hit driver and irons well in the same day.............. lol

You can always cut an inch off all your irons and wedges if all else fails... Ditto for the putter. Well, maybe not. But it works for the driver anyway. With par 3s, it seems like every pin is a sucker pin sometimes.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

My irons are custom fit, 1.25" short and I absolutely love them most of the time.  My putter is 33.5", I just can't read greens to save my life.  I am trying to free up a Saturday to go work with David Orr in one of his Aimpoint courses to help out my putting and green reading abilities.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Honesty, i just like choking down, it gives me more flexibility, and i feel more comfortable.. So my driver is 45", i choke down to about 43.5-44"

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by saevel25

Honesty, i just like choking down, it gives me more flexibility, and i feel more comfortable.. So my driver is 45", i choke down to about 43.5-44"

For some reason, I have never been comfortable choking down on clubs, and since I'm a short dude, I would have to choke down on everything.  For some reason, if I'm not holding the very end of the club, it feels very odd to me and uncomfortable.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I want to reshaft my driver but go shorter to increase accuracy. Everything ive heard or read suggests shorter is better, so i thought id give it a try. I currently game a 46.5" wilson dxi 10.5, with an S flex pro launch red and midsize golf pride new decade grip.


I'm getting the bimatrix tour prototype shaft and I want to play it at 44.5" but an concerned about the sw change and want to avoid the tape solution if possible.

Can I maintain swing weight (or lessen impact on feel) by adding 10g tip weight and switching to the standard GP grip which is about 10g lighter? (shafts are similar +/- 1g difference).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • Share your New Strokes Gained Data from GAME Golf!
      Wow! Thanks for the response. Seeing what I consider an "acceptable miss" for me (since I'm currently happy with a 2-putt from 9 feet), shows how much work I still have to do. My putting wasn't at its best the last couple of rounds. I could give reasons/excuses, but they were what they were. Just looking at my "last round vs scratch" shows how bad my putting was yesterday, compared with expanding it to anything over 5 rounds, where it drops into the 5.something range: Yeah, I said that my first putt is usually more than 10 feet or so.  I only meant that I'm usually not hitting my approach shots close to the pin--I'm usually on the green more than 10 feet from the hole (where a pro has about a 50-50 chance of a 1-putt).  So being beyond 10 feet, my expectation is that since a pro is 50:50 (and worse, as distance goes up), I likely won't make those putts. As always, your insight is appreciated. I've got more work to do, and an attitude to adjust--I'm setting my expectations too low.  Thanks a bunch for taking a look at this.
    • My Swing (Hardspoon)
      Reviewed the Functional Grip thread and practiced at home all week.  Here's what my grip looks like now: (Bonus points for accidentally capturing the Titleist backpack I won at the Norwalk TST outing last year.  I went to crop the picture and realized it was back there so I left it in) Hopefully I haven't gone too far in the other (weak) direction...it's frustrating that I can't figure out how to hold a damn club. Went to the range this evening, and, as expected, was back to hitting a lot of pushes and push-slices.  I had to focus on delivering the clubface square (using a flat left wrist feel)...was able to hit some solid shots with that thought, but not very many. Took @iacas' advice and kept working on the same stuff (proper turn, in-to-out path, "extendo-arms" on the follow through) and mixed in some punch swings.  I definitely made better contact on those. Hopefully I can get this stupid grip thing taken care of...if this looks good, I'll just spend a few minutes every day practicing it.
    • Are you a Better Golfer than a Year Ago?
      Might have to change my vote to about the same. Finally got to play a league round (9 holes), in some honest to God warm weather with some fairways that had firmed up enough so that drives weren't hitting and jumping back two feet! Oh how these 63 year old joints love sunshine and warmth! Scored my best round so far, right on my handicap number. Now I actually feel like getting to work on my game!
    • Jordan Spieth lobs a marshmallow w/a wedge and eats it on its way down
      Maybe it's because I have kids. . but that's a dirty marshmallow.  Yecch.  Catch it in your hat or something next time.  Jeez. 
    • When a Pro Can’t Correct
      Ahh yes, I'm entirely familiar with this little game of golf swing whack-a-mole, lol.  I know it sounds cliché but you probably don't really understand just how good Jordan Speith is.  That sounds a little condescending but I truly don't mean it like that - I'm sure I don't, either.  He's playing a pretty different game than we do.  I imagine, if it was possible to somehow transplant our brains into Jordan Speith's body as he swings a club so we could feel what it feels like - it would freak us right out.  We'd be like . .WTH!?!, lol  And then we'd quit golf forever because we couldn't do that without our bodies snapping in half. 
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. golf82
      golf82
      (57 years old)
  • Blog Entries