• Announcements

    • iacas

      Create a Signature!   02/05/2016

      Everyone, go here and edit your signature this week: http://thesandtrap.com/settings/signature/.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
jmac696

Is Sergio Garcia a One or Two Plane Golfer?

18 posts in this topic

Is Sergio Garcia a one or two plane golfer and can someone describe the difference
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

A one-plane golfer tracks the same path on his backswing as his downswing.

A two-plane golfer has a downswing that has a different path than his backswing.

I asked my golf pro whether I had a one-plane or a two-plane swing, and he told me not to worry about it. He said it was more important to be consistent.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Two. The water plane and the grass plane.

Ok I'm terrible at humor.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are so many definitions of swing planes that this thread could get interesting (and maybe leave our heads spinning).

I go with this definition:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Izp9Jrirk1Q&NR;=1&feature;=fvwp

By that definition Sergio has a one plane swing, but he is one of the few golfers that returns the shaft as low or lower at impact than he was at address.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey, guys. I was just messing around here and made a video about this just now. Just experimenting of course. Please chime in if I said something wrong as I always welcome being corrected so I can improve too.

Here's my vid though on this:

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Hey, guys. I was just messing around here and made a video about this just now. Just experimenting of course. Please chime in if I said something wrong as I always welcome being corrected so I can improve too. Here's my vid though on this:

Awesome! A few things I would look at: (1) Sergio looks to be a bit more one-plane than he was early on in his career; (2) you're comparing Sergio with a wedge to Freddie with a driver (you'd probably find the same results if they were using the same clubs, though maybe not as pronounced); and (3) the way Sergio drops his hands without really starting down with his hips messes with the one-plane/two-plane stuff. Sort of like how there's no one perfect spot to define Ben Hogan's A4 because he started down with his hips before his arms were at the top, Sergio can go from his arm plane above the shoulder plane to one-plane before he even starts down with his body. And if my voice wasn't so awful that it would shatter the windows in your house, maybe I'd make an Analyzr video about that. :-D

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by jamo

Quote:

Originally Posted by JetFan1983

Hey, guys. I was just messing around here and made a video about this just now. Just experimenting of course. Please chime in if I said something wrong as I always welcome being corrected so I can improve too.

Here's my vid though on this:

Awesome! A few things I would look at: (1) Sergio looks to be a bit more one-plane than he was early on in his career; (2) you're comparing Sergio with a wedge to Freddie with a driver (you'd probably find the same results if they were using the same clubs, though maybe not as pronounced); and (3) the way Sergio drops his hands without really starting down with his hips messes with the one-plane/two-plane stuff. Sort of like how there's no one perfect spot to define Ben Hogan's A4 because he started down with his hips before his arms were at the top, Sergio can go from his arm plane above the shoulder plane to one-plane before he even starts down with his body.

And if my voice wasn't so awful that it would shatter the windows in your house, maybe I'd make an Analyzr video about that.

Haha! You should have!

All good points. I should've used driver Sergio. It's basically the same.

I also probably could've mentioned how hand depth changes, how there's a difference between arm lifting and being a pro with a 2-plane swing, etc.

Also, this isn't the same stuff as when Johnny Miller or Nick Faldo says "he's right on plane" when referring to some pro's downswing. In that scenario, you really only have one option when swinging your club. You better be on plane. And that refers to the angle of the shaft relative to the tilted plane we play golf on.

Again, please correct me where wrong, guys!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

When I watched today, it seemed Sergio was dropping way less inside than I remember.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sergio is a modern guy in tune with our high tech society.  He is a .com-plainer.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by JetFan1983

Nice video, yeah agree with Jetfan, Sergio is a one planer.  Interesting thing is, if you cut off Couples and Sergio's arms at the top of the backswing, very similar looking torso positions.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

It appears Sergio gets more wrist hinge on the downswing than the backswing - does anyone else see that?
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by mvmac

Interesting thing is, if you cut off Couples and Sergio's arms at the top of the backswing, very similar looking torso positions.

Good point! Yea, both players' shoulders tilt a good amount downward. They're definitely not level shoulder turns.

Originally Posted by Mulligan Jeff

It appears Sergio gets more wrist hinge on the downswing than the backswing - does anyone else see that?

For sure! Go on Youtube, and you'll see that the vast majority of the comments on Sergio's swing videos are "OMG, LAG!!!"

But yea, this is part of that "whip effect" people talk about with the golf swing. Make a motion like you're going to crack a whip, and you'll notice your wrist does the same thing. The wrist hinge increases at the start the "downswing" of the whipping motion. Some instructors say that if your wrist hinge is about 90 degrees at the top of the backswing, it should increase to about 80 degrees during the early moments of your downswing, or thereabouts.

Having said that (Curb reference), this video Mike made recently best explains how to go about creating said lag:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by WUTiger

A one-plane golfer tracks the same path on his backswing as his downswing.

A two-plane golfer has a downswing that has a different path than his backswing.

That's not really the definition. Almost every golfer would be a two-plane golfer if that was the case, and someone like Jim Furyk would be a six-plane golfer. :D JetFan's "shoulders match the lead arm" is the definition (because it's not JetFan's, but Hardy's).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by iacas

Quote:

Originally Posted by WUTiger

A one-plane golfer tracks the same path on his backswing as his downswing.

A two-plane golfer has a downswing that has a different path than his backswing.

That's not really the definition. Almost every golfer would be a two-plane golfer if that was the case, and someone like Jim Furyk would be a six-plane golfer. :D JetFan's "shoulders match the lead arm" is the definition (because it's not JetFan's, but Hardy's).

I'm getting off-topic here, but maybe this is my opportunity to post this video and make this point... or perhaps I should just put this on the thread " Elbow Positioning and Its Effect on the Downswing " instead as that seems to be the most relevant place based on a quick search I just did.

But when I saw Lee Westwood miss the ball this past week at the Players, I thought of the "steep to shallow" shaft angle on a good player's backswing and downswing, because its the perfect explanation for why he doesn't hit the tree going back, but does hit it going down:

Last off-topic post I'll make here.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

It defines the potion at the top of the back swing.

One-plane - left arm accross the shoulder line.

Two-plane - left arm above the shoulder line.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

"You'd better be on plane." But most pro golfers have a looping swing, backswing to a high position with the right arm showing a nice 90 degree angle between upper arm and forearm, then the right elbow goes down tight against the body in what is called "the magic move," which means the clubshaft and head approach the ball on a lower angle. Loop.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only way you're not gonna have a loop in your swing is if on the backswing your right upper arm and elbow goes back to a tight position against your ribs and that is its position in the downswing.

Those who take their left arm back near shoulder plane often have a separation between right elbow and torso, and they bring the elbow in against the ribs on the downswing. But that alters the plane of the downswing, and so you can't say absolutely they have a one-plane swing. Yeah, it may be close to a one-plane swing compared to most swings, and maybe that's enough to make them fit the one-plane classification.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by JetFan1983

But when I saw Lee Westwood miss the ball this past week at the Players, I thought of the "steep to shallow" shaft angle on a good player's backswing and downswing, because its the perfect explanation for why he doesn't hit the tree going back, but does hit it going down:

Yeah the shaft angle gets steep to shallow, "loop" but as you know lead arm tends to be "over the top" for a lot of the best players.  Meaning the lead arm is more inward at A3 than at A5.  Just because they're more turned away from the target at A3 than A5.  Sergio's arm depth is pretty similar at A3/A5.  More due to the way he increases his inclination than him trying to actually "loop" it.

Originally Posted by Ole_Tom_Morris

The only way you're not gonna have a loop in your swing is if on the backswing your right upper arm and elbow goes back to a tight position against your ribs and that is its position in the downswing.

Those who take their left arm back near shoulder plane often have a separation between right elbow and torso, and they bring the elbow in against the ribs on the downswing. But that alters the plane of the downswing, and so you can't say absolutely they have a one-plane swing. Yeah, it may be close to a one-plane swing compared to most swings, and maybe that's enough to make them fit the one-plane classification.

Again, not the definition of a One Plane Swing, read this

Originally Posted by EverythingGolf

It defines the potion at the top of the back swing.

One-plane - left arm accross the shoulder line.

Two-plane - left arm above the shoulder line.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • My Swing (coop6)
      It pretty much is, I'm not going to debate 5 degrees with you. As I've said repeatedly, Tiger's swing and a standard swing do not require rotation. On this shot he rotated 5 degrees, not much. If you want to play with rotation to closed enjoy. I prefer to keep the club square. 
    • Struggles of turning pro
      http://thesandtrap.com/blogs/ Normally you must be an Established Member to create a blog, but I've enabled this for you now.
    • No Forearm Rotation - Biggest Swing Flaw?
      Completely bogus. The arms (forearms) rotate in every good golf swing. Here's an old thread that's appropriate for this discussion.   Also, I don't think I've ever really seen a golfer, throughout his backswing, rotate his forearms the opposite way. For short periods of time, maybe a few golfers "counter-rotate," but all end up rotating some. No, there won't be "arguments" over this, or there shouldn't be, because… like many things, this is pretty much a fact. There really doesn't need to be an argument or a discussion. It's a knowable, understandable thing. Hunter, like every other PGA Tour pro, rotates his forearms during the backswing. You're rotating your arms as you do this. It's subtle, but if you just pick the club up straight without rotating, you'll have the shaft resting against the top of your head. Look at where the back of your left hand points. Toward the target at setup, and then rotated to put the club on your right shoulder. Turn to the top when the club is on your face or the top of your head and the club will be leaning out over the target line (it'll be roughly parallel to your bend toward the ball, since it's basically just staying inline with your spine). Bending your right arm rotates your forearms. It pulls everything to the right (you can't bend your right arm straight in front of you without also bending your left arm). Then even more rotation is added after that. I agree that you don't want to be doing a lot of "things" on the downswing, but that's not how physics works. You can do all sorts of things on the backswing and not do them on the downswing. We have students who swing steep to steep, steep to shallow, shallow to steep, shallow to shallow, and all sorts of things. We have students who address the ball with a closed clubface, roll it way open, and then return it wide open, etc. The "equal and opposite" does not mean a delayed reaction - it means that if I push on something it will, right at that very moment, push back. If I fire rocket propulsion downward, the missile or space shuttle or whatever will move upward. You don't fire rockets and then, a week later, a different missile takes off as a "reaction." Furthermore, PGA Tour players have a variety of backswings. Ray Floyd was underneath, Rickie Fowler or Ryan Moore are steep or over the top on the backswing. The golfer who comes closest to the "square" or "no rotation" backswing is a guy who CAN'T really rotate his forearms: Tim Clark. And even Tim rotates some. But notice how far "out over his head" the clubhead is, despite the fact that he's well short of parallel on the backswing. It's so much more than that. I ask people in my lessons how much skill or raw natural talent it takes to set up properly. The correct answer: none. They just have to know how to do it. If golf was as simple as "set up properly and then turn" we'd all be a whole lot better than we are. Golfers can be set up the same and make very, very different backswings, and both can be successful. So Bubba is doing it wrong? And what does that have to do with the swing flaw of "rotating your forearms"? (Is overswinging a big problem? Absolutely. More, IMO, for what it tends to do to the trail elbow and the subsequent inability of the player to get the arms and hands down fast enough. I'll never really argue against overswinging, except when it's made as a blanket statement covering all golfers who go past parallel or something.) Also, you said (though it feels off topic since this is mostly about forearm rotation, n'est-ce pas?) "the more you have to wait for them to come down." That's not really true - you can MAKE them come down faster. Your arms aren't just limp things hanging from your shoulders that get dragged behind your hips and torso rotating. Because, biomechanically, making a swing with no forearm rotation would be ridiculous and resemble the golf swings of precisely no good players, ever. Tim Clark comes closest, and people don't even copy his swing, and if Tim Clark's forearms would rotate as most people's do, even Tim Clark would have a different golf swing. Modeling your golf swing on someone with a disability hardly seems like the prudent choice. My last piece of evidence, right here: This should drive the point home pretty significantly. Spoiler One last thing here. Consider the sagittal plane (in the spoiler above, just so it's not taking up a ton of space) and the back of the left hand (assuming a right-handed golfer). At address, they're parallel - the back of the left hand is parallel to the sagittal plane. Yet at the top of the backswing, what do we see? The sagittal plane (at the point of attachment of the arms, i.e. near the shoulders) is about 90° from where it started. It's inclined at about 35° or so, but otherwise just is still just a plane bisecting the sternum, neck, face, etc. What plane is the back of the left wrist on? Why, it's one that's about 90° to the sagittal plane. I've illustrated this here: In this illustration, I've drawn a little "cube" in the screen on the left. The green face of the cube is parallel to the sagittal plane (the edge of the plane is pointing "at the camera"). The blue side - perpendicular to the green side - is parallel to the back of the left hand. It too is pointing at the camera, but has rotated about 90°. That's why it's parallel to a perpendicular side of the cube. On the right, above, to make the back of Mike's left hand parallel the green face of the cube, he'd have to rotate his arms BACK about 90° to the red line. Now, then, @Golfer2223, you'd set a record as the first human being in history to present an argument as you have done and immediately recognize, given my response and a little thought on your part, that you want to take back your entire argument and completely change your position. In other words, I don't expect that to happen. A small part of me hopes it will some day, but I don't think today is going to be that day. But, realistically, that's what should happen. As I see it, you have no real ground to stand on here. Not biomechanically, not based on simple geometry, nothing. The arms rotate during the backswing in EVERY good player. Even in Tim Clark's backswing (or he'd truly have the club hanging out over his head. I will also say this, @Golfer2223: I appreciate your willingness to help, and to jump in, and to offer your thoughts on things. I hope you can take this rebuttal in the spirit in which it's intended - to help and to discuss. I don't know who you are (you should add more info to your profile), and I'm not responding just to be mean, but to help people learn, think critically, and better understand the golf swing. We encourage debate and discussion here, and that's all my response is to be taken as - more debate and discussion. Do I think I'm right? Yes. And I think I've backed up why. P.S. As someone noted above, often students need to feel like there's no rotation in the backswing. But that doesn't make it accurate.
    • Northern Michigan Courses
      I have been to Northern Michigan on several occasions. There are a lot of great golf courses but they are SPREAD OUT so keep driving distance in mind.   Arcadia Bluffs Forest Dunes True North Little Traverse Bay Belvedere Dunmaglas Black Lake Grand Traverse Resort (Nicklaus and Player Course) Lochenheath  Leelanau Boyne Hills Course   These are all EXCELLENT golf courses that are worth playing
    • Crandon/Key Biscayne or Biltmore
      Wow, tough choice! Key Biscayne or Crandon. Either one would be awesome.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

  • Blog Entries