Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
march11934

Protecting that left knee

43 posts in this topic

I recently watched Patrick Reed win a tournament, Humana Challenge i believe, and listened to the talking heads criticize his left foot release for the entire 4 days, while he proceeded dominate the field through the first three. This brought some attention to my own release as I always finished with my left foot, toe pointing out. It never bothered me and the few swing reviews I have had never brought a focus to it.

What i did realize is that i am protecting my left knee. I have damaged it in the past to the point that i can't drive manual transmissions unless the clutch is hydraulic to overcome the pedal pressure. So a golf swing could create issues with my knee. Stack and tilt swing is out of the question. I can load up on it to a point but the twisting on the release is not going to happen.

My point is that i notice that on my follow through, after impact, I tend to point my left foot up allowing me to rotate on my left heel as my body comes around. This allows me a full follow through without having to make any adjustments other than my left foot stance. I have no issues with balance, aim, power, etc. If i try to keep it planted, the pain i start experiencing starts affecting my release. I think i mentally start limiting my release to prevent messing up my knee. I have seen other guys with similar issues and noticed how they shorten up their fore swings to prevent over extending their knee. I haven't mentioned anything to them as it's probably not my business but i thought i'd ask around the opinions of the post if they have ever come across this idea.

Just a thought for those struggling with age and possible knee issues. Maybe its worth thinking about allowing that left foot out like Reed does.

Regards.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Just a thought for those struggling with age and possible knee issues. Maybe its worth thinking about allowing that left foot out like Reed does.

Or, better yet, just set up with it flared out to begin with. Then you don't have to try to dynamically flare it out in the middle of your downswing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

A flared left foot enables many positive moves ...agree with Erik ....try it in practice and then see what happens on the course when you are under your own self-inflicted pressure
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also have a bad left knee and dead nerves from the knee to my toes. Out of the question for me to let my left ankle roll over like many golfers so I have to flare the left foot (even a little more than most would probably recommend). When I first started playing my natural self-preservation instinct had me raising the left heel in the backswing and placing it back down leaving the foot open to start the downswing. I can't say that worked too badly but I finally figured I might as well just start that way to begin with. P.S. I also can't make any move that has any chance of hyper-extending the left knee so it has to stay at least slightly bent throughout the swing.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To OP, suggest observing Craig Stradler's swing.

Many golfers who have large body build will seldom make a full weight transfer side to their left, but have incredible power at impact.

This swing style will allow you to play without having complications of a weak knee.

Also, varying shot selections (3/4 swing) or like playing in windy conditions, should enable you to play without concerns.

Club Rat

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Thanks for the input guys. I have tried changing my stance with a flared left foot. Found it when researching Hogan's swing. But its not enough. I still find myself turning on my heel or rolling over my ankle. Unfortunately i don't much care for the flared left foot stance. Throws me off somewhere on my backswing. Im going o check out Stradtler's swing to see what his weight transfer is all about. Thanks

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Then youre probably doing it wrong.-You could flare your left foot out 90 degs and you couldn't possibly roll your ankle or whatever-it would limit your BS a bit though. So somewhere in the middle has to be a good mix-Otherwise you have a screwed up downswing-Most likely.[quote name="march11934" url="/t/72411/protecting-that-left-knee#post_948585"]Thanks for the input guys. I have tried changing my stance with a flared left foot. Found it when researching Hogan's swing. But its not enough. I still find myself turning on my heel or rolling over my ankle. Unfortunately i don't much care for the flared left foot stance. Throws me off somewhere on my backswing. Im going o check out Stradtler's swing to see what his weight transfer is all about. Thanks [/quote]
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I recently watched Patrick Reed win a tournament, Humana Challenge i believe, and listened to the talking heads criticize his left foot release for the entire 4 days, while he proceeded dominate the field through the first three. This brought some attention to my own release as I always finished with my left foot, toe pointing out. It never bothered me and the few swing reviews I have had never brought a focus to it.

What i did realize is that i am protecting my left knee. I have damaged it in the past to the point that i can't drive manual transmissions unless the clutch is hydraulic to overcome the pedal pressure. So a golf swing could create issues with my knee. Stack and tilt swing is out of the question. I can load up on it to a point but the twisting on the release is not going to happen.

My point is that i notice that on my follow through, after impact, I tend to point my left foot up allowing me to rotate on my left heel as my body comes around. This allows me a full follow through without having to make any adjustments other than my left foot stance. I have no issues with balance, aim, power, etc. If i try to keep it planted, the pain i start experiencing starts affecting my release. I think i mentally start limiting my release to prevent messing up my knee. I have seen other guys with similar issues and noticed how they shorten up their fore swings to prevent over extending their knee. I haven't mentioned anything to them as it's probably not my business but i thought i'd ask around the opinions of the post if they have ever come across this idea.

Just a thought for those struggling with age and possible knee issues. Maybe its worth thinking about allowing that left foot out like Reed does.

Regards.

If you mean your left foot (as a RH) spins out after impact, that isn't a problem from what I have seen and do.There are videos of even Hogan doing that.There is one video of Hogan against a grid almost coming out of his shoes.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you mean your left foot (as a RH) spins out after impact, that isn't a problem from what I have seen and do.There are videos of even Hogan doing that.There is one video of Hogan against a grid almost coming out of his shoes.


I would be the last person to say that any technique that avoids injury is not what somebody should do (goodness knows I do my share of "wrong" things).

The OP is talking about keeping the weight on his heel during the downswing to assure that the foot is going to spin open. My only question would be if that allows the knee to flex parallel to the target line so the weight can transfer properly. I would try it myself to see but I also can't use that technique because I can't lift my toes off of the ground with any weight on my heel due to dead nerves.

I'm pretty sure he (or anybody else with a bad knee) is not talking about the natural spin out from the momentum of the swing that Hogan and countless other people did or do. With a healthy knee the worst that usually can happen if the spikes hang in the ground is that the ankle rolls over (no big deal). With a bad knee or ankle (or both) if the foot hangs and doesn't spin out the result can be much more severe.

As long as he is assured of the weight staying on the heel, and if that somehow doesn't mess up his weight forward position coming into impact, maybe he can make it work.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Then youre probably doing it wrong.-You could flare your left foot out 90 degs and you couldn't possibly roll your ankle or whatever-it would limit your BS a bit though. So somewhere in the middle has to be a good mix-Otherwise you have a screwed up downswing-Most likely.

Flaring out my foot too much does exactly that, it limits my backswing. I know my foot is planted all the way through impact. Very similar to Reed's move. Chip and pitch shots don't affect my need to turn my foot over. Its not until i hit a full swing and about some time that i straighten my left leg on the forward transition that i seem to lift my foot a bit and rotate on my heel. I know there was quite  bit of info in the Five Lessons about being on your heels and not the front part of your feet. Probably need to get a video of my self to find out when it happens.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you mean your left foot (as a RH) spins out after impact, that isn't a problem from what I have seen and do.There are videos of even Hogan doing that.There is one video of Hogan against a grid almost coming out of his shoes.

Thanks. Have to look for those videos. If its good enough form Hogan… then certainly good enough for me. My point of the post was my noticing that even a modern pro is doing it and may last a long time  doing it rather than blowing a knee like Tiger Woods.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks. Have to look for those videos. If its good enough form Hogan… then certainly good enough for me. My point of the post was my noticing that even a modern pro is doing it and may last a long time  doing it rather than blowing a knee like Tiger Woods.

check out Phil here...out of his shoes

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

check out Phil here...out of his shoes

LOL. Now that's what i'm talking about!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is a video of my swing. Its a number of swings in succession so you can see i pretty much keep the foot turn consistent.

Funny thing is this is one of the only times i have ever seen my swing on video. Probably a good thing…. won't do much of this. LOL

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is a video of my swing. Its a number of swings in succession so you can see i pretty much keep the foot turn consistent.

Funny thing is this is one of the only times i have ever seen my swing on video. Probably a good thing…. won't do much of this. LOL

You look pretty good...better than Jim Furyk.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is a video of my swing. Its a number of swings in succession so you can see i pretty much keep the foot turn consistent.

Funny thing is this is one of the only times i have ever seen my swing on video. Probably a good thing…. won't do much of this. LOL

Yea, I would flare that front foot a bit more, and then I would concentrate on keeping a bit more flex in that front knee. Your a bit too early with the extension and it looks like it is causing you to flip a bit at the ball. That could be due to the ball position as well, it is a tad to far back. I would move it forward 2 inches or so.  Yea, flare foot, little bit more knee flex going into impact, get that left wrist further forward towards your left hip at impact. Besides that, the swing looks pretty solid. You got a good turn there, head stays steady.

I recommend taking this video and posting it in a  'My Swing' thread on the forum. Get a down the line view as well, you'll get some good tips from some people who know a lot about the golf swing.

You look pretty good...better than Jim Furyk.

Yet Furyk is on the PGA tour. Lets not rip on a US open champion, ya? A swing that looks like, "an octopus falling out a tree" has been one of the most successful swings on the PGA tour.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Yet Furyk is on the PGA tour. Lets not rip on a US open champion, ya? A swing that looks like, "an octopus falling out a tree" has been one of the most successful swings on the PGA tour.

March11934 has a reasonable looking swing,better than most.My Furyk comment was meant to point out that a swing does not tell the story when it comes to striking a ball solidly.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

March11934 has a reasonable looking swing,better than most.My Furyk comment was meant to point out that a swing does not tell the story when it comes to striking a ball solidly.

It does if you know how to read the story. What may look like a "bad" swing to the untrained eye may actually accomplish everything (all 5 keys) that is required to hit quality golf shots. Jim Furyk has a strange looking way of doing it but he does all 5 keys well enough to win Majors.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    Leupold Golf
    Snell Golf
    Talamore Golf Resort
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • He started off playing the first hole exactly how he should: fairway, 20-footer for birdie to the fat side of the green, tap-in par.
    • @iacas-Tho it is nice to be able to take your time and type out what you mean to say this is one of the downsides to a forum too-You have to respond to a whole bunch of crap and a person can get all of their thoughts out uninterrupted. If you were been sitting in a room with @natureboy and he started drawing that entirely stupid picture with the lines you could have cut him off and spared all of us the pain of having to watch him so badly miss the point. I bet @natureboy is still going to look at the response-And I bet he is still not going to see where he went wrong. But that is because he is just that way and he is unable to see how stupid his own posts are and how little they actually deal with golf swings. His stick drawing is exactly why you asked for a video-Even though he posted it after you asked. His errors and flaws and stupid thoughts would have been even more evident if he had actually tried to make a vid.
    • Or… golf is hard, and he got hot for awhile. Wouldn't be the first flash in the pan. We'll have to wait to see what the true version is. He could be quiet for ten years and then win a few majors.
    • That makes a great third bullet point. Or a first bullet point, bumping my two down.
    • This photo and the text above illustrate pretty well exactly why I and the entire moderation team is now done with you. The image fails on two levels: The center image is not representative of an actual good golf swing. The right hip is closer to the right foot in the center image, yet you maintain that it's farther away. Whether the second thing is done intentionally or accidentally I don't know. I don't care to know. But it's very representative of how you argue, and why you're now going to be prevented from arguing. You pervert arguments to the point where we're no longer discussing the golf swing. You get basic facts or concepts wrong (like when arguing about course rating, misunderstanding the radius vs. diameter in faulting the rating process for higher handicappers). You focus on some small thing - which often isn't even something anyone else has said - and lose sight of the forest or the big picture. You're not here to help golfers. You're here to "win" an argument, a goal that as yet is unmet, and you have to post absolute crap like the above to try to do it. I had a bit of free time this morning. So I responded to your last post in some detail. It, as one would expect, contains a number of typical @natureboy traits: cherry picking a photo while ignoring the concept, failure to understand basic points, perversion of the statements of others, putting words in the mouths of others, use of vague words like "a lot" (often in combination with the "putting words in the mouths of others), and hyper-focus on some small largely negligible point. Nobody else should waste their time to read the below, or open the spoiler and read that. It will not shed light on anything, it will not help you with your golf swing, and you will not glean any useful information. It exists simply as my last effort at illustrating to @natureboy a small part of the reason why we're tired of him… even though as I post it I know with certainty it too will fail. I gave you twenty warning points last night. It was made clear to you what you had to do, and you failed to do so, flaunting the requirement in several posts. The entire moderation team - @mvmac, @RandallT, @boogielicious, @jamo, @billchao, @nevets88, @mchepp, others - and myself have simply gotten sick and tired of your entire persona here. You're constantly and never-endingly arguing stuff to the point where you bastardize things so much you're no longer even talking about the golf swing, and you fail to comprehend or respond to what's written to you in response. You have two real choices once your current suspension is over: You can ignore these warnings, continue to be a belligerent arguer, and receive a final 50-point warning that will result in your permanent ban. You can avoid behaving in the manner that infuriates the entire moderation team. That will likely mean limiting the topics in which you post quite a bit, because though you fancy yourself to be capable of discussing the golf swing from a theoretical perspective, you've proven that you are not. Now, I want to be very clear about something. You're not being warned or "handled" because you disagree. You're being handled here because you contribute nothing positive. You're belligerent. You don't help people. You don't demonstrate anything. You pervert and distort topics in order to make a point that often has little or nothing to do with how people actually play golf. You're on a mission to "win" an argument, not to further the understanding. You speak as if you know and fail to ask questions, despite the holes in your logic and posts being constantly exposed as gaping. You quite often fail to read what's written, take a beat, and try to understand it. P.S. This requirement is anything but arbitrary. The list of reasons are long, the surface of which was only scratched in this post. Arbitrary would have been to say something like "to continue posting here you must dress up in a purple outfit and post a photo of yourself diving from a diving board into a pool of jello." Asking you to post a video illustrating your point is the opposite of arbitrary.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Catcher20
      Catcher20
      (27 years old)
    2. JD15
      JD15
      (52 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon