Since nobody else seems to want to talk about anything other than the guy who finished DFL of those who made the cut, allow me to be the one to congratulate Adam Scott on a solid win!
Rory had a good tournament too, until the wheels fell off halfway through the front 9 on Sunday.
@ncates00, I think all of your points are good but then why would you not apply the same thought process to distance as well? You have elevated, rightfully so, the skill aspect of golf many times so a bit surprised you would want to limit distance. I think it is well established that distance is primarily and overwhelmingly, I might add, a skill.
Rolling back seems to effect only top distance achievers. Doesn't seem fair.
I actually do have an idea, my first putt over the last 15 or 16 rounds averages a little over 22 feet. I know this because I began using @RandallT's strokes gained putting spreadsheet last fall, after converting it (mostly) to work with Excel. That average includes all first putts, whether a result of chipping or pitching or short irons or long iron shots or whatever. It doesn't include the effect of the one or two times I managed to hole a shot from off the green. As @iacassuggests, it doesn't seem like a very meaningful, statistic, as its influenced by a lot of factors.
I didn't say this. I said MOI isn't going to overrule strike or face to path. Strike is king at the end of the day.
Fair enough, but no amount of marketing or technology is going to fix a player's poor striking or face to path issues.
Nonetheless, golf equipment advances are merely a natural progression; it takes place in all markets. My 65 mustang was nice, but it doesn't drive like a new one and wasn't as safe either. But golf club advancements are hardly as potent as what has happened to vehicles.
Another point I would bring up is--well at what point were you satisfied with the level of "being punished" due to mis-hits? This kind of argument leads to pointless line-drawing and notions of nostalgia. Again, you still have to game your ball--I don't care what kind of "jailbreak" technology, cavity backs, and chunky clubs are in your bag. Does it make it a little easier--sure. But golf is still a skill game and one where we want people to come play and enjoy--not to mention speeding up the pace of the game a bit.
I'm for keeping courses shorter and keeping equipment capped where it is. I don't care about "preserving par" or anything like that--par is a useless notion in competition anyway; all that matters is the total score relative to the competition at the end of the day. I don't care if a guy shoots -30 or +3--it's about what did you do relative to the competition.