• Announcements

    • iacas

      Create a Signature!   02/05/2016

      Everyone, go here and edit your signature this week: http://thesandtrap.com/settings/signature/.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Stuartmacgregor

Tiger Woods - Vice Captain?

30 posts in this topic

As a proud Scot, and a European supporter, but a golf fan working at the Ryder Cup, I want to see the best and a great competition, with Tiger's injury making it unlikely that he will get a pick, should he be invited as a vice captain, to give experience in the team room??

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

As a proud Scot, and a European supporter, but a golf fan working at the Ryder Cup, I want to see the best and a great competition, with Tiger's injury making it unlikely that he will get a pick, should he be invited as a vice captain, to give experience in the team room??

Excellent question.  I would say yes.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

As a proud Scot, and a European supporter, but a golf fan working at the Ryder Cup, I want to see the best and a great competition, with Tiger's injury making it unlikely that he will get a pick, should he be invited as a vice captain, to give experience in the team room??

I don't think so.  Steve Stricker has already been chosen specifically to fill that role.  Adding Tiger would really feel like Watson was just throwing him a bone.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

As a proud Scot, and a European supporter, but a golf fan working at the Ryder Cup, I want to see the best and a great competition, with Tiger's injury making it unlikely that he will get a pick, should he be invited as a vice captain, to give experience in the team room??

Great question, but I think he's going to be a Captain's pick for the team. If for no other reason than who he is. The US team is very thin this year & they are likely going to lose irrespective of how makes the team & who is picked, so they might as well have the guy who could possibly summon some old magic, ala Seve.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great question, but I think he's going to be a Captain's pick for the team. If for no other reason than who he is. The US team is very thin this year & they are likely going to lose irrespective of how makes the team & who is picked, so they might as well have the guy who could possibly summon some old magic, ala Seve.

Never happen.  I'll bet the bank on it......and for much the same reason as you think he'll be picked.

The U.S. team is weak this year and almost certain to lose.  The last thing Watson wants is, having lost, people remembering his captaincy for having picked a guy who's played like crap all year, whether healthy or not, just because he's Tiger Woods, when there are dozens of guys playing a LOT better than him who ultimately would have contributed more.

The only way that scenario doesn't play out, is if Tiger is chosen and actually has a very good Ryder Cup.  Given his play of late, does anyone honestly see that happening?

As for summoning some old magic, there's a saying.....  "The race isn't always to the swift, nor the battle to the strong, but that's the way to bet!" ;-)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

Fair enough, but keep in mind he wouldn't have to play him five times. Every RC there's a couple of players who play like twice, or maybe even just once...Sunday singles.

But I think Tiger in best-ball wouldn't be a horrible call. As well, there's still a little time for him to get his game together - he posted a couple rounds in the 60s before the back gave him fits.

I think, honestly, if he is truly healthy by the time the RC comes around, he'll be picked.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Ryder Cup is almost 6 weeks away and it is 3 weeks before Watson announces his selections.

Just 2 weeks ago, Phil was looking pretty ordinary with no Top 10s for the year with people questioning whether he should be on the team. Now, everyone seems happy he made it on points and are expecting good things from him.

A month ago, Rory had no PGA Tour wins and didn't seem to be much of a candidate for POY- now he seems to have a lock on it.

Just over 6 weeks ago, Kaymer looked like the player to beat with a dominating US Open backing up his Player's win.  Now he has finished worse than 55th in 4 of his last 5 events, including 2 missed cuts.

My point is that a lot can change with a players game in a short period of time.  Given the greatness Tiger has shown for so long (including POY last year with 5 wins), I think Watson will take as much time as possible to assess where Tiger is at before making a decision.  True, this will be harder to objectively evaluate unless Tiger tees it up in the Hotel Fitness Championship or the Italian Open, but I still think Watson will try to determine if his game is coming around.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think its a terrific idea.  I would almost always use a captain's pick on Tiger, the lone exception being when he isn't healthy.  So I think bringing him on as a coach is a great idea.  Unless the other players really don't like him.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fair enough, but keep in mind he wouldn't have to play him five times. Every RC there's a couple of players who play like twice, or maybe even just once...Sunday singles.

But I think Tiger in best-ball wouldn't be a horrible call. As well, there's still a little time for him to get his game together - he posted a couple rounds in the 60s before the back gave him fits.

I think, honestly, if he is truly healthy by the time the RC comes around, he'll be picked.

How are you going to define "truly healthy"?  Especially given that he's said that he was "truly healthy" each of his last 2 starts.......  He either wasn't healthy wasn't honest in evaluating his own health, or he was, and played like crap anyway.

Either way, I just don't think Watson is going to pick a current under-performer (to be generous) just because of his name......and I'm not sure "not a horrible call" is the standard by which Watson wants to be remembered.

I think its a terrific idea.  I would almost always use a captain's pick on Tiger, the lone exception being when he isn't healthy.  So I think bringing him on as a coach is a great idea.  Unless the other players really don't like him.

But again, Steve Stricker has already been tapped to fill that exact role......an active player to bridge the gap between the players and the rest of the team leadership.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

Vice captain would be fine, but at this point - for Tiger's own continued good health - I hope he's not picked to play.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

But again, Steve Stricker has already been tapped to fill that exact role......an active player to bridge the gap between the players and the rest of the team leadership.

Sorry, I wasn't aware it was limited to 1.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am pretty sure he is going to be on the team in some form or fashion. Sponsors, and TV ratings rule these types of things.  Tommy Watson may not have much of a choice.

I also think Watson would have a better than even chance to  beat Woods in match play right now, which to me says a lot against Woods being on the team.

A vice captain pick would be work well, if it's possible. I don't know how many vice captains they are allowed to have on a team. I don't think he would be a very good swing coach to any of the other players, but some personal support in other areas would go a long ways.

I think if Woods is picked for the team, and he loses his first round match, Watson will most likely limit the rest the of his play to a very bare minimum.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

Tiger will be in FL come Ryder Cup week. 1st, he will not be golf-healthy, even though he may feel ok. 2nd, David is correct - Watson's not picking him for the reasons cited. 3rd, Watson won't ask him to be an asst captain. He was asked this yesterday and was flummoxed at the question, finally responding with a meek "I don't know." Not something Watson had even considered up til the question was asked. 4th, don't believe Tiger would accept.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

But again, Steve Stricker has already been tapped to fill that exact role......an active player to bridge the gap between the players and the rest of the team leadership.

I think you are correct about this.  When I heard that Stricker was picked for this, I was wondering if Watson was picking him to be a potential fill in as a player if someone like Dufner or Kuchar got to Scotland and woke up one morning with injury issues.

I feel that Stricker will get slotted to play if he performs well during the next 3 weeks- 3 of the 4 Americans who finished better than Stricker at the PGA are on the team and it looks like all the Americans (except DJ and likely Tiger possibly or ZJ) who are ranked ahead of him on the OWGR will be on the team.

I agree that Tiger won't get asked to be a non-playing Vice Captain if Stricker is not picked at a player, but there might be small chance he would be invited in such a role if Stricker is named to the 12 man team with the thinking that Tiger could step in last minute in case of injury.  Overall, there is a good chance Tiger will be in FL for the reasons Gunther cited.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing to consider -

If Tiger was offered a vice captain, non-playing role...would he accept?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing to consider -

If Tiger was offered a vice captain, non-playing role...would he accept?

I don't think so.

If Stricker remains as an assistant, then he'd know that he was just being thrown a bone, because honestly, he doesn't bring anything more than Stricker to the table in that role.  Slightly better chance if Stricker is elevated to playing status as @MEfree even then, he knows that he was the second choice and I don't think that's going to sit well and he likely declines, citing the need to "get healthy".

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

I don't think so.

If Stricker remains as an assistant, then he'd know that he was just being thrown a bone, because honestly, he doesn't bring anything more than Stricker to the table in that role.  Slightly better chance if Stricker is elevated to playing status as @MEfree mentioned, but even then, he knows that he was the second choice and I don't think that's going to sit well and he likely declines, citing the need to "get healthy".

And let's be honest. It's Tiger. Not the most endearing guy to other pros. How effective could he be in a Co-Captain role?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And let's be honest. It's Tiger. Not the most endearing guy to other pros. How effective could he be in a Co-Captain role?

True dat...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • How do I organize a charity tournament to be a raging success?
      26 and a stroke? Holy smokes. Very sorry to hear that.  I have no idea how to organize a tournament but I have played in my share. The best ones are scrambles where you can organize your own team. The outcome has rarely ever mattered to us as long as we were well fed. Find a local restaurant (usually a bbq place) that wants to help you out and give a discount for advertising and spend your money there. Everyone will love to come for a good meal. Some nice prizes and maybe a raffle with some local companies offering you something if you are able to convince them it is worth it to give something to the cause.  Another thing I have seen work well is a silent auction at the end with donated items. I donated airline miles of which I have tons and 100,000 miles went for $205. Free gift for me and the cause got $205. 
    • How to eliminate blowup holes
      Haha - I get a couple of reputation points for a post and then go and have a blow up hole. Good drive, left myself 145 in down hill (8i), aimed #deadcenter, pulled 2 shots 25 yards left out of bounds, made 9 (+5) in a 9 hole round of (+11). A better way to avoid blow up holes - play stableford!
    • Donald Trump for president?
      Come on now, that's a bit uncalled for in Bernies case.  His political ideals might be way left, but he is at least honest and virtuous.
    • Jack or Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?
      I'll have to examine your other post closer. That's a good point to consider about the expansion to Continental Europe. Largely explains the poor showing of UK & Ireland in the 60's with many top tier European players not eligible. But considering the 200 million U.S. population base to 63 million in the U.K. & Ireland at the time, the latter did surprisingly well if population base was all that matters. IMO an established competitive golfing culture matters in producing elite players too. Those same European players excluded from Ryder Cup were always eligible for the Majors. The Ryder Cup is also a limited field event. It concentrates the 12 top players of the European Tour. From what I've read, depth of field is still stronger for the 'typical' PGA event, though some non-major Euro events are now stronger than some of the 'minor' PGA events. That is a significant change in Euro competitiveness from the 60's. To some extent that 30% drop sounds like it could be due to simply more international players occupying slots in the fields. If the period you mention covers when majors started to use OWGR for automatic qualification that has some not insignificant inherent issues in terms of strength of field. Having a guaranteed start rather than having to qualify would certainly make for an easier decision to travel to the event. But I'm not arguing against the policy decision facilitating international competition with a little points boost just trying to point out that field strength may not have been as weak in Jack's day as you seem to think. Compared to his peers, which is really the only thing I think you can do without speculative nuance I agree there's no question he's the best golfer. I'm really just arguing that standouts of their caliber (so many more wins so many more majors) than typical players among already elite fields are so rare, that I expect they both represent near the achievable human pinnacle in golf talent, which I don't think really differs within a few generations. The nuances of comparison across eras is interesting to me so I'll debate relative points, but I'm against arguments undervaluing Jack's achievements against 'weak fields'. They both faced very stiff competition.   I'm not dissing Jack. I think his achievements are amazing. I also think the same of Tiger's record. IMO winning percentage per start in the Majors is a very significant stat and Tiger has that in his favor (they are both top 10 and within ~ 2% of each other's number). That number is not the official one for Jack though, I truncated his Major starts to end at age 47, which I think is a reasonable cutoff for competitiveness. If Tiger competes as long as Jack did his major win % (up to age 47) might stay about the same, increase, or decrease (more likely), but he certainly won't match the 18 Majors if he doesn't get like 22+ more major starts between now and age 47.
    • Wedges, Bounce, and Ground Conditions
      Typically more bounce (or a "healthy" amount of bounce) helps in any condition.  
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. glinks
      glinks
      (43 years old)
  • Blog Entries