I guess some people missed the title that said "Affordable".....
While Caledonia is without a doubt one of the best courses I've ever played, it's not one that I (nor most people) could play every weekend at over $100 a round. I can walk on Aberdeen and play for under $40 with $25 replays anytime I get the urge. It was one of the better "under $50" courses that I've played down there. I don't like Waterway Hills, don't like Man O' War and didn't like most of the courses that are built in sub-divisions for that price. I go to play out of town to enjoy the scenery, not look at houses the entire round.
My most enjoyable rounds have been at Caledonia, Thistle, World Tour, Wild Wing and Aberdeen. I also enjoyed TPC, although it was more because of the wildlife than the golf. Thieving fox squirrels and crows, along with the occasional gator on the tee box kept things interesting.
If we want to talk about favorite courses in the area, I'd have to put Caledonia and Thistle as two of my favorite tracks. The only time I didn't enjoy Thistle was when it was cart path only after heavy rains. I wish they'd have just let me walk that day, it would have been a lot less walking and a lot more enjoyable.