or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The 19th Hole › Sports › MLB instant replay
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

MLB instant replay

post #1 of 3
Thread Starter 

I was against this for years, but slowly came around to the concept after umpires continued to butcher one important call after another that could easily be corrected through a review. Now an expanded version has arrived and I like it a lot!


I just watched the Cubs-Pirates opener on ESPN, which included an overturned call on a pickoff play in the top of the 10th. The Cubs' Emilio Bonifacio was clearly out, but was originally ruled safe. Umpires have long ruled in favor of the runner on extremely close pick-off plays because it's one of those instances where they had to be certain they were right before throwing up the thumb. The default call was always "safe," and a lot of guys remained on base who shouldn't have.


The process was completed quickly – it took much less time than your average NFL challenge. I really think it's going to be a great thing for the game.


What say you people?

post #2 of 3
I agree. There was another challenge earlier in that game on a play at first. Took a bit longer than it should, but they got the call right and it should only get faster as they work out the kinks.

I think the current technology may become a limiting factor pretty soon though. The frame rate of the camera they used was pretty low, so I can pretty easily imagine similar scenarios where they just can't tell whether the ball or runner got there first. They'll probably set up a few dedicated slow-motion cameras within a few years.
post #3 of 3

I like instant replay as long as it doesn't take all day.   During the NCAA tournament they took 5 minutes in the Michigan / Tennessee game and it distracted from the game.  It should be easy in baseball.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Sports
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The 19th Hole › Sports › MLB instant replay