Re: Scorecard: Golf Statistics Software (Mac/Windows)
Originally Posted by ChappyEight
Thanks for pointing me to the manual but this is one of the reasons I don't want to make the definition part of this discussion - the piece you reference is a best practice suggestion.
Originally Posted by Scorecard User Guide
Basically that part of the guide makes us both right, the author (Erik I assume) states that they do not count this stat except under certain scores but that it is still a valid stat outside that context.
So let's try again - to remove the problem that seems to be obfuscating the real question - different scenario:
* Hit tee shot in fairway on par 4 hole leaving 125 yards
* Hit 125 approach to fringe of the green against the first cut (I guess this is the collar of the green?) 30 feet from the hole
* Hit putter from fringe to 3 feet
* Hole out from three feet
Now the $.02 question - which of the following is true:
A.) You just two putt from 30 feet
B.) You just got Up and Down with a 1 putt from 3 feet
C.) Neither A or B - A fairway - one putt - NO GIR - with no other stat recorded