• Announcements

    • Welcome to the New Site!   09/30/2015

      Welcome to the brand new TST! Click the title of this announcement to read more about what's new and different here at The Sand Trap!       We're using some new software to power this forum, and while this means some change, it's for the better. However, there will be a few bumps, and one of those may be that you may have a little trouble logging in to your account. So try this: Log in with your existing username and password.If that fails, reset your password here: http://thesandtrap.com/lostpassword/ .If that fails, PM either @mvmac or @iacas and we'll help you out.After that, check out this thread to share any bugs you find along with your likes/dislikes, and check out this thread to see what awesome new features you can use on this site. Finally, once you're on the site, do a few things if you don't mind: Check your account settings. This is where you can clean up your signature.Edit your profile (to possibly include your GAME Golf account). Do this by clicking "Edit Profile" on your name in the top right corner of the site.Add or replace the cover photo on your profile. They're now Facebook-like dimensions. Change your avatar if it looks distorted, too.
    • Failed Logins   10/06/2015

      If you attempt to log in and can not, please email (just one of) erik@thesandtrap.com or mike@thesandtrap.com to have your account password re-set. Thank you.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

New (used?) clubs for a shorty?

3 posts in this topic


So I've just gotten back into playing golf...

My family owns a thrift store (and a bunch of commercial properties, but I digress), and as we were loading the contents of an estate sale, I spied a full set of Titleist DCI 962 irons, a few Big Bertha Titaniums, a nice Ping putter, and an Adams Tight Lies. My cousin wants to pick up golf, and at our store the clubs go for $1 a piece, so he did as I recommended and just took them home.

But now *I* need clubs, it would seem.

I feel pretty comfortable with my old clubs, but... They're for someone 4'9", and I'm 5'5".

Guess I've grown since freshman year of high school. =P

Link for the clubs (though I'm a righty) here. https://www.uskidsgolf.com/shop/lh-ts57v-10-club-stand-set-graphite-steel-red-white-bag

The only other clubs I have are some Silver Scot knockoffs, with extensions on them... Handmedowns from my uncle who's 6'3".

So one set is for someone who's 6 inches shorter than me, and one's for someone who's 10 inches taller than me.

I suppose my question is whether or not I should go for new clubs, and if so, what should I go for?

I think someone 5'5" playing with clubs suggested for someone 4'9" is probably a bad idea... There's no way they could be at the right angle, unless I'm crouching... Which messes up my stance.

Maybe the clubs are why I hit it thin so often?

I guess I feel fine with my old clubs because I'm used to them... So I guess this is a stupid post, and the only way for me to know whether or not I simply feel fine with them because I'm used to them is for me to go and try some properly sized clubs out and see how it goes.

Anyway, beyond that, advice would be helpful.

Right now I'm looking at Callaway Diablo Edge irons...

I've heard they're 2 inches shorter than most irons, which is good for someone my size, and they're also good for people who strike low on the club... Which I have the tendency to do, but now I'm wondering if it's not because my clubs are 6 inches too small. Anyway, they seem reasonably priced, and people seem to like them, also...

Any opinions on them?

Any opinions on good drivers/woods/hybrids for someone my size?

I know getting fitted is the way to go, but I can't really afford to buy fitted clubs, and I doubt anyone wants to fit me for the fun of it.

If it helps, I'm thin, have long arms for my size, and wear ~ 30 x 30 pants.

TL;DR: My old clubs are for someone 6" shorter than I am, is this why I'm hitting the balls thin so often?

What clubs are good for a short guy?


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!


Most off-the-rack men's clubs seem to be aimed at the 5'11" - 6' crowd.  You may have better luck finding used clubs that fit by looking at women's clubs, but you may find the shafts are not stiff enough.  Not all women's clubs are pink or overtly feminine, though some certainly are.  Another good option, if you want to go with used clubs, would be hunting around for a club repair shop and discussing your plans with them, they may be able to help guide you in which shafts to look for to make modification easier.

You didn't indicate any sort of budget constraints, but for new clubs I would suggest visiting a decent fitter for help in getting into clubs that will really work well for you.  It isn't as simple as picking up some clubs and shortening the shafts with a hack saw, though a competent craftsman can indeed shorten them without messing up the dynamics of the club and then adjust the lie angle of the head accordingly.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites


I agree with PirateJim that a fitter is always the best option. Pretty much any golf shop can cut shafts down and if you want the same swing weight that's no problem either, although most of us don't even know for sure what our ideal swing weight is anyway so restoring it may mean nothing, and may even be the opposite our optimum swing weight. Even a different weight of grip can change the swing weight.

FWIW. A person's height is not the best indicator of the proper length of clubs. Wrist to floor (while standing erect) is the most used guide.

IMO. I doubt if your thin shots have much or anything to do with your club lengths unless it's only the shortest clubs in the bag that are a problem. We all have "short" and "long" clubs in our bag and hitting a longer 4 iron well doesn't mean we are going to hit a shorter pitching wedge thin.

That said, My son's wedges feel to me like they came from Toys Are Us because his wrist to floor is so much less than mine (and we are about the same height).

P.S. Adding an extension on your clubs that are too short is another option, and not hard to do.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign up now.
  • Posts

    • Cart bag with less than 14 slots
      By caniac6 · Posted
      I use a three wheeler, and would like to find a cart bag that has a top like a staff bag. Any recommendations? Thanks.
    • Game Golf - Creating a REAL long drive challenge
      By mailman · Posted
      I joined the October Long Drive Challenge and was excited to see that after my first round my average driver distance was about 265 yards so imagine my surprise when my stats came up as 214 yards instead? So I fired off a question to the game golf team and the answer was that the long drive competition takes in to account ALL par4 and 5 drives regardless of the club used, hence why my average was only 214 instead of 265. Anyway game golf people, the question is how do I go about creating an actual long drive challenge that ONLY takes in to account the driver? Because at the moment I can't see a way to actually do that? For those of us that play on tighter courses where you have to actually use some skill to get around (i.e. all your clubs in your bag) we are at an instant disadvantage over those who's courses tend to be longer or more open to start with. Regards Mailman
    • Buying Rental Clubs
      By WUTiger · Posted
      My home course will get last year's models as rental clubs, and then sell them after a couple of years of use (about three years after model's release). Just try them out, and play a round with them, before  you buy. Make sure they are a close fit to what you need. If you have to spend an extra $200 to get them tweaked to your stance and swing, it may not be that good a deal. Also, if the clubs look really beat up, think twice. If the renters abused them a lot, individual clubs may have damage you can't see right away.
    • How would you handle unmarked GUR in a match?
      By rogolf · Posted
      A point to remember - your opponent is not a referee.  He has no right to "decline" your relief.  You have the right to do what you consider proper proceed accordingly.  If your opponent disagrees with your choices, he must file a claim in accordance with 2-5.  
    • How would you handle unmarked GUR in a match?
      By saevel25 · Posted
      A committee does not have to make a tractor rut GUR. It says they would be justified in declaring. It does not say they have to declare it a GUR. It doesn't say it shall be GUR. If it isn't marked as such then the play is still to play the ball as it lies and either of the players depending on how it's played make a claim to the committee. 

      Again, GUR has to be marked GUR. In all decisions they specify that the players bring the situation to the committee to review it. So unless it is marked GUR you can not assume it is GUR.  Like many things in golf. We sometimes think the golf course should consider something GUR. In the end I've played out of bunkers with no sand that on other courses have been marked GUR before. I've played out of ripped up fairway due to it being wet and a golf cart went through there. It's golf. I don't get to decide what GUR is. That is why there is a process to go to the committee to have it reviewed. 

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    No users celebrating today
  • Blog Entries