IGNORED

# Geometry... Spine angle

Note: This thread is 2763 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

## Recommended Posts

New to this site and enjoying the post.

The home page mentions Dave, D.O.I. and your other instructors teach a physics and geometry based method. Assuming this has roots with Bennett and Plummer. I looked at your students, Their students and even the instructors golf swings. I am confused as to what is geometrically a correct Spine Angle that face on view of Righthander:

At Address : Spine Angle looks like,    I  (straight )

In Back Swing : Looks    / ( Tilted Left )
Impact and Finish :   Looks  \  ( Tilted Right )

Is the premise that the Spine, ie. Spine Angle is not the center of the Swing ?

I mean   I to / to \ is geometrically friendly  ?  Both the Spine and the total core area of the trunk of your students dramatically move.

##### Share on other sites

New to this site and enjoying the post.

The home page mentions Dave, D.O.I. and your other instructors teach a physics and geometry based method. Assuming this has roots with Bennett and Plummer. I looked at your students, Their students and even the instructors golf swings. I am confused as to what is geometrically a correct Spine Angle that face on view of Righthander:

At Address : Spine Angle looks like,    I  (straight )

In Back Swing : Looks    / ( Tilted Left )

Impact and Finish :   Looks  \  ( Tilted Right )

Is the premise that the Spine, ie. Spine Angle is not the center of the Swing ?

I mean   I to / to \ is geometrically friendly  ?  Both the Spine and the total core area of the trunk of your students dramatically move.

You're using the term "spine angle" from a face-on view somewhat unusually (or incorrectly).

During the backswing, the spine is not "tilted left" from the face-on view. Absolutely not. If anything, from face-on, it's more \ (for a righty).
I encourage you to look at http://purestrike5sk.com/ for more of what Dave, myself, Mike, and James teach.

##### Share on other sites

On the backswing, your body in order to keep a steady head will require extension of the right side, to enable a 90* turn of the shoulders and a 45* turn of the hips. In order to not sway rightward or away from the target, and maintain a steady head, the right leg will straighten. And the right hip will be deeper and higher than the left. This forces your spine to tilt left and your left shoulder will go under the chin, and the right will be higher on the arch. A feel golfers will often have is that their entire right side is stretched in full extension at the top of the swing. This loads the pressure on the right side. But doing so maintains a centered pivot, and a steady head - key #1.

In order to now move from the top of the swing - where the golfers right side is in extension, and the spine is tilted toward the target. A lateral shift of the lower body is required. The golfer will slide his hips laterally toward the target by stepping down with the left foot. This move ensures proper ground reaction forces (GRF) are generated and help enable and power this lateral shift required to hit the golf ball with maximum force. This lateral slide of the hips enables the golfer to move his weight to the left side and ensure weight forward (key #2).

Yes most golfers will extend there right knee to some degree. Also, you are NOT required to turn 90 degrees, and hip angle to shoulder angle can vary as well. But if your a person who is not flexible, don't go overkill on the hip rotation to get to 90 degrees. You can turn to much and your weight will start to fall towards the target. So there is a balance here.

Also, everyone is a feel player

I disagree with this, the spine is not tilted towards the target. The point of the center pivot is to keep the upper center stable. For this to happen, your hips must rotate on a proper incline. Try doing a Russian Twist with a medicine ball, with your feet off the ground. To stay centered, as you drop the weight to one side, your hips will adjust and rotate slightly. The spine does not move laterally, or change title. If your hips open, the bottom of the spine will stay centered, meaning if you want the spine to tilt towards the target, then your head would have moved forward in the backswing, which is bad.

Yes, the spine will tilt away from the target at impact, slightly, and more pronounced with the driver. This is because the hips have driven forward, the head has stayed steady. Though in the FINISH, you might not see this because some players tend to move forward and get that stand straight up and down look. Most younger golfers, get the tilt look at finish with belt buckle pointing towards the sky, the old stand straight up and down on the front  leg is an older looking finish. Its a style thing, but it has nothing to do with Impact. So I wouldn't go judging this by how they finish, more of were they are at with impact.

Lets say your a right handed golfer, lets say your hitting a middle iron.

I would say that the spin tilt would be.

Address: Slightly tilted to the right, but mostly vertical

Top of the backswing: Same tilt

Impact: slightly tilted away from the target

Finish: Depends on golfer.

##### Share on other sites

saevel25, I guess we can agree to disagree on the spine tilting left at the top? Edited to show more accurate photo: From what I've been taught, and learned there is a leftward tilt of the spine to get the left shoulder low and hip low and in, and the right shoulder and hip high and deep to create extension. In order to keep the left arm straight. You need extensor action. The right arm/hand PP1/2/3 pulling. This creates depth which is required by the right hip and shoulder. And the shoulders turn in a vertical and horizontal arch around the spine. In order to make a full turn it is easier to straighten the right leg to allow the hips to rotate and create depth and extension. These moves create that leftward tilt of the spine. And enables the head to stay centered. You are misunderstanding how they are connected. Just because the spine tilts left doesn't mean the head tilts left. It's a misconception that you and many folks who don't understand the anatomy of the body easily fail to grasp. I did as well, until I truly sought out the answers. Flexion, to extension and regaining flexion and then going back into extension is the most efficient and anatomical way the body should operate in a powerful golf swing. One that prevents injury.

##### Share on other sites

saevel25, I guess we can agree to disagree on the spine tilting left at the top?

There's no need to agree to disagree when discussing facts. You're wrong that the spine tilts "towards the target" at the top. If anything, the spin will tilt slightly away from the target at the top because the lower portion of your back (near your butt) can rotate and be closer to the target while your head stays relatively still (and your head is connected to your upper spine, or neck).

The "side bending" or "left tilt" at the top is oriented towards the golf ball not towards the target.

Also, to be clear, the spine extends and left tilts about 5-10°. It's not a lot. It's very, very minor.

And the shoulders turn in a vertical and horizontal arch around the spine.

The spine turns too. The orientation of the shoulders to the spine remains pretty consistent.

##### Share on other sites

Ok.  So it tilts left by ~ 5 to 10*.  Thank you.

##### Share on other sites

• Moderator

Ok.  So it tilts left by ~ 5 to 10*.  Thank you.

Yes and like Erik said, the orientation of the left tilt is towards the ball and the spine overall is tilted away from the target.  Certain instructors place too much emphasis on how much the spine tilts/extends or how much the golfer should implement.  Erik helped me understand how a lot of that tilt/extension is originating in the hips and the knee linkage.

http://thesandtrap.com/t/66901/importance-of-the-hips-in-the-golf-swing

##### Share on other sites

Thanks for the input guys and gals. Interesting to say the least.

"Spine Angle",  didn't mean it so much as a  golf term.
Only, If I look at you eye to eye and you ..lets say reach down and scratch your knee you create spine angle. It is spine angle. From any view.

Ok, no tilt toward the target.  Good., Solid.

Hey, no worries, just trying to understand.

Another confusing area to me is:

The club moving to the right in the downswing, Is it your premise that the club, all clubs, should always be moving right before and through impact. Except, purposeful working the ball, of course ?

##### Share on other sites

The club moving to the right in the downswing, Is it your premise that the club, all clubs, should always be moving right before and through impact. Except, purposeful working the ball, of course ?

No. But it moves from in to out for the vast majority of all good players, and moves left quite early for many poor players.

Anyone who hits a fade could be said to be moving the club IN at impact, but it's moving out until a few inches before the golf ball.

##### Share on other sites

Note: This thread is 2763 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

## Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
• ### Topics Being Discussed Right Now on The Sand Trap

• Want to join this community?

We'd love to have you!

• ## Support TST Affiliates

Use the code "iacas" for 10% off Mevo and the code "iacasfeb21" for 10% off SuperSpeed.
• ### Posts

• One of the things I have noticed about really good Youtube channels - let alone excellent films, is exactly this. There might be a time lapse that would take hours to video, but it is on screen for perhaps less than two seconds. But it gives the presentation quality. Look at films with incredible special effects and costumes/props - Lord of the Rings, for example. Years and years go into making things like a belt that a camera may never even focus on, or be a hundred metres a way, but the film wouldn't work without them.The total is greater than the sum of its parts. The flip side of this, of course, is that a prop that takes 5 minutes to make and looks like crap it is noticeably crap even if it is on screen for half a second. A poorly photoshopped "family portrait" or newspaper "front page" with a stuck on headline on paper not even close to the colour of the newspaper. The devil is in the detail and tiny things connect to make the big picture. A bit like golf, perhaps.
• I’d rather have it shut than open. I can find a swing where it’s more shut than that. Open doesn’t work for me, the extended lead wrist gets me steep and I shallow late, leave the face too open (or shank) going to A7. The last 3 instructors I’ve worked with have told me to bow the lead wrist at 4 more and I’ll get away from that and get steep.  When I try and do that my arms come off my chest and path goes too out to in. When I feel like I drop the club behind me at A4 my arms will go out towards the ball pretty good I think, like in the second swing, at A5 my hands bisect the torso.
• My 2 cents is that if you have to add more than 1.5" or so, you are really in need of new shafts. As far as "orange dot length" is concerned, I always thought that the dot color only denoted lie angle, not length. For example, if I were to order Pings, I would want blue dot (1" upright) at standard length (I fall on the short end of standard range). I just came across an old post on here that give a good Ping chart. Don't comment in there unless it is really pertinent though, as it is quite an old thread.
• Looks closed to me, Steve.
• Late to post, but... I managed a par on the 18th on Sunday.  Not a birdie, but now I've birdied or parred every hole on the course! 🙂  👍
• ### Today's Birthdays

1. Miguel Martinho
(25 years old)
2. mtclinton21
(36 years old)
3. SwingCity18
(33 years old)

×
×
• Create New...

## Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...