or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › Michelle Wie... Love Her or Hate her?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Michelle Wie... Love Her or Hate her?

Poll Results: Michelle Wie... Love Her or Hate her?

 
  • 100% (37)
    Love her
  • 0% (0)
    Hate her
37 Total Votes  
post #1 of 59
Thread Starter 

Since Michelle is the talk of the golf world right now, I'd like to hear your comments on which side of the fence you fall.  Are you jumping on the bandwagon and cheering for her because of her recent good play, or perhaps you've been a longtime fan, or do you cringe every time they show her hitting a shot or talking to a reporter?

Personally, I am NOT a fan and haven't been since she turned pro.  Before that I didn't really feel one way or the other, but in 2004 she said she would consider turning pro if she got what she wanted, which was "Tiger money".  Wie said "If someone comes up with $100 million, or a big briefcase--someone opens it up and shows me all the money".  THAT was what did it for me...it irritated me that she was arrogant enough to think she deserved huge endorsement deals that rivaled what Tiger had despite an amateur career that wasn't even a fraction of what he accomplished before he turned pro.  After that, EVERYTHING she did was irritating, plus it was retro-active...stuff from before that had already happened got "grandfathered" in!  Things like:

  • Playing in all those PGA Tour events when she hadn't accomplished anything on the LPGA Tour (yeah, I know her parents and agent were likely behind this, but still...)
  • The number of caddies she's gone through
  • Withdrawing from Annika's tournament when she was 14 over thru 16 to avoid the Rule of 88
  • Getting an exemption into the 2004 U.S. Women's Open

And the list goes on.  Ok guys, sound off...do you love her or hate her?  I don't know if you can be in the middle!

post #2 of 59

Love.

post #3 of 59

Can I say just really like her a lot? O:)

 

Okay. . . love. :roll: 

post #4 of 59

I don't really hate any pro golfers. Some I may not root for and others I may not care how they do, but no hatred. As for Michelle, I think she's changed, and will continue to pull for her and Lexi to win.

post #5 of 59
Michelle who? J/k

Glad I am not held accountable for all the things I did in my 20's ...

I think she is growing as person and golfer ... Look forward to seeing her compete some more ...

The golf sort of has a way of weeding out the non-performers ...
post #6 of 59
Neither.

Just another woman golfer, though more talented than most.
post #7 of 59

Glad to see her finally start to live up to some of the hype she had as a young teenager, immense pressure was put upon her way too young and it obviously hurt her early on, I love seeing her doing well now because having her play well is nearly as important to golf as having Tiger back. Oh yeah, Love.

post #8 of 59

She's adorable and finally matured into a professional.  I really enjoy watching her play.  

post #9 of 59
Quote:
Originally Posted by boogielicious View Post
 

She's adorable and finally matured into a professional.  I really enjoy watching her play.  


+1  couldn't have said it better

post #10 of 59
One of my favorite players to watch on either tour.
post #11 of 59

She's a good golfer. Enough for me. I try not to hold what people said 10 years ago against them. Especially if said person was a teenager at the time.
 

post #12 of 59
Tota
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zeph View Post

She's a good golfer. Enough for me. I try not to hold what people said 10 years ago against them. Especially if said person was a teenager at the time.

 
Totally agree. She was 14 at the time.

I also don't think what she said was arrogant; more kidding around than anything.
post #13 of 59
Love her and her legs. She's awesome.
post #14 of 59

Love watching her play, really happy for her recent success, hope that she can continue as the LPGA needs all the help it can get, and unlike you, @1badbadger, I realize a few facts…

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by 1badbadger View Post
 

Before that I didn't really feel one way or the other, but in 2004 she said she would consider turning pro if she got what she wanted, which was "Tiger money".  Wie said "If someone comes up with $100 million, or a big briefcase--someone opens it up and shows me all the money".  THAT was what did it for me...it irritated me that she was arrogant enough to think she deserved huge endorsement deals that rivaled what Tiger had despite an amateur career that wasn't even a fraction of what he accomplished before he turned pro.

 

You do realize she was 14 years old at the time, right? Let's go back and take a look at the things you said when you were 14… I'm pretty sure you said some awfully stupid things then too. You were - and she was - a child.

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by 1badbadger View Post
 

After that, EVERYTHING she did was irritating, plus it was retro-active...stuff from before that had already happened got "grandfathered" in!  Things like:

  • Playing in all those PGA Tour events when she hadn't accomplished anything on the LPGA Tour (yeah, I know her parents and agent were likely behind this, but still...)

 

Things that happened afterward were grandfathered in? Her first PGA Tour event was in 2004. She nearly made the cut and was the talk of the town. Sponsors often use their invitations on local players.

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by 1badbadger View Post
 
  • The number of caddies she's gone through

 

Do… you expect the caddies to stick around for a player who is in college and playing a partial schedule, or do you expect them to seek employment on a week-to-week basis?

 

Wie (or her parents/agents) fired a few (I almost said "a couple of" because it's really not that many) caddies, true, but she's only had nine in ten years of playing, which is about the average for a regular PGA Tour player who plays a full schedule, so…

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by 1badbadger View Post
 
  • Withdrawing from Annika's tournament when she was 14 over thru 16 to avoid the Rule of 88

 

She was also injured at the time, and was routinely seen wearing bandages and getting treatment on her wrists.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by 1badbadger View Post
 
  • Getting an exemption into the 2004 U.S. Women's Open

 

So… the decision of the USGA reflects poorly on Michelle Wie how?

 

BTW, she finished T13 and was tied for the low amateur in that event. So…

 


 

Don't let a few facts get in the way of your narrative…

 

I've been critical of the mistakes she's made, but I've chalked them up to the mistakes made by a girl who hadn't even graduated from high school yet.

 

Seriously, what has she really done in the last five years except win four times (including a major) and, you know, graduate from freaking Stanford? (The water hazard penalty, for which I was quite bothered, is barely in this window).

post #15 of 59

1bad,

 

I hate to tell you this, but Wie doesn't care what you think of her. I, personally, don't care what you think of her either.

post #16 of 59

Wie playing well is good for the LPGA, and golf in general. Anything, or person that is good for golf brings more amateurs to the game. The more amateurs playing the game of golf also means lower green fees for me. Myself I like to watch good golf being played. It matters little which pro  is playing that good golf . Except for Tommy Watson that is. :-)

post #17 of 59
I like her because she has not not quit the games although so many people take her as a laughing stock ...( before 2014 ) .

Her table top putting etc.
post #18 of 59
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by WUTiger View Post
 

1bad,

 

I hate to tell you this, but Wie doesn't care what you think of her. I, personally, don't care what you think of her either.

 

I appreciate most of the comments guys...thanks for weighing in.  This is simply something to spark some conversation or even a spirited debate.  No need to get personal...if you don't care about me or what I think feel free to not respond.  If you have some thoughts on the topic, by all means join in!

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Tour Talk
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › Michelle Wie... Love Her or Hate her?