or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Rules of Golf › How do you deal with the 'Gimme' players?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How do you deal with the 'Gimme' players? - Page 3

post #37 of 159

I have no issues with gimmies. However, a gimmie is a putt that you would have to try to miss. 6" or less. 10" is not a gimmie...I've seen many of those missed before. IK Kim anyone? lol

post #38 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dave2512 View Post
 

I takes seconds to putt out a sub 12" putt. Not much more than it takes to pick it up.

 

In theory I agree with you, but in practice I find it doesn't always work that way.  A Saturday morning foursome.  Everyone is on the green at once.  You putt first and hit your 30-footer 12 inches past the hole.  Your options:

1. Pick it up--it's good.

2. Try to putt it without trampling on someone else's line.  More often than not you're taking an awkward sideways one-legged stance, or you hit it backhanded.  When you miss it you feel like a complete ass because you tried to get cute.

3. Mark it and wait your turn.  Move your mark out of someone else's line.  Move it back....

 

Options 2 and 3 can really slow down the group, especially when one or two players in the foursome are doing this on 18 holes.

 

I understand that Option 1 is "cheating", but that's how I'm playing it on my typical Saturday morning round when we're just out enjoying the morning and playing golf.  If I'm playing in league or a tournament, I putt everything (and yes I've missed 1-footers in these situations).  If I'm playing skins or match, it's the opponent's option.  But for 75% of my rounds, which are casual rounds played on busy Saturday and Sunday mornings, I'm taking Option 1.

post #39 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slice of Life View Post
 

I have no issues with gimmies. However, a gimmie is a putt that you would have to try to miss. 6" or less. 10" is not a gimmie...I've seen many of those missed before. IK Kim anyone? lol

 

But that is not how most of the gimmee giving part of the golf world view it.  Most seem to think that in the leather means the length between the putter head and the grip, when traditionally it meant the length of the (leather) grip.

post #40 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by turtleback View Post
 

 

But that is not how most of the gimmee giving part of the golf world view it.  Most seem to think that in the leather means the length between the putter head and the grip, when traditionally it meant the length of the (leather) grip.

 

Yeah, I hear you, I just disagree with the general definition. For me, if someone wants to hit my putt back to me that I left 2" from the cup, sure...I'm making that putt 100% of the time. 

 

Even if I only miss a 1' putt 2% of the time, to me...it's not a gimmie.

post #41 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ernest Jones View Post


It pisses them off because they don't want to face up to the fact that there scores and handicaps are BS. When you insist on putting out they feel a little pressured to putt out as well and seeing as they never putt anything under 3' they know damn well that they're probably going to miss and maybe not get the come backer either. b2_tongue.gif

 

On the NFCn blog, we would call this a "truthbomb!"

post #42 of 159

I'll usually putt out even if someone says "that's good" or "pick it up". I've yet to miss one they tell me to do that on either, but that's not the point. It takes me just as long to tap it in and grab it from the hole as it does to grab it pretty much. Now the ones they knock back at me.. well I suppose I could walk over and put it back down but I just tell them I like to putt out and they'll typically let my ball alone the rest of the round.

post #43 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by k-troop View Post
 

 

In theory I agree with you, but in practice I find it doesn't always work that way.  A Saturday morning foursome.  Everyone is on the green at once.  You putt first and hit your 30-footer 12 inches past the hole.  Your options:

1. Pick it up--it's good.

2. Try to putt it without trampling on someone else's line.  More often than not you're taking an awkward sideways one-legged stance, or you hit it backhanded.  When you miss it you feel like a complete ass because you tried to get cute.

3. Mark it and wait your turn.  Move your mark out of someone else's line.  Move it back....

 

Options 2 and 3 can really slow down the group, especially when one or two players in the foursome are doing this on 18 holes.

 

I understand that Option 1 is "cheating", but that's how I'm playing it on my typical Saturday morning round when we're just out enjoying the morning and playing golf.  If I'm playing in league or a tournament, I putt everything (and yes I've missed 1-footers in these situations).  If I'm playing skins or match, it's the opponent's option.  But for 75% of my rounds, which are casual rounds played on busy Saturday and Sunday mornings, I'm taking Option 1.

 

I suppose all of that is possible but my experience is there isn't much to sweeping in a 12" putt. I can't remember the last time I marked one that wasn't something tricky, like above the hole on a day the greenskeeper decides to torture everyone. Most of the time it's nothing more than a one handed move.

post #44 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dave2512 View Post
 

 

I suppose all of that is possible but my experience is there isn't much to sweeping in a 12" putt. I can't remember the last time I marked one that wasn't something tricky, like above the hole on a day the greenskeeper decides to torture everyone. Most of the time it's nothing more than a one handed move.

 

Speaking of the gimmes, anyone else notice it's easier to make those shorter putts one handed? Like playing solo you grab the flag out and hold it while you putt out? I rarely miss anything under 3 foot that way but I'll miss a few if I lay the flag down and putt out normally.

post #45 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeremie Boop View Post
 

 

Speaking of the gimmes, anyone else notice it's easier to make those shorter putts one handed? Like playing solo you grab the flag out and hold it while you putt out? I rarely miss anything under 3 foot that way but I'll miss a few if I lay the flag down and putt out normally.

 

Yeah, because you don't rely on both hands. Only one needs to do its job. Add another in and you lose stability, but if one wants to do something different than the other, you lip out a 2 footer.

 

Troll hand. lol

post #46 of 159
Mark you ball and putt out. I don't think telling people that you want to putt out is a big deal. Just don't make it one.
post #47 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by MissouriHack View Post

Mark you ball and putt out. 

 

There are plenty of opportunities for playing partners to knock your ball back to you before you can mark, if they are so inclined.  The key is to either let people know on the first tee how you play the game, or let them know after the first time they knock is back to you that you like to putt everything out.

post #48 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by bplewis24 View Post

There are plenty of opportunities for playing partners to knock your ball back to you before you can mark, if they are so inclined.  The key is to either let people know on the first tee how you play the game, or let them know after the first time they knock is back to you that you like to putt everything out.

I think the Key is too not touch another persons ball on the putting surface. Have you ever had someone do that too you?
post #49 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by MissouriHack View Post

I think the Key is too not touch another persons ball on the putting surface.

So is that Six Simple Keys now? This is getting confusing, and now Erik is going to have to retool his entire marketing campaign.
post #50 of 159

I say "I just love the sound of it going in the cup."
No one has ever insisted after I say that.

post #51 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by k-troop View Post

So is that Six Simple Keys now? This is getting confusing, and now Erik is going to have to retool his entire marketing campaign.

Retooling, yea thats the other key. You could also have a golf shirt made that says." Real men don't stop till they hit bottom."
post #52 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by GillPier View Post

No problem putting out those 10", unless when you look up into the fairway, you see the next group waiting...then its not ok. You're not on tour, and if you want the practice from 10" out, there's more than likely a practice green readily available

It's always Ok to play by the rules.

Slow play and playing by the rules are two different things. It's absurd to complain that about someone following the rules. Everyone is out there playing golf.

Besides, its not the guy that insists on putting out that slows up play, it's the guy that takes way too long to hit that 1 footer.
post #53 of 159
Quote:
Originally Posted by dsc123 View Post


It's always Ok to play by the rules.

Slow play and playing by the rules are two different things. It's absurd to complain that about someone following the rules. Everyone is out there playing golf.

Besides, its not the guy that insists on putting out that slows up play, it's the guy that takes way too long to hit that 1 footer.

 

I agree. Seriously trying to say that you should just bypass the rules if there are people behind you?

 

"Well, I missed the green, but it'll probably be quicker if I just drop a ball on the green and take the gimme...easy birdie!" 

post #54 of 159

Agree 100%.  If you are holding up the group behind you, it is more likely you are just slow player regardless of whether you putt out or not.  You need to play faster.  One putt will not be the cause of you being slow.  Or it could be someone in your group, not necessarily you, that is slowing everyone else down.

 

Quote:

Originally Posted by dsc123 View Post


It's always Ok to play by the rules.

Slow play and playing by the rules are two different things. It's absurd to complain that about someone following the rules. Everyone is out there playing golf.

Besides, its not the guy that insists on putting out that slows up play, it's the guy that takes way too long to hit that 1 footer.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Rules of Golf
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Rules of Golf › How do you deal with the 'Gimme' players?