Quote:
Originally Posted by
jshots 
I do think I still would prefer to hit my short less than 5 footers a little harder, depending on the severity of the break. I could be wrong of course, but I think that on some shorter putts, and possibly even some longer putts, could it be beneficial to hit it a little bit harder to take some of the break out even though you are shrinking the cup size. As you hit the ball harder there would be a relationship between speed and cup size, as well as speed and amount of break. The more break in the putt the harder it is going to be to read and as speed increases, break decreases, cup size decreases. Slower speed means more break and bigger cup, maybe there is a certain distance and/or amount of break that you gain more by taking out the break, and a certain distance where you gain more by increasing the cup size.
The thing is you still aim at a specific point. The hole is round - it's not like a ball breaking more has a smaller cup because it's curving more.
Case in point: a three-foot putt that is played at point A or point B.
The "jam it in" guy aims at point A, the edge of the cup, and it should break two inches into the middle of the cup.
The "coast it in" guy aims at point B, three inches outside the edge of the cup, but plays it to roll about six inches past the hole if he misses. He needs the putt to break five inches.
Both of these players are aiming at a precise point that's not any wider than the other player.
The thing is, player A is putting to a cup that's about 1.4 inches in size, while player B is putting to a cup 3.8 inches wide.
Player A can have some combination of misreading and mis-striking his putt +/- 0.7 inches. Player B can combine misreading or mis-striking his putt +/- 1.9 inches. That's nearly 3x as much room for error!
Do you know how many putts outside of two feet I've begun playing outside of the hole? Almost all of them! (Admittedly, I play greens that are 10 or 11.) And you know what? The hole begins to look huge when you just start seeing the ball diving in time and time and time again. With AimPoint I'm NOT going to misread the amount of break very much, so I have a good portion of the +/- 1.9 inches to miss my line and still make the putt.
When the ball starts lipping out the hole size gets smaller and smaller. When the ball keeps diving in even if you pull the ball almost two inches... it gets larger and larger.
Just sayin'. :-)
Update:
