RFKFREAK

My Swing (RFKFREAK)

200 posts in this topic

I've been Playing Golf for: 6 months

My current handicap index or average score is: 36

My typical ball flight is: Mostly straight but sometimes left to right

The shot I hate or the "miss" I'm trying to reduce/eliminate is: Fade with driver but I've gotten better with it.

A little backstory:

I'm 37 years old and really started getting into golf in March with a starter set that I bought 6 or 7 years ago.  I've been keeping track of my scores (roughly 25 rounds) and if I did the math correctly, I'm a 36 handicap and have had numerous rounds on par 4 holes where I put up an 8 or worse.  I've never really been able to consistently make good contact with my irons, have fade my driver for most of the season, and only recently have I been hitting my woods fairly well.  I've been going to the range roughly once or twice a week after work and usually get a round in once a weekend.

Three weekends ago I achieved my one goal for the season of shooting a round under 100 (96).  The following weekend I played and shot a miserable 125 and this past weekend I shot a 108.

My biggest issue at the moment is solid contact so I took a lesson with a local PGA instructor where he had me work on two things:

1) Grip.  The instructor said that my left hand should not have a gap between my thumb and pointer finger.  He also said I should hold the club in my left hand more on my finger tips.

2) He said I shouldn't be turning my body as much as I do when I go in the backswing and should feel as though I'm going forward.  He said I should practice this motion without a club by having my arms outstretched and feeling the left one moving forward which allows my right shoulder to move forward and my right arm like a back swing which allows my shoulder to move back.

This is my first range session since that lesson so was hoping I could get some feedback on my swing.

Thanks in advance!

Videos:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

Hmm, your stance looks like it might be too narrow for your build and your toes appear to be pointed straight ahead.  I used to do something similar and I think it was one of the things that killed my ability to hit the ball far.  I ended up watching a few different videos that suggested a wider stance and flaring the toes out a little bit (20 degrees) and it seemed to help me.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm confused as to why I want to flare my toes out.

The common reason is I think it unlocks the hips and allows you to more easily turn your body through the swing.  When I tried it for the first time my swing really did feel easier, like I suddenly wasn't fighting a phantom resistance that was there all this time.  I've also noticed that when I keep my left foot pointed straight ahead and shift my weight onto my left leg during my swing it tends to roll my ankle under my leg.  When I get home and relax after the round I notice my ankle aches from doing this over and over all day.   If I remember to turn my foot out slightly that doesn't happen at all since my weight is able to shift onto the ball of the foot instead.

I would certainly like more experienced players to chime in though in case I am making bad observations.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hysterical Office Space reference :-D

Hmmm, why should you do this, hmmm. Because Sam Snead did it and he was awesome? :-P

OK, here's why you do that:

.... I like both feet flared out.  Like you found out, helps the hips turn and the rear knee release some flexion so the shoulders and hips can turn on an incline plane.  Also helps the right foot bank on the downswing and prevent injury in your hips.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Watching the videos a couple more times it really does look like your stance is too narrow, it's almost impossible to see any weight transfer going on.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep that front arm locked straight.  As it is now you're practically wrapping the shaft around your throat on the back swing.  It's going to be near impossible to get a consistent swing with much better results than you're getting now doing that.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

What mdl said.  A straight left arm and fairly flat left wrist (which for me at least means a right wrist cupped well back) will help you get the club back to the same place it started.  Once you let the left arm break down much it is very hard to return on plane.  Everyone wants a big backswing.  All the pros do it.  However, they are flexible as Gumby and most of us aren't.  You will be surprised how far you can hit the ball even with a shorter back swing.

And on the subject of the backswing, now would be a great time to practice a slower more deliberate one sweeping the left arm and club shaft back along the swing plane.  If the shaft is aligned right the butt of the grip should point at the ball on the way back.  This picture is one of my regular swing keys.  Seems to help me.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is all great advice, thank you! I'm heading to the range in an hour and I'm thinking focusing on the straight left arm and footwork unless someone thinks different.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I'm also finding that I'm not very flexible with my swing which is probably why I break my arm
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

What mdl said.  A straight left arm and fairly flat left wrist (which for me at least means a right wrist cupped well back) will help you get the club back to the same place it started.  Once you let the left arm break down much it is very hard to return on plane.  Everyone wants a big backswing.  All the pros do it.  However, they are flexible as Gumby and most of us aren't.  You will be surprised how far you can hit the ball even with a shorter back swing.

And on the subject of the backswing, now would be a great time to practice a slower more deliberate one sweeping the left arm and club shaft back along the swing plane.  If the shaft is aligned right the butt of the grip should point at the ball on the way back.  This picture is one of my regular swing keys.  Seems to help me.

Yep, those were huge discoveries for me, more so the flat wrist.

Quote:

Originally Posted by RFKFREAK

This is all great advice, thank you!

I'm heading to the range in an hour and I'm thinking focusing on the straight left arm and footwork unless someone thinks different.

How did it go?

I'm also finding that I'm not very flexible with my swing which is probably why I break my arm

I think it's mostly the urge to wind up and try to crush the ball.  It's a pretty hard habit to break though, I still find myself doing it sometimes but in a slightly different way.  My arm doesn't break down and do the chicken wing but my torso twists too far and I can't get back to the ball in time and end up hitting a slice.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How did it go?

I think it's mostly the urge to wind up and try to crush the ball.  It's a pretty hard habit to break though, I still find myself doing it sometimes but in a slightly different way.  My arm doesn't break down and do the chicken wing but my torso twists too far and I can't get back to the ball in time and end up hitting a slice.

It went...ok.

I think I really have to also concentrate on my swing plane.  I think I'm coming over the top too much.  I also think I improved my left arm but it's probably not completely straight.  I never realized how hard it is to keep it straight.  I feel it's something I'll have to focus on...along with everything else.  I'm probably also still swinging too fast.  I did notice that my ball didn't seem to go as far but I'm guessing that's to be expected since I'm trying to learn new things.

Here are a couple of vids with my 7 iron from today:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

The wider stance looks better imo, but I think your feet (especially the left) still aren't flared out enough.  If you watch the first video towards the end of your swing do you see how the inside of your left foot comes off the ground?  I think that's your weight trying to shift onto your left leg but your closed stance is getting in the way.  It looks like your weight goes onto your heel at that point which is also probably not good and the swing ends with an all around unstable look (plus the step forward gives it away).

And yeah you're still wrapping the club around your neck.  lol  That's a whole other animal though, I think I would mess with the stance until you can swing and not feel any urge to tip forward or back at the end of the swing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The wider stance looks better imo, but I think your feet (especially the left) still aren't flared out enough.  If you watch the first video towards the end of your swing do you see how the inside of your left foot comes off the ground?  I think that's your weight trying to shift onto your left leg but your closed stance is getting in the way.  It looks like your weight goes onto your heel at that point which is also probably not good and the swing ends with an all around unstable look (plus the step forward gives it away). And yeah you're still wrapping the club around your neck.  lol  That's a whole other animal though, I think I would mess with the stance until you can swing and not feel any urge to tip forward or back at the end of the swing.

You're quite perceptive. Yeah, with my old swing I felt more control. Not so much now. Planning on heading to the range again tomorrow and definitely will focus on the keeping my left arm straight, trying to get in the correct swing plane, and do slower swings until it feels more natural and not so off balance. Roughly how many degrees do you think I should flare my feet out?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

You're quite perceptive. Yeah, with my old swing I felt more control. Not so much now. Planning on heading to the range again tomorrow and definitely will focus on the keeping my left arm straight, trying to get in the correct swing plane, and do slower swings until it feels more natural and not so off balance.

Roughly how many degrees do you think I should flare my feet out?

The number I recall reading was 20 degrees but someone here mentioned 10-15 so I'm not sure, probably 15-20.  There should be kind of a sweet spot where if you turn too far out it'll feel awkward and you'll start hitting whack shots and you'll just know you crossed the line.  I would simply spend a dozen balls trying different amounts and see which one feels completely comfortable and leaves you without the urge to tip some direction at the end of the swing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A couple more vids.  I think I'm keeping my left arm straighter but it's not fully straight.  I also just noticed I have no lag in my swing and don't get my hands in front of the ball at impact.  I tried flaring my toes a bit more and failed to get on a good swing plane.

So much to do.  I will say that I was hitting the ball pretty well towards the end of my range session today.  It wasn't going very far, but i felt I was making good contact more consistently.

Anyway, here's a couple of vids from today's session.  The down the line video was taken towards the middle of my session while the face on video was towards the end when I felt I was striking the ball well (at least, for me).

All this being said, I feel like I've improved this week and have stuff to build on.

I'm planning on playing at an outing with friends on Saturday and possibly on Sunday with a friend (hoping to hit a couple buckets beforehand)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

You look a lot more stable at the end of the swing in the top video which is cool, though I still think the flared feet would be helpful. :-P Perhaps later.

Like someone mentioned earlier your backswing is very, very fast which isn't necessary and makes it hard to tell what you're doing with your hands.  I think the reason you have no lag with the club is because you aren't utilizing your wrists.  At address your wrists are tilted forward, towards the head of the club, and your arms and club form roughly a long straight line, right?  I have a feeling this isn't changing much at all during your swing.  When you take your backswing they need to hinge back the opposite way (towards your right shoulder) so that your arms and club form the letter L instead. Be sure not to lose your flat left wrist when you do this. This should get the clubhead behind your wrists and create the lag you're looking for on the downswing.

Check out this video, this is one of my favorites and watch it from time to time to remind myself how to do the backswing:

Edit:  Here is the follow-up video about the downswing, also very good:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • 2016 BMW PGA Championship at Wentworth
      Many years ago while on a business trip to London I got a chance to play Wentworth West - even back then in 1991 it was a tremendous course that made great use of the rolling woodlands in Surrey. Its a bit sad that the course has now become the architectural plaything of Ernie Els and the European tour - some of the holes now resort to certain modern tricks like artificial water features or shaved greenside banks leading to hazards or chipping areas - perhaps in the next round of changes Ernie and his design elfs will come a bit more to their senses and let the design return a bit more to the features that were there in the original HS Colt design. As far as the tournament goes, it seems like there is a real problem in terms of when to fit it in a place in the schedule where you can get the cream of the European tour to show up.  The Players Championship with its huge reward of 10 years of exemptions for the US tour makes it a bit more compelling as an event and the Nelson and Colonial and Memorial tournaments are all big events on the US tour leading up to the US Open so taking the two weeks time to travel over to England in the start of the summer is perhaps not something a lot of European pros who live in the US are willing to make.  Was exciting to see if Chris Wood was going to choke the event away but nice to see him win - he did have a great front nine but seemed on the verge of letting it get away on the back nine.
    • Scientific Studies
      Oh, good Lord! I can't believe that you entered such a completely off the mark reply! I thought you had some smarts. Valuable eyeballs? There are no such things! There are only eyeballs. Advertising rates are established on "number of impressions", in other words the number of people who see your ad. The only "value" established for those "eyeballs" is what age they are, what demographic they belong to. If you're seeking to market to a particular demographic, you might pay more to place an ad on "this" show rather than "that" show. And who said anything about "left and right"? You did! You used the phrase "industry supported research", which is a code phrase of the left to indicate research that is suspect! When have you ever heard "Entertainment Industry supported research", or "Actor supported research" in reply! And please don't try to tell me that government sponsored research is as pure as the wind driven snow. I've just realized that you may be confining your remarks to the field of physics. In that realm, they might be valid. Besides you, me, and a couple of guys behind the tree, who the hell cares? I'm referring more to "agendized" science, like climatology, nutrition, and prescription drugs. As for blind funding, that doesn't mean throwing money at any bunch of yahoos who cook up some hare brained scheme. All it means is that the people who are doing the research don't know where the money is.coming from. So they don't know who is buttering their bread! Let's face it, scientists are people, and they need to make a living. There was a line from "The Big Bang Theory" that, while fictional, makes real world sense. In one episode another physicist, Barry Kripke, is asked why he's still studying string theory. He says, "Hey, I study a theory that can't be proven, I apply for grants, and I spend the money on booze and broads!"
    • "Swing Machine Golf" by Paul Wilson
      I will apologize in advance if this post winds up being long. I went out for my first round of golf in 2015, shot a 110, went home, put my clubs on Craigslist, sold them within a day and decided to quit the game. I had been playing for 25 years but only felt I was getting worse. Then, while planning a summer trip to Las Vegas I stumbled upon Paul Wilson's golf videos. I watched a few and couldn't believe how simple he made the golf swing look. I picked up an extra driver from my garage, started trying to swing free and easy and went to the range 2-3 times a week to see if this method would really work. My first time out I shot 97. The second was a 92. The next was an 85. Then, I booked a pair of lessons with Wilson during my vacation. Long story short, Paul Wilson's teaching methods kept me from quitting the game. My handicap is down to an 11, and I am scheduled for two more lessons with him in July so I can confirm somebody who reads this forum is a Wilson disciple. While he can get pretty technical when describing his approach for me it's pretty simple - turn to the top, start the downswing with the lower body and let my arms swing loosely. I expect to break 80 for the first time in my life by the end of the year.               One more thing, which has been noted previously in this thread - if I get off track I immediately go to YouTube, que up a couple of Paul's videos and know exactly what I'm doing wrong. His web site is an incredible resource for me, and I assume it's the same for many others.
    • Muirfield Out of Open Rota, Denies Women Membership
      I was under the impression that Cypress Point had been removed from the "Crosby Clambake" simply because the membership at that course didn't like the idea of the general public trampling on their hallowed turf.  Part of that reasoning might be based simply upon the notion of exclusivity and status; on the other hand, the environment around the course is somewhat fragile and having thousands of golf fans moving around that delicate seaside plant life and sand dunes would not be good for it. You can't tell me that most of the pros who play in the AT&T ProAm don't try and pull whatever strings they have at their disposal to play a round at Cypress during the weekend or weekdays before the AT&T event given the spectacular design and the chance to play a relatively well-preserved MacKenzie design. So even now that Cypress Point has female members I don't believe we can expect that we will ever see it on the AT&T course rota again.
    • Carry-on one Driver golf club in airplane? US and to Eurpoe?
      Thanks, Iacas. I will carry on one Driver with me without  any packaging.  I will have to pass through security check and X-ray scanning. By the way, my flight will be from Toronto Pearson airport to EU, so I hope Canada will have the same regulation as US since they are part of NA (North America). I will let you know if I will get into any trouble.  (I will not do practice swing inside the plane, but I may try while I wait around boarding area. ) Thanks!      
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

  • Blog Entries