or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › Rory McIlroy is overrated...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Rory McIlroy is overrated... - Page 6

post #91 of 284

Let's hope Rory he isn't like Paddy Harrigton.  The guy wins 3 majors and then changes his swing.  Dumbass.

post #92 of 284

I don't know how you can say he is overrated. Maybe you didn't just watch him dominate the U.S. Open or lead the Masters by 4 strokes after 54 holes?  Sure he couldn't close the door on the Masters like Tiger did in some of his early majors but Rory doesn't have the cocky arrogance of Tiger, I don't think he was raised that way but he will get better at closing... as he just showed.

 

 In 7/10 majors as a pro he was top 20, 5 of those are top 10 and 1 of them is now a win and its only going to get better in the foreseeable future. In Tiger's first 10 majors as a pro he went 8/10 top 20s 5 of them being top 10 and 1 win, kind of similar. Maybe he isn't better than Tiger and Tiger did better outside of majors during the start of his career, but it is still early.

post #93 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by BunkerBuster View Post

Rory has class. Something Tiger Woods has never had.



You sound very bitter.  You must have been dating the Perkins waitress Tiger played hide the salami with...

 

post #94 of 284

For one thing, he just blew away the field at a US Open. Though it wasn't the toughest set up due to the midwest rain, but still, to win by that much, its insane. 2nd, he has one of the greatest swings in recent history. I think he has a better swing than tiger had when Tiger first came out. Now he's gotten his putting down with Stockon, and he has a good short game. I think he has the tools to win 5-7 more majors, and win 2-3 tourniments a year. He might not be that fiery as tiger was, but the kid walks with confidence, he didn't back down to the pressure after the Masters. I think he's primed to start being in the top 5 of the world for the next decade. I don't think anyone will be tiger, hell even now, Tiger isn't jack. I doubt Tiger will beat jacks record in major wins.

post #95 of 284

I have this feeling that if Rory had been American, after this victory we would not talk about him being overrated but instead about him being the new golf legend...

post #96 of 284

My prediction is Rory Mcilroy will be the next Rory Mcilroy.

 

He won't get close to Jack's record. That may not ever be broken because fields are so deep now. That's just common sense.

post #97 of 284

I don't see how you can say he's overrated at this point; he just became the youngest winner of the US Open since Bobby Jones 88 years ago and could have won the previous 3 as well. Maybe  by overrated you meant having far-reaching expectations for his career? But, given what he's already accomplished at this point in his career, it's almost impossible to overrate him. 

post #98 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by Elvisliveson View Post

I don't see how you can say he's overrated at this point; he just became the youngest winner of the US Open since Bobby Jones 88 years ago and could have won the previous 3 as well. Maybe  by overrated you meant having far-reaching expectations for his career? But, given what he's already accomplished at this point in his career, it's almost impossible to overrate him. 



Not sure if you noticed, but this thread was actually started in 2010 and ressurected after this win.

 

post #99 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by shades9323 View Post





Not sure if you noticed, but this thread was actually started in 2010 and ressurected after this win.

 


True.  I'm sure even Jack had a few detractors in 1961.  It's nearly impossible to project a player's legacy at the onset of one's career.  Resurrect this thread in 2015 to check in on his Majors win total - let's see if his trending towards Jack's 6 Majors win total at the 5-year mark.  a2_wink.gif

 

post #100 of 284


If they ever had a rule where you had a play a balanced schedule, a lot of player's records would look different.
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kieran123 View Post

My prediction is Rory Mcilroy will be the next Rory Mcilroy.

 

He won't get close to Jack's record. That may not ever be broken because fields are so deep now. That's just common sense.



 

post #101 of 284

As long as he doesn't change his swing, or his attitude, I'm predicting him winning 7 or 8. But any number higher than 5 would be great considering the incredible young talent that is overflowing in the world of golf.

post #102 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigbertha19 View Post

So many optimistic sports bloggers out there are saying he's filling Tiger's shoes...take www.seatgeek.com/blog/mcilroy-us-open-champion for one (check out the hilarious picture of Rory)--the "McIlroy Era" seems a bit premature.  Most of these 'bandwagoners' don't actually know anything about golf. Sure, the kid has a beautiful swing and there's something about the confidence he has on the course. Still, remember how he blew up at the masters. He's not consistent enough yet to be the kind of dominating golfer Tiger has been. Doesn't mean I wouldn't love to see it, though! 



Not everyone can be Jack or Seve or Tiger and win out of the gate (well almost out of the gate). Some guys like Watson, Faldo, Price, etc lose a couple in spectacular fashion before they hit their stride. Not saying Rory's going to win as many majors as Faldo or Watson, but at this point we can say he's proven wrong anyone who made a direct comparison between McIlroy and Fowler - for now anyway.

 

post #103 of 284

I think after this win, and the way in which he won, he now Smells blood....

 

post #104 of 284

I thought Rory turned pro in 2007 (thus making the 5-year mark next year)?
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by NI4NI View Post




True.  I'm sure even Jack had a few detractors in 1961.  It's nearly impossible to project a player's legacy at the onset of one's career.  Resurrect this thread in 2015 to check in on his Majors win total - let's see if his trending towards Jack's 6 Majors win total at the 5-year mark.  a2_wink.gif

 



 

post #105 of 284

Seems he keeps the ball out of the fairway and into the rough a lot. Works for him though.

post #106 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by BunkerBuster View Post

Seems he keeps the ball out of the fairway and into the rough a lot. Works for him though.



Are you any relation to Hennie Bogan?

 

post #107 of 284

Quote:

Originally Posted by BunkerBuster View Post

Seems he keeps the ball out of the fairway and into the rough a lot. Works for him though.



He hit 64% fairways this week (ranked tied for 26th) according to the US Open website which admittedly isn't great but also isn't awful, at an average of 310 yards. Only 6 players who made the cut (Garrigus, Woodland, Johnson, Quiros, Bubba and Westwood) averaged further. I think when you hit it that far and leave yourself a wedge at the green, whether you're coming out of rough or the fairway, you stand a good chance. All these stats speak for themselves. 83% FIR for the week. That is obscene iron play over 72 holes.

post #108 of 284

As a lifetime Ohioan, I guess we in the Midwest just Annexed the Mid-Atlantic subregion of the East Coast. Awesome! Crab Cakes for everybody!

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by saevel25 View Post

For one thing, he just blew away the field at a US Open. Though it wasn't the toughest set up due to the midwest rain...

 

 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Tour Talk
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › Rory McIlroy is overrated...