I never read ANY posts AFTER the 1st page of this thread. Just because my picks has the time stamp after the summary, I can see your point and understand your angst. But I honestly feel like Rose is going to win and just happened to like -5, and if I wanted to increase my chances trust me...I wouldn't have picked the same score as a previous poster(s).
If Justin Rose wins at -5, the poster that picks him first at -5 is the winner. But this contest does have a second place