or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › What Happens First: Rory Completes Slam or Tiger Wins 15th Major?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What Happens First: Rory Completes Slam or Tiger Wins 15th Major?

Poll Results: Which Happens First?

 
  • 60% (47)
    Rory wins the Masters to complete the career grand slam
  • 39% (31)
    Tiger Woods wins his 15th major championship
78 Total Votes  
post #1 of 171
Thread Starter 

So which happens first....Rory completes the career Grand Slam or Tiger gets his 15th major?

post #2 of 171
Quote:
Originally Posted by atb5079 View Post

So which happens first....Rory completes the career Grand Slam or Tiger gets his 15th major?
Tiger. As Jamo said earlier, McIlroy is streaky, he could miss the cut at Augusta for the next three years and I wouldn't be shocked.
post #3 of 171

Good question.

 

Rory's won 3 out of 14 majors and was T-8 at the Masters this year. Augusta does fit his game and ball flight. I'm going with Rory.

post #4 of 171

Tiger. More opportunities. As noted above, Rory can be streaky at times, good or bad.

post #5 of 171
That's a good question. If you'd asked me on Thursday night, I would have said Tiger. If you ask me in two weeks, I might say Tiger. Today, three hours after Rory won, it's tough not to go with McIlroy.

Quote:
Originally Posted by RJH999 View Post

Tiger. As Jamo said earlier, McIlroy is streaky, he could miss the cut at Augusta for the next three years and I wouldn't be shocked.

I think that was @iacas but I'd gladly take credit. a3_biggrin.gif
post #6 of 171
I went with Rory but it's a helluva tough call. Tiger has 4x the opportunities (if he stays healthy) but Rory's game is made for Augusta.

I'm already second guessing my pick.
post #7 of 171

I'm going with Rory. He's been close at Augusta before and has shown he can win majors.

 

If Tiger stays healthy, he can of course come out roaring next year, but I'll believe it when I see it.

post #8 of 171
Very tough call! I'm sure both will happen, but which first!!! I'd like to think mcilroy will! But opportunity wise, tiger has the advantage at 4 to 1, and if tiger has an advantage, you couldn't bet against him! So tiger!
However, I reckon mcilroy will eventually be the highest earner in golf! Surpassing tiger, It's a bold statement, but with youth, ability, and nike on his side, plus likeability, something which tiger lacks, the future seems very bright for Rory!
post #9 of 171
I voted for Tiger. He's got the numbers on his side.

Since his last major victory, he's had 9 top 10 finishes out of 19 events played, including 2 last year. In that same span, Rory has played in 6 Masters, with 1 top 10 finish.

There are 4 opportunities a year for Tiger vs 1 for Rory.

The PGA Championship is coming up, which means Tiger has a chance to win this contest before Rory even gets to tee the ball at Augusta.
post #10 of 171

That is a great debatable question. Off hand, I would have to say Woods would win his 15th major. Then again, what if part of his problem at the Open was a physical  problem? What if his back issue does not allow him to play "Tiger Golf" for another year or so?  

 

On the other hand, what's to keep Mcllroy from winning the up coming PGAC, which would give him an even greater drive for winning his missing green jacket next year? 

 

My guess is that Woods is not in tournament golf shape yet, and won't be for a few more months. I am assuming he left the tournament with no new, or lingering injuries. For 18 holes he was in good shape. The following 54 holes he played were riddled with mistakes that I think were brought on by fatigue. Both mental, and physical.  

 

Although I think Mcllroy will eventually win his own grand slam, if he does not win the next Masters, Woods has the better chance at his 15th major. If Woods plays 8 more years, he has 32 chances at a major, where Mcllroy is looking at only 8 Masters during the same period of time. Lots of plausible arguments for both players in this debate, but the percentages favor Woods.  

post #11 of 171
The odds are with Tiger, but I still say Rory.....
post #12 of 171

I don't think Tiger will win another major, so I'm going with Rory.

post #13 of 171

I will go with Rory and think he will win the Masters next year or the year after.   He's got a ton of talent and that high ball flight, great putter,, and he is gaining experience and he knows he is quite capable of winning the Masters.   He can be streaky and that could be a problem, but I will go with Rory.  If he is on, he could run away with the Masters.  He needs to get more consistent and that might improve as he gains more experience and confidence.   I think Tiger may have some more majors in him, but they are probably not going to come as easy for him like they did before.  Tiger's physical problems are a concern too. 

post #14 of 171

Rory's Dad put down a few pounds on Rory over Tiger for this bet. ;-)  I'll take Tiger though due to the number of chances.

post #15 of 171

At this point, it's looking like John Daly is just as likely to win another major as Tiger is...

post #16 of 171
Quote:
Originally Posted by tmac20 View Post

I don't think Tiger will win another major, so I'm going with Rory.

I'm the unofficial president of the TST ABTG (Anyone But Tiger Group), but I'll take that bet for as much as you want to lay down.....

...I'd be happy to pay though. a2_wink.gif
post #17 of 171

I say Rory. I think he will do it right off the bat next year. As soon as he holed out on 18 yesterday, that became all he is thinking about. I don't think Tiger will get to 15th until his career is on the wain. I believe it will come in one last hurrah like Jack in 1986.

post #18 of 171
Quote:
Originally Posted by Elvisliveson View Post
 

I say Rory. I think he will do it right off the bat next year. As soon as he holed out on 18 yesterday, that became all he is thinking about. I don't think Tiger will get to 15th until his career is on the wain. I believe it will come in one last hurrah like Jack in 1986.

 

Pretty sure he's still thinking about the PGA this year… :D

 

And $10M for the FedExCup would be nice too…

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Tour Talk
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Tour Talk › What Happens First: Rory Completes Slam or Tiger Wins 15th Major?