or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › Phil Mickelson Tending the Flag
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Phil Mickelson Tending the Flag

post #1 of 42
Thread Starter 

Man it was good to watch phil playing good golf again.  He's just an exciting player to watch, I mean who else has their caddy tend the flag while he is hitting a 72 yard approach shot that needs to go in to get into a playoff.  Then he stuffs it and it actually looked like it could have had a chance.   Certainly a fun weekend of golf! Can't wait to watch phil this season. 

post #2 of 42

Faldo made a great point about Phil he said when Phil is just letting loose on every swing he seems to hit it better off tee then when he tries to control it. I was kind of disappointed when he hit the lay up on 18 but if Phil is laying up there must have been no way he could have hit a decent shot to the green. I agree having bones tend the flag was great and the fact he came close to making it was awesome.

post #3 of 42
I loved that approach from Phil, it's what makes him Phil. Wasn't too far from dropping either.
post #4 of 42

If he would have made that it would have been like Babe Ruth calling his shot.

post #5 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aquaguru View Post

If he would have made that it would have been like Babe Ruth calling his shot.



Agreed!  Very fun to watch regardless.

post #6 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aquaguru View Post

If he would have made that it would have been like Babe Ruth calling his shot.



 I read somewhere that actually never happened. Ruth was pointing at the pitcher. I do know that Owen Nolan (rumoured to be a huge jerk btw) did call his shot in an NHL All Star game that was being played in his home rink, which means nothing.

 

Anyway, I think the fact Phil chose holing out a wedge from the fairway, over going for the green in two with a hybrid, says a lot about high handicappers insistence that a hybrid is a "rescue club". If only I could convince my fellow hackers to think about getting back to the fairway first, then the hero shot second (if at all), rounds would be so much quicker.

post #7 of 42

I don't get why he layed up before Watson even putted for birdie.

 

 

The chances of hitting the green from 230 is much higher than putting the ball in the cup from 70 in my opinion. So what if you put it in the drink, at least you took the shot.

post #8 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by CassinoNorth View Post

I don't get why he layed up before Watson even putted for birdie.

 

 

The chances of hitting the green from 230 is much higher than putting the ball in the cup from 70 in my opinion. So what if you put it in the drink, at least you took the shot.


Read Mickelson's interview on pgatour.com (or tsn.ca - it's easy to find). Phil's not one to play for positioning (second shmecond), so if he thought the layup/wedge was the best chance at eagle, then it was.
 

post #9 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by sean_miller View Post


Read Mickelson's interview on pgatour.com (or tsn.ca - it's easy to find). Phil's not one to play for positioning (second shmecond), so if he thought the layup/wedge was the best chance at eagle, then it was.
 



Surprisingly I agree with Sean sunglasses.gif.  Knowing the way Phil is, if he thought he had a slightly better chance at making eagle going for it, he certainly would have.  Still awesome to watch.

post #10 of 42


 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Quinn07 View Post



Quote:
Originally Posted by sean_miller View Post


Read Mickelson's interview on pgatour.com (or tsn.ca - it's easy to find). Phil's not one to play for positioning (second shmecond), so if he thought the layup/wedge was the best chance at eagle, then it was.
 



Surprisingly I agree with Sean sunglasses.gif.  Knowing the way Phil is, if he thought he had a slightly better chance at making eagle going for it, he certainly would have. 

With due respect, guys, do you actually believe in what you are writing??? That someone ACTUALLY believes that he has a better chance to sink a 72 yds wedge than a potential 30-footer putt or a 50-footer chip?
 

post #11 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ignorant View Post

With due respect, guys, do you actually believe in what you are writing??? That someone ACTUALLY believes that he has a better chance to sink a 72 yds wedge than a potential 30-footer putt or a 50-footer chip?
 

It's not just the putt, it's the approach shot and putt combo. He was faced with two choices:

1) a) Hit the green, b) sink the 50-foot putt
2) a) Lay up, b) Sink the 70-yard pitch

He knew that 2.a was a given, so he was comparing the two shots against the one shot. Apparently he figured he had as good a chance at the pitch as he did at the green-hit+putt combo.
post #12 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ignorant View Post


 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Quinn07 View Post



Quote:
Originally Posted by sean_miller View Post


Read Mickelson's interview on pgatour.com (or tsn.ca - it's easy to find). Phil's not one to play for positioning (second shmecond), so if he thought the layup/wedge was the best chance at eagle, then it was.
 



Surprisingly I agree with Sean sunglasses.gif.  Knowing the way Phil is, if he thought he had a slightly better chance at making eagle going for it, he certainly would have. 

With due respect, guys, do you actually believe in what you are writing??? That someone ACTUALLY believes that he has a better chance to sink a 72 yds wedge than a potential 30-footer putt or a 50-footer chip?
 



Are you suggesting he lied in his interview or that you know Phil's game better than Phil does?

post #13 of 42

I was there on the 18th green bleachers!  that was entertaining!  my first ever pga tournament that I've seen live!  

post #14 of 42


Quote:

Originally Posted by B-Con View Post

It's not just the putt, it's the approach shot and putt combo. He was faced with two choices:

1) a) Hit the green, b) sink the 50-foot putt
2) a) Lay up, b) Sink the 70-yard pitch

He knew that 2.a was a given, so he was comparing the two shots against the one shot. Apparently he figured he had as good a chance at the pitch as he did at the green-hit+putt combo.


Indeed. In each scenario you need to multiply the probablities of both shots to get the total probability of the scenario.
 

post #15 of 42

As well as Phil knows his own game it doesn't affect the objective probabilities.  I agree that Phil believed he had a better chance at eagle with layup and a 72 yd lob wedge, but he was wrong. Credit to his skills that he hit it as close as he did.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by sean_miller View Post

Are you suggesting he lied in his interview or that you know Phil's game better than Phil does?

post #16 of 42

That's a fairly easy thing to say say considering he didn't hole out.  I guess we'll never know for sure, but Vegas and Watson had stellar approaches in 2, from much closer to the green, didn't they!?!

 

 

 

Quote:

Originally Posted by max power View Post

As well as Phil knows his own game it doesn't affect the objective probabilities.  I agree that Phil believed he had a better chance at eagle with layup and a 72 yd lob wedge, but he was wrong. Credit to his skills that he hit it as close as he did.

post #17 of 42

Agreed.

 

It probably had a lot to do with his great approach shot on 17, where he hit the perfect spot on the ridge - pin high - to roll the ball within 3 feet.  Dialed in after a shot like that, he probably felt he had a legitimate chance to make it from 70 yds out.  And he came pretty close.... 

 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by max power View Post


As well as Phil knows his own game it doesn't affect the objective probabilities.  I agree that Phil believed he had a better chance at eagle with layup and a 72 yd lob wedge, but he was wrong. Credit to his skills that he hit it as close as he did.

 
post #18 of 42

I watched it but forget...Had Bubba sunk his putt for birdie yet when Phil laid up? 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Tour Talk
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › Phil Mickelson Tending the Flag