• Announcements

    • iacas

      Visit FlagstickRule.com   03/13/2017

      Visit the site flagstickrule.com to read about and sign a petition for the USGA/R&A regarding the one terrible rule in the proposed "modernized" rules for 2019.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
zenbudda

Releasing lag, distance between hands and body at impact

22 posts in this topic

Preface

From ages 5-13, I played "just to play" and never had any real instruction.  My father also never had any instruction and just followed what he could learn from the pros (Nicklaus, Miller, Palmer, etc ) .  So my "basics" came from hand-me-down information.  Between 13-16 I started practicing and playing several times a day, several days a week.  Dad built me some clubs (Golfsmith Tour Model II's with square grooves, and true temper dynamic golds).  I was never really consistently good.  I could shoot +9 to +18 on better days.  I struggled with shanks, tops, hitting it fat, duck hooks and high fades.  I put down the clubs for most of 20 years.  I played here and there but nothing ever spectacular or worth talking about.  A few years ago I took some lessons at GolfTec (Golfsmith) and realized some major flaws in my swing.  I tilted towards the target on my backswing, re-routed my club from outside to in, lifted my head to get my left shoulder under my chin...etc etc.  My instructor was trying to get me back to a more stable one-piece sort of swing.  My swing looks a lot better and a lot different know.  I still feel really tight in my backswing, and it's hard to keep my head from moving up and down.  It's easy to start my down swing by sliding slightly foward, and it's easy to rotate my hips.  But for the love of god, i cannot unwind my upper body in proper sequence.  My timing is way off at contact and i'm still shanking (hozel), topping, fatting, hooking, blocking and slicing.  Out of 100 balls, I hit approximately 10-20 decent shots within 10-20 yards left/right of target.  About half of those are 5 yards within target.

Question

I feel I'm having problems grasping some mind-to-body concepts when it comes to lag, releasing lag, and where my hands need to be at impact.  I'm really struggling with trying to understand how to pull my arms through my upper body and keep my hands in a position where i do not hit the hozel (i do this quite often).  I watch a lot of youtube videos to see if i can find some indicators on how the pros pull their arms through the strike zone, but nothing is making sense in terms of that mind-body connection (ie. i can see what they are doing, and i can understand it mentally, but physically it's not happening).  So the way I would like to summarize this is, what muscles are being fired when you release lag (and for those that think you cannot hold on to lag too long you are way wrong), and where are your hands supposed to be in relation to your body (how far away from your body...think of a down-the-line shot).  I know you are supposed to have shaft lean but I feel as if I'm not releasing most of my lag before impact.

Sorry for so many words.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Question

I feel I'm having problems grasping some mind-to-body concepts when it comes to lag, releasing lag, and where my hands need to be at impact.  I'm really struggling with trying to understand how to pull my arms through my upper body and keep my hands in a position where i do not hit the hozel (i do this quite often).  I watch a lot of youtube videos to see if i can find some indicators on how the pros pull their arms through the strike zone, but nothing is making sense in terms of that mind-body connection (ie. i can see what they are doing, and i can understand it mentally, but physically it's not happening).  So the way I would like to summarize this is, what muscles are being fired when you release lag (and for those that think you cannot hold on to lag too long you are way wrong), and where are your hands supposed to be in relation to your body (how far away from your body...think of a down-the-line shot).  I know you are supposed to have shaft lean but I feel as if I'm not releasing most of my lag before impact.

Sorry for so many words.

Check this out, I'm not a big fan of a "pull" feel to sustain leverage.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

My swing in this video has its faults, but the principal is there. To me, sustaining lag in this little nudge of a swing, I don't feel any pulling at all. I agree with mvmac. I can't recall how many instructors told me to feel like I'm pulling, it never ever worked.

In the video, I feel like my right arm is pushing, thrusting, extending post impact. Leading with the right elbow too. Hands feel low. I don't start with a lot of lag if you're thinking Sergio Garcia, but between P5 and P6, where many people start casting, I've retained the shaft to arms angle BUT no pulling, no holding the lag, no Herculean feats of strength here, just proper timing, I'm holding the club lightly throughout. I see those YT videos out there of people showing exercises to "hold the lag" and I shake my head. There's lots wrong with the swing, no use of hips, arms too long, etc..., but it helped me start to figure things out although I still continue to figure things out, I'm less confused. Ball didn't go far, swinging very slowly, but came off real low, obviously, and curved a little left.

These are what I call my finding proof of principal swings.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

mvmac,

thanks for your response.  do you have anything that focuses on release of lag (proper way to release) and a down-the-line video of where your hands are through the release in terms of distance from the body?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

nevets88,

thanks for your response.  can you replicate this technique at near full swing?  if so, do you still feel your arm thrusting forward?  where are your hands from your body through the lag release?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I currently don't have a mechanism to video tape myself effectively.  i'll try to come up with something tonight.  however, i can guarantee that part of my problem is when i release lag, my hands are too away from my body (hence i'm blocking, toping and shanking a LOT Of shots).  this is why i'm interested in hearing a sound solution for releasing lag and where your hands should be in terms of distance from the body (ie. the same as they are at address?  if so, why are the pros hands a little more forward)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@zenbudda , please read this thread: . The multiple posts - particularly without quotes - are tough to follow.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

nevets88,

thanks for your response.  can you replicate this technique at near full swing?  if so, do you still feel your arm thrusting forward?  where are your hands from your body through the lag release?

Not yet. I'm not focusing on lag, but forward shaft lean with a shallow angle of attack, hands ahead of ball, less flippy. What I'm having problems with is getting my hands more forward. I'm not working on lag at all. When I get a good strike, my hands feel further away from the body post impact. Currently, I get about 200 yards from a 3I (that's a 22 degree, 38.75" shaft) on a normal tempo solid swing, probably a little more, but my post impact conditions are less than optimal, my arms are long on the way down and my left wrist is cuppy. I can get my hands even more ahead of the ball at impact. You can see it in my last video in my myswing thread.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

mvmac,

thanks for your response.  do you have anything that focuses on release of lag (proper way to release) and a down-the-line video of where your hands are through the release in terms of distance from the body?

You can have many different looking "releases" and still play pretty good golf.  There is no "proper" way to release other than making sure you have a flat lead wrist at impact.

I currently don't have a mechanism to video tape myself effectively.  i'll try to come up with something tonight.  however, i can guarantee that part of my problem is when i release lag, my hands are too away from my body (hence i'm blocking, toping and shanking a LOT Of shots).  this is why i'm interested in hearing a sound solution for releasing lag and where your hands should be in terms of distance from the body (ie. the same as they are at address?  if so, why are the pros hands a little more forward)

You feel like you retain the lag too long?

We like to say "lag happens" and I find it to be true for most golfers.  Pro's hands are more forward at impact because that's how golf clubs were designed to be hit, with the weight forward and the shaft leaning forward.  We call it Flat Left Wrist, right pic below, lead arm and shaft line up, Key #3.  Most golfers look like the left pic and that's where a lot of contact problems come in.

There is no one solution, it's figuring out what is going on with your swing and fixing the priority piece.  You may feel like the release is important but if I had to guess I'd bet your weight isn't forward enough at impact, Key #2.  Having a solid Key #2 helps get Key #3.

I would spend some time doing these drills before you tried to do anything with the release.  If you're topping and shanking a lot of shots, imo the release isn't the culprit.

More on the 5 Keys

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Here are some swings (front view and down the line).  After reviewing these, I thought about taking another set but the set-up is cumbersome.  I realize that I have not corrected my backswing "that much".  I'm still tilting towards the target a little, and I'm taken the club back too inside.  I'm also still lifting my head/chin to get my left shoulder underneath.  I admit, I'm incredibly stiff in my upper body.  I cannot seem to separate my hips from my upper body that well.  Anyway, for what it's worth.  The FPS sucks.

The reason for the video is to attempt to show that I do have shaft lean, and I do have lag, but I tend not to release it properly (hitting fat, topping, hitting hozel, blocking to the right etc etc).  If you slow the video down (you can do this in YouTube but not using the embedded vid), you will see where I do have lag in my swing and my hands are in front of the ball through impact.  My divots at the driving range suggest I'm pulling the club across my body, and on my drives, I definitely feel the ball hitting the inside of the club (high slice).  I really do need to work on my back swing but if someone could just point me to the right direction of proper release, I can start to play golf again instead of hitting 500+ balls a week on weekends.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

mvmac,

thanks for those tips.  if you trust me, i can guarantee you that 95% + of the time i am coming down on the ball, and out of that, 50% of the time i am making a divot in front of the ball.  I think you will see in my video that I am definitely leaning forward into the swing.

I still have a funny feeling that i'm not releasing the club correctly and i'm either releasing too late (causing my hands to be too far in front of the ball) or my hands are drifting away from my body causing me to hit the hozel instead of the center of the club.  It might be because i'm started out tilted towards the target (somethign I thought I had corrected) and I'm getting trapped by not over correcting and pulling my arms across my body in an attempt to correct the problem (/shrug wtf do i know lol).  This next few weeks, I'm going to focus solely on limbering up my upper body and trying to get a smoother transition from my back swing to my down swing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would shank the ball if my butt moved that much toward the target line and my spine raised up that much (from the down the line view) from the top of the swing to impact. Disclaimer: I'm not an expert but used to shank more than my fair share of balls.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would shank the ball if my butt moved that much toward the target line and my spine raised up that much (from the down the line view) from the top of the swing to impact.

Disclaimer: I'm not an expert but used to shank more than my fair share of balls.

Can you explain what you mean by "spine raised up that much"?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you draw a vertical line on the edge of your butt at the top of the backswing by the time you get to impact your butt is probably close to a foot off of the line. (Just a guess). If you draw a line on your spine angle at the top of the backswing it's probably between 30 and 40 degrees (also guessing) but by the time you get to impact that line would have to be vertical to match your spine angle. P.S. I don't lose any sleep over either of those things as long as I keep it to some sort of minimum.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reason for the video is to attempt to show that I do have shaft lean, and I do have lag, but I tend not to release it properly (hitting fat, topping, hitting hozel, blocking to the right etc etc).  If you slow the video down (you can do this in YouTube but not using the embedded vid), you will see where I do have lag in my swing and my hands are in front of the ball through impact.  My divots at the driving range suggest I'm pulling the club across my body, and on my drives, I definitely feel the ball hitting the inside of the club (high slice).  I really do need to work on my back swing but if someone could just point me to the right direction of proper release, I can start to play golf again instead of hitting 500+ balls a week on weekends.

Can't tell much of what the hands are doing with that video

mvmac,

thanks for those tips.  if you trust me, i can guarantee you that 95% + of the time i am coming down on the ball, and out of that, 50% of the time i am making a divot in front of the ball.  I think you will see in my video that I am definitely leaning forward into the swing.

I still have a funny feeling that i'm not releasing the club correctly and i'm either releasing too late (causing my hands to be too far in front of the ball) or my hands are drifting away from my body causing me to hit the hozel instead of the center of the club.  It might be because i'm started out tilted towards the target (somethign I thought I had corrected) and I'm getting trapped by not over correcting and pulling my arms across my body in an attempt to correct the problem (/shrug wtf do i know lol).  This next few weeks, I'm going to focus solely on limbering up my upper body and trying to get a smoother transition from my back swing to my down swing.

This is the reason for your problems.  Make it hard to get the weight forward properly, just helped a golfer yesterday with this same issue.  His path was well left and couldn't keep it on the golf course.  Made some changes and he shot nine shots better on the back nine.  No more slices.

To fix it, narrow your stance, allows the hips to turn.  Stance is too wide and promotes a sway.  Also feel like you turn your right hip pocket to a line that bisects your body.

Also note how the left knee will work, how this pic below is different than yours.  Left knee isn't collapsing inward.

Can you explain what you mean by "spine raised up that much"?

This

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    Leupold Golf
    Snell Golf
    Talamore Golf Resort
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • There are several statements that I disagree with which I feel are important to discuss: All golf balls do not go about the same distance.  A low compression, 2-piece Surlyn covered model will launch higher and with less spin than a 5-piece, high compression urethane covered model which will result in a noticeable difference in distance off the tee.  Dean even stated in another answer "The soft golf ball market has taken off due to the lower spinning balls means players can be longer in distance." Regarding balls for different swing speeds and compression:  3) Bridgestone (and I think Callaway) has come out with tour caliber balls for players who swing under 105mph. Is it possible to design a tour caliber ball for a specific segment of swing speed or is this just mostly a marketing thing?  DEAN: The whole swing speed story to me is one of the most over-rated stories in golf. Companies force or teach golfers to play low compression balls so their low swing speed can compress the ball. The problem with this is that low compression balls have the lowest spin in all shots, so they are pushing players to play a ball with no performance at all… and when you need that spin around the green, it's not there…            I almost don't know where to start on this one.  The concept of designing golf balls based on swing speeds doesn't teach or force players to use a low compression ball...it's about using a ball that has the appropriate compression for your swing speed.  Some players will have better results with a higher compression ball, others will have better results with a lower compression.  Keep in mind, there is a difference between "lower compression" and "low compression".  Most of the urethane tour balls have a compression rating somewhere between the mid 70s to mid 90s.  Tour models like the Chrome Soft, B330-RX and B330-RXS are in the mid 60s, which is lower.  Balls like the Supersoft and e6 are in the upper 30s and 40s, which is considered low.  Dean's statement that "low compression balls have the lowest spin on all shots" is somewhere between a little misleading and flat-out wrong.  It's true that a lower compression ball will spin less (and launch higher) than a firmer ball on full shots.  But on short game shots around the green, the ball is not compressed.  On pitch shots, chip shots, and greenside bunker shots for example,    the only part of the ball that is being activated is the cover. Notice on this chart that the lowest compression ball is very close to the highest spinning, and the lowest spinning ball has almost the same compression rating!  The point is, compression has little to no affect on short game shots...the cover is the main factor.  All 4 of these models have a urethane cover, but the two that provide the most spin have softer covers.  To put this in context, the chart below was a test Golf Digest did in 2015 which shows the performance on a partial wedge shot (I think it was 40 yds) with most of the balls on the market at the time The different colors represented the price point.  These results don't match the first chart I posted exactly which can happen when player testing (this one shows the B330 has higher spin than the RXS). Is there a difference between the lower spinning "red dots" and the highest spinning?  Sure.  There should be though.  Golf balls are designed to have different types of performance for different types of players.  The B330-RX has the lowest spin among the red dot models, but that doesn't mean it's lacking in performance...it spins exactly how the ball designers intended it to, because not everyone wants/needs maximum spin.  Notice the e7...this is a high compression ball very comparable to the B330, but has very different spin characteristics. So again, higher compression doesn't mean higher spin around the green and lower compression doesn't necessarily mean low spin.  About the only thing that I could agree with Dean's comment on would be that all the ultra-low compression balls are Surlyn covered models designed for distance, so it's true that these balls have low spin on all shots and will not offer the same level of performance around the greens, but again, that has more to do with the cover than the compression.  The fact is, there are lower compression balls that perform at the highest level. The B330-RXS is the same type of ball as the Pro V1 in many respects, and performs just as well as, or even better for many players, so I'm surprised by his comments that fitting for swing speed is over-rated and lower compression balls have no performance.  That's like saying getting fit for the correct shaft flex is over-rated, and softer flex shafts don't perform as well as stiffer shafts!  Does anyone consider the Dynamic Gold S-300 to be a lower performing shaft than the Dynamic Gold X-100?  No, of course not. They are designed to do the same thing, but because some players don't swing as fast as others the softer flex will give them better results, just like the B330-RXS is the equal to the B330-S, but will fit players who don't swing as hard better. I'm also not on-board with the opinion that fitting with a driver is a "mistake" and when testing to choose a ball based on 100 yds and in.  I'm not saying that short game performance isn't important, but wow...to claim that testing with a driver is a mistake is ridiculous.  I'll make a simple point on this...anyone can hit good wedge shots with a Pro V1 or B330 or Z-Star.  Fast swingers, slower swingers, high handicappers, low handicappers...it doesn't matter, they can all get good results on wedge shots.  Does that mean that's the ball they should play, and it will work equally as well for the other aspects too?  No.  A wedge can mask any issues in performance because of the loft and backspin, but the driver exaggerates issues.  The same players who hit respectable wedge shots with various tour balls might struggle to keep shots in play or lose potential distance. And before anyone tries to use the old "the driver is used 14 times a round, but half of the shots are inside of 100 yds" argument...save it.  If you play a high spin ball and you're struggling to hit the fairway with your tee shots, that ball will not help you save shots around the green.  Too much spin for players who can't control it is worse than a lower spinning model. Sorry Dean...not trying to blast you or anything, just putting in my two cents.  Ok, maybe more like four cents!
    • So......Is this your point @Jack Watson?
    • https://thesandtrap.com/b/clubs/titleist_716_ap1_review My review for the site is above. I've been using them since writing this review. Excellent clubs. One watch out is with short game shots with the PW and GW. They will go a bit farther than a corresponding chip or pitch with the equivalent wedge. The ball feels like it jumps off the face with good contact. So be careful with that.
    • Thanks for all the comments. I realize change is always hard but single length, lie and weight make so much sense to me. I am going to build a set of Value Golf clubs and see what happens. As improve I may go back to normal but who knows.  I think it will be better for learning the overall game. Which in my opinion and observance needs a lot of help. In my other hobbies that required learned skills it was easy to find groups to help you with the skills and drills to improve them. Businesses that the hobby supported held seminars and workshops covering all aspects. Trying to find help, other than paid lessons, is impossible, at least in my area. 
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Golfgirl10543
      Golfgirl10543
      (43 years old)
    2. jkettman
      jkettman
      (28 years old)
    3. old man1953
      old man1953
      (64 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon