Jump to content
IGNORED

Are most amateur golfers being mislead on how to swing?


Note: This thread is 4373 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

I asked my instructor about getting the club parallel at the top. He said I shouldn't worry about it since I already do the important things. He mentioned a move that's wide, then narrow, then wide as being desirable. As in, wide on the way back and to the top, then arms getting closer to the body on the way down and through, then getting wider after impact. He mentioned it because he says the "natural" tendency for a lot of high handicappers is to do the opposite. They start out narrow, get wider on the way down, then narrower after impact. It's hard to hit the ball hard that way apparently. He knows more about the swing than I ever will, but he speaks to me on my level. How deep his knowledge or understanding of the swing and what new players need is not important since I'm neither a technical person nor a beginner, but it's nice to know I could get my wife or kids a lessons package and they'd likely be successful.

Mizuno MP600 driver, Cleveland '09 Launcher 3-wood, Callaway FTiz 18 degree hybrid, Cleveland TA1 3-9, Scratch SS8620 47, 53, 58, Cleveland Classic 2 mid-mallet, Bridgestone B330S, Sun Mountain four5.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Replies 305
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Originally Posted by iacas

Yeah, I typically do a google image search on people's usernames and then use an appropriate image.



I wish you wouldn't have posted this.  I just did that same thing and my whole life on the internet flashed before my eyes.  It was disturbing.  Taking the rest of the day off now to contemplate my existence...

[ Equipment ]
R11 9° (Lowered to 8.5°) UST Proforce VTS 7x tipped 1" | 906F2 15° and 18° | 585H 21° | Mizuno MP-67 +1 length TT DG X100 | Vokey 52° Oil Can, Cleveland CG10 2-dot 56° and 60° | TM Rossa Corza Ghost 35.5" | Srixon Z Star XV | Size 14 Footjoy Green Joys | Tour Striker Pro 5, 7, 56 | Swingwing

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by Patrick57

Hi tristanhilton,

my daughter plays off 3 and I know most of you will think she lives on the course. From the age of 8 to 12 she played about 3 times a week and took lessons from me a couple of times a week. From the age of 13 with a handicap of 4.4 she has more or less given up taking lessons with the odd 15 minute correction before a tournament.

She now only plays a couple of weeks of the year just before the club championship and then wins the thing. Last season she won the said stroke play championship with a scratch 75 and 73.

This is only one of my low single figure students. I am of the opinion that many more golfers can get to a single figure handicap but not with a knowledge of geometry or physics but with a more natural approach to learning the game.

Sincerely yours

Patrick



I am new to golf but not new to sports..    In nearly every sport, your skill level will improve with practice.   I remember a kid on our basketball team that technically speaking had horrible shot form.   Nobody else could emulate his shot form and hit the backboard, let alone make baskets, yet this kid consistently made baskets from all over the floor.   The reason was, he practiced A LOT!   Your daughter practiced golf in one fashion or another 5 days a week for 4 years.   Thus, while I will draw no inferences into your skill as a teacher, I am saying that her success is more likely a testament to her dedication to practice than to anything you may or may not have taught her...

Razr Fit Xtreme 9.5* Matrix Black Tie shaft, Diablo Octane 3 wood 15*, Razr X Hybrid 21*, Razr X 4-SW, Forged Dark Chrome 60* lob wedge, Hex Chrome & Hex Black ball

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by sean_miller

I asked my instructor about getting the club parallel at the top. He said I shouldn't worry about it since I already do the important things.

Sounds like pretty sound advice to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by teamroper60

I am new to golf but not new to sports..    In nearly every sport, your skill level will improve with practice.   I remember a kid on our basketball team that technically speaking had horrible shot form.   Nobody else could emulate his shot form and hit the backboard, let alone make baskets, yet this kid consistently made baskets from all over the floor.   The reason was, he practiced A LOT!   Your daughter practiced golf in one fashion or another 5 days a week for 4 years.   Thus, while I will draw no inferences into your skill as a teacher, I am saying that her success is more likely a testament to her dedication to practice than to anything you may or may not have taught her...

Hey, I agree, she's the talent, I am only the coach. I think I was only mentioning her because a reply came that my coaching was only for a certain level. You're only as good as the woman you are teaching. LoL

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by sean_miller

I asked my instructor about getting the club parallel at the top. He said I shouldn't worry about it since I already do the important things. He mentioned a move that's wide, then narrow, then wide as being desirable. As in, wide on the way back and to the top, then arms getting closer to the body on the way down and through, then getting wider after impact. He mentioned it because he says the "natural" tendency for a lot of high handicappers is to do the opposite. They start out narrow, get wider on the way down, then narrower after impact. It's hard to hit the ball hard that way apparently. He knows more about the swing than I ever will, but he speaks to me on my level. How deep his knowledge or understanding of the swing and what new players need is not important since I'm neither a technical person nor a beginner, but it's nice to know I could get my wife or kids a lessons package and they'd likely be successful.





Originally Posted by Patrick57

Sounds like pretty sound advice to me.



Not to put words in anyone's mouth, but I think the message that was meant to be conveyed pertained to what is "natural" and what isn't based on the experience of his instructor.  You advocate a "natural" swing method.  A fellow instructor found that a "natural" swing method doesn't work.  To each their own.

:titleist: :scotty_cameron:
915D3 / 712 AP2 / SC Mont 1.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by Tomboys

Quote:

Originally Posted by sean_miller

I asked my instructor about getting the club parallel at the top. He said I shouldn't worry about it since I already do the important things. He mentioned a move that's wide, then narrow, then wide as being desirable. As in, wide on the way back and to the top, then arms getting closer to the body on the way down and through, then getting wider after impact. He mentioned it because he says the "natural" tendency for a lot of high handicappers is to do the opposite. They start out narrow, get wider on the way down, then narrower after impact. It's hard to hit the ball hard that way apparently. He knows more about the swing than I ever will, but he speaks to me on my level. How deep his knowledge or understanding of the swing and what new players need is not important since I'm neither a technical person nor a beginner, but it's nice to know I could get my wife or kids a lessons package and they'd likely be successful.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Patrick57

Sounds like pretty sound advice to me.

Not to put words in anyone's mouth, but I think the message that was meant to be conveyed pertained to what is "natural" and what isn't based on the experience of his instructor.  You advocate a "natural" swing method.  A fellow instructor found that a "natural" swing method doesn't work.  To each their own.


I meant both. It took a lot of hard work to get a natural swing.

Mizuno MP600 driver, Cleveland '09 Launcher 3-wood, Callaway FTiz 18 degree hybrid, Cleveland TA1 3-9, Scratch SS8620 47, 53, 58, Cleveland Classic 2 mid-mallet, Bridgestone B330S, Sun Mountain four5.

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Quote:
Originally Posted by Patrick57 View Post

Quote:
You also wrote,
Incidentally what makes your instruction/book any different to teachers like Shawn Clement and what makes you think people will pay attention to what you're saying if your demonstration is more of a "do as I say, not as I do"?

Did I offer this book to you?


Not at all; I just noticed you offered it out to a member and it intrigued me as to whether there's a big difference between what Shawn teaches and your own philosophies as they seem quite similar on paper.

SWING DNA
Speed [77] Tempo [5] ToeDown [5] KickAngle [6] Release [5] Mizuno JPX EZ 10.5° - Fujikura Orochi Black Eye (with Harrison ShotMaker) Mizuno JPX EZ 3W/3H - Fujikura Orochi Black Eye Mizuno JPX 850 Forged 4i-PW - True Temper XP 115 S300 Mizuno MP R-12 50.06/54.09/58.10 - Dynamic Gold Wedge Flex Mizuno MP A305 [:-P]

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by MiniBlueDragon

Not at all; I just noticed you offered it out to a member and it intrigued me as to whether there's a big difference between what Shawn teaches and your own philosophies as they seem quite similar on paper.


As I have no idea what Shawn teaches, it is impossible for me to make comparisons. Sorry

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by Patrick57

Unfortunately you haven't understood my OP or you didn't even bother to read it. You're so far off the mark, I feel as if I am reading about someone else.



Wait, so your answer is taking umbrage and continuing to not actually answer anything that was raised?  At least you're consistent.  I noted in my original response that yes, feeling the restriction at the top of the backswing, in a position that lets you get to impact consistently, with reasonable power, is obviously necessary.  ALL you've offered is a drill to get students to consider the feeling of restriction, and then platitudes like "swing naturally" and how we shouldn't try to imitate or really even learn from pros' swings.

I'm a naturally good athlete who taught myself to play.  In my "natural" swing I absolutely felt the restriction at the top.  In fact, it's something I consciously thought about and learned how to feel and all that.  I "naturally" felt very loaded, and could absolutely murder the ball (especially with the driver, with the huge club face and ball up off the ground) if I really went after it and happened to hit it reasonably straight that time.  Unfortunately, my "natural" swing had a bunch of elements that made it almost impossible to learn to play consistently, and I plateaued as an 80s player who's only broken 80 twice, both times with both putting and the punch-slice recovery from a bad drive absolutely on fire, despite my (what I would consider) solidly above average natural athletic ability and very consistent practice over 4 years.

I recently took my first lesson where the instructor pointed out what was making my game inconsistent and showed me a bunch of "pro swing" positions I should aim for to let me become more consistent, one of which had to do with how to feel and in what position to achieve restriction at the top of the swing.  After two weeks of practice I've played one full and one 9 hole round.  I shot 78 and 39, by far the best 27 consecutive holes I've ever played.  It still doesn't feel "natural" yet, and the restriction doesn't feel more or less, just achieved in a different way in a different position.  So much for your magic platitudes...

Matt

Mid-Weight Heavy Putter
Cleveland Tour Action 60˚
Cleveland CG15 54˚
Nike Vapor Pro Combo, 4i-GW
Titleist 585h 19˚
Tour Edge Exotics XCG 15˚ 3 Wood
Taylormade R7 Quad 9.5˚

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by Patrick57

Quote:

Originally Posted by MiniBlueDragon

Not at all; I just noticed you offered it out to a member and it intrigued me as to whether there's a big difference between what Shawn teaches and your own philosophies as they seem quite similar on paper.

As I have no idea what Shawn teaches, it is impossible for me to make comparisons. Sorry


Here ya go:

SWING DNA
Speed [77] Tempo [5] ToeDown [5] KickAngle [6] Release [5] Mizuno JPX EZ 10.5° - Fujikura Orochi Black Eye (with Harrison ShotMaker) Mizuno JPX EZ 3W/3H - Fujikura Orochi Black Eye Mizuno JPX 850 Forged 4i-PW - True Temper XP 115 S300 Mizuno MP R-12 50.06/54.09/58.10 - Dynamic Gold Wedge Flex Mizuno MP A305 [:-P]

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by Patrick57

Hey, I agree, she's the talent, I am only the coach. I think I was only mentioning her because a reply came that my coaching was only for a certain level. You're only as good as the woman you are teaching. LoL



Obviously, you missed the point......

Razr Fit Xtreme 9.5* Matrix Black Tie shaft, Diablo Octane 3 wood 15*, Razr X Hybrid 21*, Razr X 4-SW, Forged Dark Chrome 60* lob wedge, Hex Chrome & Hex Black ball

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by mdl

So much for your magic platitudes...

I'm happy for you. I made my point but it takes time to delve into the intricasies of your story. I'm glad you agree with back swing restriction and paired with your athleticism, its sounds like a good blend. I'm not entirely sure exactly what you altered in your back swing but I'm sure you are working with something that isn't a million miles away from your self taught swing. Of course its going to feel alien but be happy that it is working. I'm sure you will go from strength to strength.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Moderator

Ok, I'm going to answer the OP's question, YES most golfers, amateurs and pros are mislead on how to swing.  There is no consideration for swinging on a tilted angle, how the body should work to accommodate that motion.  Heck, there isn't even any consensus on how to hit draws and fades.

Patrick, when a golfer hits a shot, what dictates it's initial start direction, the direction of the path or the face angle?

Mike McLoughlin

Check out my friends on Evolvr!
Follow The Sand Trap on Twitter!  and on Facebook
Golf Terminology -  Analyzr  -  My FacebookTwitter and Instagram 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by jamo

So then how does one find their natural swing? Which tips are fine, and which lead you down the path of artificiality?

(Also, rather than quoting people the way you are, the best way is to hit the quote button at the bottom of each post, and then you can always cut stuff out or copy/paste if you need to make it shorter.)



I have not posted in awhile, (check in and read everyday) but I could not sit quiet about this thread anymore.  Will  the OP please answer jamo's questions?

-Matt-

"does it still count as a hit fairway if it is the next one over"

DRIVER-Callaway FTiz__3 WOOD-Nike SQ Dymo 15__HYBRIDS-3,4,5 Adams__IRONS-6-PW Adams__WEDGES-50,55,60 Wilson Harmonized__PUTTER-Odyssey Dual Force Rossie II

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by mvmac

Ok, I'm going to answer the OP's question, YES most golfers, amateurs and pros are mislead on how to swing.  There is no consideration for swinging on a tilted angle, how the body should work to accommodate that motion.  Heck, there isn't even any consensus on how to hit draws and fades.

Patrick, when a golfer hits a shot, what dictates it's initial start direction, the direction of the path or the face angle?

This is too easy but I'll answer...The direction of the path of course.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Moderator

D@mn! I was gonna post that! I'll finish it for you.

uh, oh...

Wait for it...

Wait for it...

Here it comes...

Originally Posted by Mr. Desmond

uh, oh....



Steve

Kill slow play. Allow walking. Reduce ineffective golf instruction. Use environmentally friendly course maintenance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Note: This thread is 4373 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-15%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope.
  • Posts

    • Day 76 - Pretty sore today, so I opted for putting over my Stack session. Primary focus was on starting line, as my putting has been pretty poor this year. 
    • Been a bit of delay in updates but I needed to come back east as my mom's health has taken a serious turn for the worse. In a 3 day span we learned she had a tumor to she has stage 4 cancer and stopped eating and drinking for the most part. She has had a rough 3 months but certainly didn't think we'd be at the point of setting up hospice for her. My mom was never into any sports really other than following the Red Sox because my dad was a big fan. She always cared about what we were involved in including asking about how golf went.  I have kept up with my 5 minutes of daily practice and will go to the gym here in NH tomorrow morning. Despite the somber nature of this trip my family has commented more than a few times about my weight loss so it's important to me to keep it up. I know my mom always wanted us happy in whatever we did so I'll continue with my fitness journey keeping that in mind. 
    • Day 109- Putting drills on a putting green for 20 minutes. 
    • Day 252: did a stack session. Did some slow rehearsal swings during breaks. 
    • Day 82: 3/18/24 Tried a Stack session but could not certify my warmup. Finished with indoor chips and putting. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...