Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?

[stinkerface]

Jack. He seems more fun. Tiger is so intense these days.

[shamsone]

i think the question is will tiger beat jacks most wins and more majors record?

because on paper jack is the better golfer with out seeing them play golf. but these days aren't like the days jack played in so who knows. until tiger beats jacks records i'd say jack is the better player

[TrucknGolf]

Tiger!! FTW

[Rocket]

Tiger no doubt. He won on one leg.

[ANTC]

Tiger changed the world of golf

[Jeffelite]

Both are amazing golfers, but I barely remember Jack. I have to go with Tiger.

[shane4golf]

tiger with out a doubt

[andy]

I measure greatness by two factors. # of majors, and # of wins.

As of now, jack has more. So my vote goes to jack

Although Tiger has surpassed Jack in many "milestones", he has yet to surpass those benchmarks i've just highlighted. With that said, Tiger can get hit by a car tomorrow so until he achieves it, he's second-rate in my book

Andy

[Seven Iron]

Anyone who can win a playoff on a 'bum" knee for a major championship is pretty good I must say.

[Carrsbie]

Saw Tiger go pro at the GMO in Milwaukee in '96.

[dam00n]

Old school rules =)
I really depends on who impressed you when you were young

[Guest]

i have to go with tiger

[the_kid]

It's too early to say Tiger is the greatest... if he keeps up the way he is playing now for another 10 years ..he will beat every golf record easily. Tiger will one day be the greatest just because of his competitiveness.

[jopela]

Too bad jack nicholson is not a choice... I know he can hit a car with a golf club quite well..

[SCSammy]

I'm an old guy who watched Jack in the 70's, so I have to go with him for now. If Tiger keeps his singlemindedness and drive to pass Jack's records I think he'll have a legitimate claim to being called the greatest.

[san-pancho-mex]

I've only been a golfer while Tiger has been playing. Jack sure does have some incredible courses down here in Mexico though. Played San Luis Potosi signature course a couple weeks ago and it was awesome and FREE! I'ts not what you know but who you know.

[TechDude]

Just like a number of others on here, I'm too young to know much about Jack. I grew up more so with Tiger, so I am going to have to go with him.

[Chism]

I think Tiger will eventually surpass all of Jack's records. That said, Jack played with a quarter of the technology available today. Ever tried to hit a persimen driver? Jack could hit one 300 yards straight as an arrow or working it either way.