How Often Do You Replace… Your Putter?

I have the same Ping My Day putter that I bought about 40 years ago.

I've been thinking about getting a new one, but my first inclination is to work more on my stroke and worry less about the club I'm putting with.

I've had the same putter for 10 years. Was fitted for it when I was 17 and have used it almost exclusively since. I have been through a couple different grip styles with it.

Got my fitted Edel a year or year and a half ago, and I don't foresee ever replacing it.

1st 3 years, I went through 4 - 5 putters, experimented with a few more.   I still have 5 putters at home, and donated the rest.  Since then, I had settled with the current putter and had it for 2.5+ years.  It's the only putter I use now.

I really like the Odyssey Tank Cruiser #7 so I doubt I'll replace it unless it breaks.  I voted 1-2 years because this will be the 2nd year I'm using it.

Sooooo ... you plan on breaking it this year?

Pretty much every year. I lose confidence in my putter after about a year of use.

LOL, no more likely I'd throw it in the lake ala Rory.  With my luck I'd go to break it and I'd end up stabbing myself in the leg with the busted shaft.

My Odyssey Dual Force Rossie I is over 20 years old, I think.

I've had an Edel for 6 years. Did not think I'd need to replace it if fit properly and kept the same stroke, setup, etc. I found out not much later that the guy who fit me was a bit of a charlatan but I had hoped he had done club fitting well. I have fiddled a lot with the putter in terms of weight and counterbalancing over time. Some of it was me, some of it was the fit.

Last weekend, I asked my new Edel fitter, also my instructor, for a formal fitting. We went on the SAM to see what was happening with the old putter - an anser style Rogue - we cleared up some issues and then went to aiming. I was left and right with the putter. He put a E-1 (torque balance) mallet in my hands, and 3x in a row, the laser was at or over the target. We went on the SAM after a couple of reaction drills and worked on the issues. The e-1 closed a bit less than the traditional putter, and I'd found that I did not have much of an arc going back and tended to open the club slightly going back.  We corrected the issues and putts were going center - SAM showed a consistent and technically correct stroke and proper contact. Aiming it was much easier...

So an e-1 is coming...no sightlines, just a dot on top.

What is the torque balance thingie? One can correct the twisting themselves with a traditional putter, it's just that with the torque balanced putter it seems an easier fix. It's an odd look at first, so odd it seems distracting. After taking a demo home for 4 days and practicing with it, the "look" is so plain that it is no longer distracting. I'd say it focuses you more, similar to an anser style without lines. If you can aim it correctly ...

I'm not thrilled about getting a new putter, but I know its aim is true.

Not sure about this one. I went through a few putters fairly quickly before settling on the current one. Had it about two years, and expect it to stick around. I voted 2-4 years.