Jump to content
IGNORED

Hole 18 - Finish with a Par 5, 4 or 3?


Blitz28179
Note: This thread is 3780 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

0  

1 member has voted

  1. 1. Which do you prefer as a closing hole?

    • Par 5
      41
    • Par 4
      19
    • Par 3
      6


Recommended Posts

I think a par 5 adds alot more excitement to the end of a round, especially the final round,Most PGA courses have the 18 hole as the toughest handicap hole ,which is usually a par 4.IMO I think making hole 18 the easiest hole would make for more exciting finishes.Its like watching football, nobody likes a low scoring defensive game,everybody wants to see a shootout, because its more exciting.Let me hear your thoughts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I think a par 5 adds alot more excitement to the end of a round, especially the final round,Most PGA courses have the 18 hole as the toughest handicap hole ,which is usually a par 4.IMO I think making hole 18 the easiest hole would make for more exciting finishes.Its like watching football, nobody likes a low scoring defensive game,everybody wants to see a shootout, because its more exciting.Let me hear your thoughts.

I didn't vote in the poll because I think the answer (for me) is entirely dependent on the situation.  There is no "right" answer.  For example, if the leader of the tournament is a few groups ahead of all of his chasers, then, yeah, I want a par 5 that is reachable to give them all good chances to catch him.  On the other hand, if the leader is in the last group, then I want him to have to work for his victory.  I don't want him to have an anti-climactic cake-walk on the last hole.

Its like watching football, nobody likes a low scoring defensive game,everybody wants to see a shootout, because its more exciting.

This is false. Less people may like low-scoring games, but not "nobody."  Assuming we're talking about great defensive play, as opposed to just shitty offensive play (overthrown balls, dropped passes, fumbles, that kinda garbage) then count me in the group that loves watching a great defensive battle.  I like crazy high scoring games too ... but defensive games can be beautiful to watch as well. :)

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Most PGA courses have the 18 hole as the toughest handicap hole ,which is usually a par 4

I disagree................every golf course is different.  Whether its one of many hometown courses you play on the weekend, or played on the PGA tour.  In some events, the final holes are birdie/eagle fests.........in others, it's "HANG ON" for dear life........

This is a good thing....

I didn't vote because I don't care......I don't like par3s finishing holes, but that's besides the point.  I equally enjoy courses with a difficult finish and one that can be attacked. I've belonged to courses that had both.....it doesn't matter.  Each is good in it's own way.

What's in Paul's Bag:
- Callaway Big Bertha Alpha Driver
- Big Bertha Alpha 815 3-wood
- Callaway Razr Fit 5-wood
- Callaway Big Bertha 4-5 Rescue Clubs
-- Mizuno Mx-25 six iron-gap wedge
- Mizuno Mp-T4 56degree SW
- Mizuno Mp-T11 60degree SW
- Putter- Ping Cadence Ketsch

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I wouldn't want all courses to be the same, but I do like playing par 5s as the closing hole at both the Keystone Ranch and Keystone River courses.

18 at the Ranch has over 500 yards of water on the left side, to a pretty narrow (but deep) green with bunkers on the right.  It is not an easy hole, but can offer up a variety of scores sorta like 18 at Pebble Beach.  I like that.

:mizuno: MP-52 5-PW, :cobra: King Snake 4 i 
:tmade: R11 Driver, 3 W & 5 W, :vokey: 52, 56 & 60 wedges
:seemore: putter

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Moderator
I think a par 5 adds alot more excitement to the end of a round, especially the final round,Most PGA courses have the 18 hole as the toughest handicap hole ,which is usually a par 4.IMO I think making hole 18 the easiest hole would make for more exciting finishes.Its like watching football, nobody likes a low scoring defensive game,everybody wants to see a shootout, because its more exciting.Let me hear your thoughts.

I think ending on a par 5 would make it less exciting.  If a player has a multiple shot lead, making a par on a par 5 is much easier than par on 18 at Carnoustie, Oak Hill, Oakmont, Doral, Riviera.  If it's a par 5 that's reachable for most of the field, like 18 at TPC Boston, then it's basically just a long par 4, I think the hole averages about 4.5.  To make that hole more exciting they actually made the green smaller by 50%, essentially making it more difficult, not easier.

Mike McLoughlin

Check out my friends on Evolvr!
Follow The Sand Trap on Twitter!  and on Facebook
Golf Terminology -  Analyzr  -  My FacebookTwitter and Instagram 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Our *toughest* holes is #9 - a few years ago, the club tried to flip the 9s to make that #18 - to leave a lasting impression with guests and hopefully turn them into members.

It also made sense since it would force everyone to drive by the clubhouse going from 9 to 10.

But the old guys went nuts (they bitch when it is their turn to start on the back during our double tee time weekend times)

It is the only non par 3 hole with a forced carry with trees blocking the shorter carry on the left -  a slicer may not carry or may hit it into the second pond on the right.

It is often my last hole during weekend rounds and even dropped me from first to out of the $$$ in a tourney.

Follow me on twitter

Chris, although my friends call me Mr.L

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Its like watching football, nobody likes a low scoring defensive game,everybody wants to see a shootout,

Well I guess I'm "nobody" (along with a whole lot of people that live around here).

I'll also take a 1 to 0 game in baseball with two great pitchers any day over a 9 to 8 home run fest with pitchers that should be back in Triple A.

And I'll take a US Open, where par is likely to win, over some tournaments where -15 doesn't even get a top 5.

I do acknowledge that most fans (especially casual fans) want to see points, runs, and birdies and don't appreciate defense as much.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Doesn't matter as long as it's a great hole. The 18th at The Experience at Koele (on Lanai) is a 180-yard par-3 to a narrow green protected by water front and left and bunkers right. It's a tough hole, but players of all abilities can hit a great (or terrible) shot there making for an exciting finish to your round. I've seen more par-5 finishers that are duds than great holes, but finishing with a birdie is awesome--so I guess that's good because you either get a great finishing hole or an easy birdie at the end. Really hard par-4s are probably what most designers want. I guess that's cool too. I guess I just really like golf so it's all good.

Kevin

Titleist 910 D3 9.5* with ahina 72 X flex
Titleist 910F 13.5* with ahina 72 X flex
Adams Idea A12 Pro hybrid 18*; 23* with RIP S flex
Titleist 712 AP2 4-9 iron with KBS C-Taper, S+ flex
Titleist Vokey SM wedges 48*, 52*, 58*
Odyssey White Hot 2-ball mallet, center shaft, 34"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Doesn't matter as long as it's a great hole. The 18th at The Experience at Koele (on Lanai) is a 180-yard par-3 to a narrow green protected by water front and left and bunkers right. It's a tough hole, but players of all abilities can hit a great (or terrible) shot there making for an exciting finish to your round. I've seen more par-5 finishers that are duds than great holes, but finishing with a birdie is awesome--so I guess that's good because you either get a great finishing hole or an easy birdie at the end.

Really hard par-4s are probably what most designers want. I guess that's cool too.

I guess I just really like golf so it's all good.

Agree.  Great doesn't necessarily mean hard either.

In David's bag....

Driver: Titleist 910 D-3;  9.5* Diamana Kai'li
3-Wood: Titleist 910F;  15* Diamana Kai'li
Hybrids: Titleist 910H 19* and 21* Diamana Kai'li
Irons: Titleist 695cb 5-Pw

Wedges: Scratch 51-11 TNC grind, Vokey SM-5's;  56-14 F grind and 60-11 K grind
Putter: Scotty Cameron Kombi S
Ball: ProV1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

It should be a hole where you need to hit a decent shot to make par, and where a great shot gives you a birdie chance. You shouldn't need to hit a perfect shot or make a crazy up and down to make par, but it should be punishing to the player who chokes and rewarding to the one who hits the clutch shot. I voted for a par 3 because par 4s can be really similar and it's rare to have a really good one at the last. I'd rather not play a hole just like #13 again. I like how some links courses handle this notion; there are severe booby traps as well as lots of open space; you can either go for broke or try to force it into a safe spot in a desperate attempt to keep a lead.

It's largely irrelevant in stroke play what the 18th is like. You should in theory be able to play the holes in any order and still shoot the same score. In match play though, you play the hole differently based on your opponent and you may need to be really aggressive on the hard holes sometimes. Take the par 4 18th at my club, which I usually play against my brother. He's gotten better but for a while I would play the previous 2 holes conservatively because I knew he's hitting it into the water 100% if he hits first, and I can hit as little as a 5 iron or as much as a driver and still be in the 160 or less range. If he does hit the fairway, I can hit it to where I'm hitting 5 clubs less than him from a better angle because the fairway is so open. Lots of options, but it doesn't offer me a lot of difference in flavor because it's an easy hole for 2 draws. I wish the back tees would make it like a 240 yard water carry and a par 5, it would still be easy enough for me but it would intimidate my opponents more.

One club has a par 5, but it's a terrible hole. It's short, doglegs twice really sharply, and basically punishes long hitters. There are no real angles to play, you have to hit 200, 180, 100ish. There's another that's like an airport runway, huge and straight and long. That one is right after a great par 3 so it pales in comparison, but it is a decent road hole on a casual round because you can let it rip, even though it isn't a great eagle opportunity unless you're really good.

Another club nearby has a very straightforward mid iron length par 3, though it's an executive course. Good for a casual round because it feels satisfying to walk away from a birdie chance on the final hole, but I'd say it's a course for hackers and they try to throw them a bone because guys who can't hit the ball well can get picked apart on 10-15. Any match would be decided on maybe #16 IMO unless one guy benefitted from getting a lot of strokes.

In My Bag:

Adams Super LS 9.5˚ driver, Aldila Phenom NL 65TX
Adams Super LS 15˚ fairway, Kusala black 72x
Adams Super LS 18˚ fairway, Aldila Rip'd NV 75TX
Adams Idea pro VST hybrid, 21˚, RIP Alpha 105x
Adams DHY 24˚, RIP Alpha 89x
5-PW Maltby TE irons, KBS C taper X, soft stepped once 130g
Mizuno T4, 54.9 KBS Wedge X
Mizuno R12 60.5, black nickel, KBS Wedge X
Odyssey Metal X #1 putter 
Bridgestone E5, Adidas samba bag, True Linkswear Stealth
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I think ending on a par 5 would make it less exciting.  If a player has a multiple shot lead, making a par on a par 5 is much easier than par on 18 at Carnoustie, Oak Hill, Oakmont, Doral, Riviera.  If it's a par 5 that's reachable for most of the field, like 18 at TPC Boston, then it's basically just a long par 4, I think the hole averages about 4.5.  To make that hole more exciting they actually made the green smaller by 50%, essentially making it more difficult, not easier.

I really think it depends on if there is a player in the last group that has an outright lead or not.

Say you have a hole that averages just over 4 and is a par 4- if two guys are tied, they will likely stay tied.  If one has a 1 shot lead, he will probably keep that lead.  If there is a club house leader, he will probably end up the winner.

With a hole that averages 4.5 and is a par 4- you are more likely to see guys make different scores than each other so two guys who are tied going into 18 may not end up tied.  It will be harder to protect a 1 shot lead and a club house leader is very likely to win.

With a hole that averages 4.5 and is a par 5- you are more likely to see guys make different scores than each other so two guys who are tied going into 18 may not end up tied.  It will be very easy to protect a 1 shot lead, but a much easier to make up a 1 shot deficit to tie a club house leader with a closing birdie (or possibly even an eagle).

For me, regardless of par, it is probably best to have a hole where 3, 4, 5 & 6 are all likely possibilities as opposed to a hole where most of the guys make 4.  While 13 & 15 at Augusta are not closing holes, I do think they are part of the reason that the final 9 at the Masters tends to be so exciting as some guys make 3 or 4 while others make 5 or 6.

:mizuno: MP-52 5-PW, :cobra: King Snake 4 i 
:tmade: R11 Driver, 3 W & 5 W, :vokey: 52, 56 & 60 wedges
:seemore: putter

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I love it when the 18th offers the possibility of a train wreck. Winged Foot in the 2006 Open had one of the more memorable finishes in US Open history. 18 at Carnoustie is another.

Bill M

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I love it when the 18th offers the possibility of a train wreck. Winged Foot in the 2006 Open had one of the more memorable finishes in US Open history. 18 at Carnoustie is another.

Not sure that 18 at Winged Foot would have been as much of a train wreck for any other player in the history of the game not named Mickelson.  "I'm such an idiot!"

Kevin

Titleist 910 D3 9.5* with ahina 72 X flex
Titleist 910F 13.5* with ahina 72 X flex
Adams Idea A12 Pro hybrid 18*; 23* with RIP S flex
Titleist 712 AP2 4-9 iron with KBS C-Taper, S+ flex
Titleist Vokey SM wedges 48*, 52*, 58*
Odyssey White Hot 2-ball mallet, center shaft, 34"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Not sure that 18 at Winged Foot would have been as much of a train wreck for any other player in the history of the game not named Mickelson.  "I'm such an idiot!"


Remember that Colin Montgomery also self-destructed and cost himself a major.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Quote:

Originally Posted by phan52

I love it when the 18th offers the possibility of a train wreck. Winged Foot in the 2006 Open had one of the more memorable finishes in US Open history. 18 at Carnoustie is another.

Originally Posted by k-troop

Not sure that 18 at Winged Foot would have been as much of a train wreck for any other player in the history of the game not named Mickelson.  "I'm such an idiot!"

But it wasn't just Mckelson. There were a number of players who messed up on that hole, Monty in particular. Ogilvie had to make a great up and down for the the par that was the ultimate winner.

Carnoustie is probably the ultimate train-wreck finishing hole, though.

Bill M

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

With the tournament on the line, you want a finishing hole that tests the nerve. Not a birdie hole.  Ones on the PGA tour that immediately come to mind:

Riviera

TPC Sawgrass

Augusta

Doral

All are very tough par 4's. And if you've got a one stroke lead, you better have your nerves under control.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Have the easiest par 3 hole as the 18th hole and let us go home on a positive note :dance: .

My current home course starts easy, and ends up hard on both front 9s.   It's very frustrating to hum along and then finish with 3 toughest holes at the end and screw up the whole round.

RiCK

(Play it again, Sam)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Note: This thread is 3780 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-15%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope.
  • Posts

    • I did read the fine print tonight. It said replace with “similar features & function”.  8 yeas ago my purchase had features that today are available on the lower end models and the current version of my model has more “bells & whistles” than what I got 8 years ago.  So I am thinking they honored the agreement and I can’t argue the offer. since getting a credit for the full purchase price all I am really out over the past 8 years was the cost of the extended warranty, which was less than a low end  treadmill would have cost me. now the question is which model to replace with.  I’ll stay with Nordic Track or I forfeit the $1,463 credit so I will get Nordic Track.  And they honored the warranty and were not hard to work with which is a plus.
    • Generally speaking, extended warranties are a terrible deal and should almost always be avoided. They are a huge profit center for the companies that offer them, which should tell you almost everything you need to know about how much value most consumers get when purchasing them.  This is correct, and the old adage applies - only buy insurance when you can't afford the loss. This usually doesn't apply to most consumer goods.  To your second question, no I don't believe the offer is fair. They are replacing it, but it is not being replaced at "no cost to you". Since the amount being disputed (over $500) is non-trivial, I would probably push the issue. Don't waste your time on the phone with a customer service agent or a supervisor. They have probably given you all they have the authority to do. Rather, I would look at the terms of your agreement and specifically legal disputes. The odds are you probably agreed to binding arbitration in the event of a dispute. The agreement will outline what steps need to be followed, but it will probably look something like this.  1. Mail the Nordic Track legal department outlining your dispute and indicate you are not satisfied with the resolution offered.  2. Open up a case with the AAA (American Arbitration Association), along with the required documentation. 3. Wait about 4-5 weeks for a case to be opened - at which point someone from Nordic Track's legal department will offer to give you the new model at no cost to you.  They certainly don't want to spend the time and energy to fight you over $500. 4. Enjoy your new Nordic Track at no cost to you. I recently entered binding arbitration against a fairly large and well known company that screwed me over and refused to make it right. In my demand letter, I made a pretty sizeable request that included compensation for my time and frustration. Once it hit their legal department, they cut me a check - no questions asked. It was far cheaper to settle with me than to send their legal team to defend them in the arbitration.
    • I never thought of looking at it on multiple purchases like you said.  Yes, the extended may help me on 1 or 2 items but not the other 5 or 6.
    • Day 84 - Forgot to post yesterday, but I did some more chipping/pitching.    Back/neck were feeling better today, so I did a much overdue Stack session. 
    • Wordle 1,013 4/6 ⬛⬛🟩🟨⬛ 🟩⬛🟩⬛🟨 🟩🟩🟩⬛⬛ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...