Hey guys,
About 6 months ago I started playing golf again after almost 10 years where I played maybe once a year (shot in the 80s back around 2002). About 3 months ago I traded in my old game improvement Callaway irons (Big Bertha X-12s that I had for 10+ years) for a player's club (Mizuno MP-58). My thinking was "if I start playing with a harder to hit player's club, it will force me to swing better and improve." I think the jury's still out on that one, but that was my rationale. Anyway...
When I came back to the game hitting my Callaways, it was like I had taken no time off at all with my full swing (short game was another story). I was hitting the same high straight shot I used to hit with an occasional fade and was very happy. Then I switched to the MP-58s and have never really hit them that well. I started hitting this low, weak draw (sometimes a pull-draw) and lost about 10 yards of distance and a ton of accuracy. I also started shanking from time to time, which really undermined my confidence. After a horrible 9 holes this afternoon, I stopped by my local clubfitter to ask him if I thought I should ditch the irons, but he was closed so I went to the driving range to work on my swing...
First few shots were bad. Low draw and a few shanks, nothing long or straight. Then on an impulse I decided to stand
closer to the ball, straighten my spine, and take a steeper and more upright swing.
At first I thought this might make the shanks worst (after all, I'm now standing closer to the ball), but instead I started hitting shot after shot long and straight with an occasional fade, just like I used to do back when I was decent at this game. And no more shanks either.
So sorry for the long post and build up, but here's a question for all the instructors / great golfers out there:
is this a valid fix that I stumbled upon?
It doesn't seem to me that this should fix a shank or a low draw problem, so I'm wondering if this was somehow a fluke? Can standing too far away from the ball and swinging too flat cause a shank and/or a low and weak ball flight (I know a draw can definitely result from a flat swing, but curious about the other stuff)?
Thanks for any input, sorry this post got so long :)