Jump to content
arduous1

Lessons: How many, How often, How long???

13 posts in this topic Last Reply

Recommended Posts

The title says it all. Assuming I know Where and with who, 30 minutes vs 60 minutes Once a week or more often? How do I know when I've had enough? Goal being go from 36 handicap to less than 18 handicap. Thx, Ard1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to hide this ad? Register for free today!

I am a terrible golfer trying to figure this out as well. This advice from Kandi Comer looks reasonable:

"I encourage all golfers to find a PGA or LPGA Professional, and interview them to find out as much as they can about the professional before they take the lesson.  You would not go to a doctor without finding out information about the doctor.  Golf Professionals are like any other professional and there are good ones and there are bad ones, so do some research on the professional you are interested in taking a lesson from.  When you interview the instructor you want to make sure you feel comfortable with them and that communication goes both ways and not just the professional talking.  Find out about the teaching experience the professional has– how long have they been teaching and is their a specific type of student the professional enjoys teaching more than another?You want to find out about their teaching philosophy.  Are they a method teacher or do they treat each golfer as an individual and work with their body type and what they can physically do with their body? Make sure you speak to golfers that you know that have taken lessons from this professional and get their feedback.

If you are comfortable after the interview set up one lesson and see how it goes.  Does the teacher give you a plan for improvement and a practice schedule? Do they use video or other technology that you feel is beneficial? If you do not have a practice schedule or a plan to improve I feel that is a red flag.  No matter how good the golf professional might be the golfer cannot improve without practicing.  I feel it is the golf professionals responsibility to give you a plan so that you can see the most improvement from your practice.  It is my philosophy that the student should have, at the most, two things to work on while practicing.   Once they accomplish these changes it is time to schedule a follow up lesson."

But, I really have no idea...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

60 vs 30

I take 60 minute lessons, and feel like if they were any shorter, i would get absolutely nothing done. After 60 minutes sometimes i feel like i want more, just to fine tune what i just learned.

As far as how regularly you take lessons, i believe is totally up to you and what you feel you need, and how serious you want to get in a certain time span. I take lessons usually every 2 weeks. sometimes 3 weeks, but never more than that. on occasion i will take a lesson on back to back weekends, if i have a tournament or something coming up, and issues with a certain aspect of my game. 2 week intervals seem to be perfect for what i am striving for, however i believe it changes person to person.

I think i will never finish taking lessons, i am sure the regularity of my lessons will dwindle, but i doubt i will ever stop taking lessons for life. I think a lesson every 2 months or so would be beneficial to my game... hell, even the pros have "coaches" that they see regularly, so why stop. but maybe once you reach your desired handicap and feel comfortable with what you learned you might decide that its time to call the lessons quits.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like the format where the pro watches your swing, makes some changes, then we sit down somewhere and analyze the video, go back and work on the changes some more, maybe one last look at video. This usually takes an hour to an hour and a half. I'm not fond of 1/2 hour lessons because I usually have lots of questions, but I'm an anal, analytical type. If I had my way, usually 2-3 weeks between lessons, but for me, life just gets in the way and frequency is much less than I'd like it to be. The interval imho is when you think you think the changes took or you're not getting it after awhile.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

IMO once a week for 30 minutes is enough.  The key is taking what they teach you and then putting it into your practice sessons.

Im not sure that you can ever reach the point where you have enough.  Theres plenty of pros who work with swing coaches at least once a week and if those guys/gals need the help of a swing coach, then there isnt a point where us mere mortals have had enough.  Id say that if you reach a point where you feel confident and happy with your swing and reach the point where you can self-diagnose it pretty well, then maybe you could back off on the lessons.

Ive always been pretty stubborn about taking lessons but even Im finally going to break down and spend the money to take at least a few lessons a year.  I know that a good teaching pro could fix that little flaws that are in my swing and in a few short lessons could probably make me a much better ballstriker.  I hate to admit it but there it is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in a similar position, though probably closer to 18 than 36 at this point. I've taken some lessons, and I'm currently getting video lessons from Golf Galaxy. So far, these have proven to be the most effective, possibly because of what I learned at earlier lessons. My wife got me the 3 pack of lessons for Christmas. The Golf Galaxy lessons are 30 minutes, and I've been going every other week. For someone at our skill level, I like the 30 minute format, with video. There are so many things to work on, it is easy to lose focus. With 30 minute lesson, you pick one or two areas to concentrate on, then really work them. The video really helps, too. I then have something to take to the driving range for practice. Any longer, and I would worry that I'd have too much to work on during my practice time. So, 30 minutes, no more than once a week. Before going, though, have a goal. For a beginner, maybe start with the basics of good ball striking. With a goal, you know when you are done, at least with that phase. Then, play a bunch, find out what you might need to work on next, and get some more lessons.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by arduous1

The title says it all. Assuming I know

Where and with who,

30 minutes vs 60 minutes

Once a week or more often?

How do I know when I've had enough?

Goal being go from 36 handicap to less than 18 handicap.

Thx,

Ard1


I think how long 30 vs 60 depends on you but, no more than once a week.  I have even heard instructor ask that students do every other week, as it can take that long for something new to become ingrained.  Trust me, you will know when you have had enough!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have taken my first lesson and got a lot out of it.  I just retired and now really have time for golf.  My son bought me 4 lessons from a PGA pro, very well known here in the area.  I have the 2nd session schedule tomorrow, how much time should I allow between the 2nd, 3rd, & 4th lesson.  

I took several weeks between the 1st & 2nd lessons and worked hard on what I was taught. 

Any advice?  I have plenty of time to practice and play now.

Regards, Gary

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote

I took several weeks between the 1st & 2nd lessons and worked hard on what I was taught. 

This is key to taking lessons

I believe a second lesson should not be so close to the first one that you don't have time to fully practice the swing change from the first.   

I've taken lessons during the winter where they were one week apart and I only had one practice session in between.   I got nothing from the lesson because I wasn't able to practice the information from the prior lesson.     I had video and a printout but it's just not the same.  

There does need to be a confirmation of a lesson so that what the instructor was trying to convey is what you are indeed practicing.    I believe a second lesson should be scheduled based upon available practice time.   

Congrats on your recent retirement.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

6 minutes ago, dennyjones said:

This is key to taking lessons

I believe a second lesson should not be so close to the first one that you don't have time to fully practice the swing change from the first.   

I've taken lessons during the winter where they were one week apart and I only had one practice session in between.   I got nothing from the lesson because I wasn't able to practice the information from the prior lesson.     I had video and a printout but it's just not the same.  

There does need to be a confirmation of a lesson so that what the instructor was trying to convey is what you are indeed practicing.    I believe a second lesson should be scheduled based upon available practice time.   

Congrats on your recent retirement.

Appreciate the immediate feedback.  Makes perfect sense to me.  Looking forward to the 2nd session and getting confirmation that what was learned in the 1st session was correct.  Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Gary Payne said:

I have taken my first lesson and got a lot out of it.  I just retired and now really have time for golf.  My son bought me 4 lessons from a PGA pro, very well known here in the area.  I have the 2nd session schedule tomorrow, how much time should I allow between the 2nd, 3rd, & 4th lesson.  

I took several weeks between the 1st & 2nd lessons and worked hard on what I was taught. 

Any advice?  I have plenty of time to practice and play now.

Regards, Gary

 

It really depends on what you're working on and how quickly you pick it up, but in general I'd say about a month between lessons is good. @iacas wrote a good post about this some time ago:

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I have done a good number of activities in my life and have taken a lot of classes/lessons/training in each.

One item that a lot of people overlook is that lessons/training are there to show you what or how to practice/improve.  One does not improve from lessons.  One improves from practicing what is learned from the lessons.

To that end, for golf, I am in the same boat as you (started in the mid-high 30s and looking to get into the teens).  I take a 30 minute lesson about every other week.  But in between those lessons, I practice at least 30 minutes a day, trying to incorporate what was taught, or play at least 9 holes.

In 2 months my handicap has come down about 13 points and trending downward. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

When do you know when you have had enough? Imo, if the lessons are from a quality instructor, that you both are on the same page with, there is no such thing as too much instruction.

As for 60-30 minute instructions, I'd go with more 30 minute instructions. 60 minutes get into the time zone of actual on course instruction with the instructor.

When I was lucky enough to have a very good instructor/club builder, I took one, sometimes two lessons a week, over a several month period. We even played practice rounds together. The majority of my instruction took place during the winter months, during his off season. 

For most golfers, time, and money available for "quality" instruction still dictates how much instruction they can handle.. Key words are "quality", "time", and "money".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2018 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    FlightScope Mevo
    More to come…
  • Posts

    • Yes that is over simplifying it. In most competitions society has made the determination that it is important for women to have equal access to sports competition. To make it fair most sports are divided by gender. Now we have a group of people who don't quite fit that division the way that it was envisioned. If we assume that a male body type tends to provide more speed and strength (true in golf as seen with top and average club head speed) then the effects of testosterone are the key question (as I see it). If you have an XY individual who identifies as a female and had hormone therapy starting before puberty and ask her to compete vs the males she is at a significant disadvantage. Conversely if she did not have hormone therapy until after puberty and adolescence then the muscle growth and bone changes will be consistent with the Male type. Yes subsequent hormone therapy will reduce that effect but once bone and muscle growth occur (in terms of lengths) they do not revert. The inverse is true for a XX who identifies as a male. The corollary is much more akin to "steroids". IT is really complicated by the fact that some XX Females have more strength and speed than some XY males so none of this is certain. Golf has come as close as any sport to having a gender neutral competition but the gener differences due to testosterone still skew the game. Lydia Ko could not keep up with Dustin Johnson over many rounds. His strength and height (golf levers) make it unfair not matter how good her game is, a wedge in hand will beat a 5 iron over time.  
    • "Tiger Woods is without question the most powerful and influential athlete of my time. Michael Jordan is not only 2nd, if it was a golf tournament, he'd be 15 strokes off the lead. " — Colin Cowherd
    • I wouldn't worry about it until you have put in enough time, with the new shaft, to make an honest assessment.  The exact specifications of any club, while interesting to know, are not as important as the clubs performance.  Remember, also, that you didn't switch shafts with the intention of producing the same result...you switched shafts to see what would happen.  Give it some time.
    • Good idea if you get the table start slowly just like you did with Yoga. The muscles have to adapt to the position. Also the blood is rushing to the head and you have to get used to that. So start slow  with just a few minutes then add time as you get used to it.  You also do not have to go all the way upside down. I have been doing Yoga and using the inversion table for over 20 years
    • Hi All. New member here. Ive joined up as I have fallen in love with the game. A while ago I had a friend over from interstate and a group of us went out and played 18 holes. I literally shot 160. It wasnt an enjoyable experience for me - I just wasnt competent enough to fit in and have fun. My friends arent amazing golfers, but I was something else. I woke up hungover the next day with a resolve to improve my game to a level where I can go and have fun with my mates. I lay on the couch watching youtube videos on the basic fundamentals. Six months later I play at least three times a week and hit the driving range at least once a week. I havent had any lessons yet and feel I need some. My goals have changed over this time. Initially it was to just get to a competent level to enjoy playing with my friends. Now it is to shoot in the 40's over nine holes consistently at my local course. I also have a more general goal to be able to play well enough to enjoy playing at golf courses if I go on holiday to overseas golf resorts with friends. I have improved markedly. Sub 50 scores over 9 are regular. My chipping and pitching are easily my strengths. Putting is quite average, irons lukewarm and as for the driver- thats my biggest head wreck. I have days where I can direct it semi straight and others where I cant keep it on the fairway. In fact a general round is a complete roller coaster off the tee. It frustrates me greatly. I move between hitting my driver or alternating with my 3 wood, which i actually hit further, but am also just as prone to shanking not much further past the ladies tee.  Ive played competitive sport my whole life - cricket, AFL, baseball and tennis and have absolutely no desire to ever play competitive golf (ie: tournaments).
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. dmkalan
      dmkalan
      (63 years old)
    2. JarrettLeger
      JarrettLeger
      (26 years old)
    3. Ratherbegolfing83
      Ratherbegolfing83
      (35 years old)
    4. seabreeze77
      seabreeze77
      (59 years old)

×

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...