Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
xerex250

Why do the pros hit it so far? Here's my take

Note: This thread is 1329 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

267 posts / 19707 viewsLast Reply

Recommended Posts

Simply put, Jack Nicklaus said that he could carry about 260 swinging as hard as he could. He rarely hit over 300 unless he has a tailwind, downhill, and dry fairways. I'd say the same for pros nowadays. They don't carry 300 yards unless they're going downhill, downwind and on dry fairways. Most of them carry about 230 (estimate) and it rolls about 50 yards. These courses that  the pros play on are dried out hard and fast. No wonder they hit it so far! Also these courses have a lot of wind. If they have a headwind, they merely hit it lower. If they have a tailwind, look out there's going to be some bombs, especially if it's downhill and the fairways are hard. I hit my drives about 200 carry and if I had these conditions described here I could hit it 270 (maybe 250) No wonder it doesn't look like they're trying. They let the course take care of distance for them.

Also, Jack also said that a course he had a hand in designing called harbor town,  there was a hole in which there was a creek separating two fairways and he said that it carried about 230. But he also said that he couldn't carry that spot unless he hit his absolutely best shot. He said that if he hit it even just a bit thin, he wouldn't be able to carry, no matter how hard he swung. This makes sense because most of us only drive about 230 on average, but we play on slow courses and we don't swing very hard. I swing all out and I still can't get it past 220 on the range, but on a fast course I can get it to 280. So generally, this is my opinion on how the pros hit it so far.

Another factor though, is how strong these guys are; they swing so fast because of their strength. So if you want more distance, work out. Simple as that.

That's my opinion.

Sources: Jack Nicklaus' Book Golf My Way and my own logic

Comment freely. Thank you for your concern, and I appreciate your responses

Have a nice rest of your week,


Xerex250 (pastaman)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One other factor you didn't mention:  Elevation.

At the match play, they were all carrying it 280-310 on some holes, but that had a lot to do with the fact that they were up in the sky.  They were hitting their 8 irons 200 yards.

I think I even heard the announcers mention that they had to factor in 10% extra distance to all of their clubs right off the bat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Simply put, Jack Nicklaus said that he could carry about 260 swinging as hard as he could. He rarely hit over 300 unless he has a tailwind, downhill, and dry fairways. I'd say the same for pros nowadays. They don't carry 300 yards unless they're going downhill, downwind and on dry fairways. Most of them carry about 230 (estimate) and it rolls about 50 yards. These courses that  the pros play on are dried out hard and fast. No wonder they hit it so far! Also these courses have a lot of wind. If they have a headwind, they merely hit it lower. If they have a tailwind, look out there's going to be some bombs, especially if it's downhill and the fairways are hard. I hit my drives about 200 carry and if I had these conditions described here I could hit it 270 (maybe 250) No wonder it doesn't look like they're trying. They let the course take care of distance for them.

Also, Jack also said that a course he had a hand in designing called harbor town,  there was a hole in which there was a creek separating two fairways and he said that it carried about 230. But he also said that he couldn't carry that spot unless he hit his absolutely best shot. He said that if he hit it even just a bit thin, he wouldn't be able to carry, no matter how hard he swung. This makes sense because most of us only drive about 230 on average, but we play on slow courses and we don't swing very hard. I swing all out and I still can't get it past 220 on the range, but on a fast course I can get it to 280. So generally, this is my opinion on how the pros hit it so far.

Another factor though, is how strong these guys are; they swing so fast because of their strength. So if you want more distance, work out. Simple as that.

That's my opinion.

Sources: Jack Nicklaus' Book Golf My Way and my own logic

Comment freely. Thank you for your concern, and I appreciate your responses

Have a nice rest of your week,

Xerex250 (pastaman)

Sorry, but no.  Even I carry a driver 230ish.

Tiger was being interviewed last year and he made a remark that stuck with me.  He said that when he came out on tour, the "big carry" was 285 yards.  In other words, it was a big deal for someone to reach deep and take it over a hazard or cut a corner at 285.  Now, he said, the "big carry" is 315.  That's carry , and that, boys and girls is a long damn ways!

They hit it that far because they swing the driver with a much higher swing speed than most of us and hit it smack dab in the center of the club face.....almost every time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Simply put, Jack Nicklaus said that he could carry about 260 swinging as hard as he could. He rarely hit over 300 unless he has a tailwind, downhill, and dry fairways. I'd say the same for pros nowadays. They don't carry 300 yards unless they're going downhill, downwind and on dry fairways. Most of them carry about 230 (estimate) and it rolls about 50 yards. These courses that  the pros play on are dried out hard and fast. No wonder they hit it so far! Also these courses have a lot of wind. If they have a headwind, they merely hit it lower. If they have a tailwind, look out there's going to be some bombs, especially if it's downhill and the fairways are hard. I hit my drives about 200 carry and if I had these conditions described here I could hit it 270 (maybe 250) No wonder it doesn't look like they're trying. They let the course take care of distance for them.

Also, Jack also said that a course he had a hand in designing called harbor town,  there was a hole in which there was a creek separating two fairways and he said that it carried about 230. But he also said that he couldn't carry that spot unless he hit his absolutely best shot. He said that if he hit it even just a bit thin, he wouldn't be able to carry, no matter how hard he swung. This makes sense because most of us only drive about 230 on average, but we play on slow courses and we don't swing very hard. I swing all out and I still can't get it past 220 on the range, but on a fast course I can get it to 280. So generally, this is my opinion on how the pros hit it so far.

Another factor though, is how strong these guys are; they swing so fast because of their strength. So if you want more distance, work out. Simple as that.

That's my opinion.

Sources: Jack Nicklaus' Book Golf My Way and my own logic

Comment freely. Thank you for your concern, and I appreciate your responses

Have a nice rest of your week,

Xerex250 (pastaman)

You have some points I agree with about rollout. Where I play there is no rollout (maybe a bounce or two if you are lucky). You are also way off on the carry distances the pros have.

Hell, I'm not even any good, and certainly not the in the top three in distance where I play, but 230 is a 5 wood for me all day long.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Originally Posted by xerex250

Simply put, Jack Nicklaus said that he could carry about 260 swinging as hard as he could. He rarely hit over 300 unless he has a tailwind, downhill, and dry fairways. I'd say the same for pros nowadays. They don't carry 300 yards unless they're going downhill, downwind and on dry fairways. Most of them carry about 230 (estimate) and it rolls about 50 yards. These courses that  the pros play on are dried out hard and fast. No wonder they hit it so far! Also these courses have a lot of wind. If they have a headwind, they merely hit it lower. If they have a tailwind, look out there's going to be some bombs, especially if it's downhill and the fairways are hard. I hit my drives about 200 carry and if I had these conditions described here I could hit it 270 (maybe 250) No wonder it doesn't look like they're trying. They let the course take care of distance for them.

Also, Jack also said that a course he had a hand in designing called harbor town,  there was a hole in which there was a creek separating two fairways and he said that it carried about 230. But he also said that he couldn't carry that spot unless he hit his absolutely best shot. He said that if he hit it even just a bit thin, he wouldn't be able to carry, no matter how hard he swung. This makes sense because most of us only drive about 230 on average, but we play on slow courses and we don't swing very hard. I swing all out and I still can't get it past 220 on the range, but on a fast course I can get it to 280. So generally, this is my opinion on how the pros hit it so far.

Another factor though, is how strong these guys are; they swing so fast because of their strength. So if you want more distance, work out. Simple as that.

That's my opinion.

Sources: Jack Nicklaus' Book Golf My Way and my own logic

Comment freely. Thank you for your concern, and I appreciate your responses

Have a nice rest of your week,

Xerex250 (pastaman)

Sorry, but no.  Even I carry a driver 230ish.

Tiger was being interviewed last year and he made a remark that stuck with me.  He said that when he came out on tour, the "big carry" was 285 yards.  In other words, it was a big deal for someone to reach deep and take it over a hazard or cut a corner at 285.  Now, he said, the "big carry" is 315.  That's carry, and that, boys and girls is a long damn ways!

They hit it that far because they swing the driver with a much higher swing speed than most of us and hit it smack dab in the center of the club face.....almost every time.

The 230 carry figure is too low for a pro, it's even a little too low for a scratch golfer (Not commenting on your distances, Dave).

The PGA average carry under all conditions last year was around 272 yards and the year before was 269.

http://www.pgatour.com/stats/stat.02409.html

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Remember, Jack Nicklaus didn't play with the same modern equipment that these pros today use. Jack was carrying 260 with a persimmon driver and balata ball. I believe in his prime his avg. drive was about 275-ish ( which was pretty much the longest on tour at the time). Also... Strength does not make one hit the ball farther. Speed makes one hit the ball farther. I guarantee I'm stronger than pretty much every guy on the tour, but they all drive it much farther than me because they swing faster and make better contact.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Women carry 230 in CO, seriously. I played behind a few of the CU Lady Buffs last month and they hit 7i on a slightly uphill 180 something par 3. Pros hit it far and accurate because they are good and golf is their career, the dedication and practice that comes with it etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

So my curious question is ... Is Jack talking about in the olden days of persimmons woods and balatta balls?     if so then i could see how the pro's only hit it about 230.. cuz they probably not swinging 100% and just trying to hit the ball perfect everytime..

I mean I am a high teen handicap golfer and i know i hit the ball with carry 230..  as for roll i think it depends on the course.. probably 95% of all public courses, you might get 5 to 10 yards of roll, unless you always hit a low shot...  why?  because the fairways are so soft..

I mean depending on the tournament and course and weather... yes the pro's are going to average 300+ in just carry... and then you have roll...  which is why you see a lot of pro's hit their 3 wood.. cuz they are going so far with their driver, they end up in that " in between " 2nd shot to the green...

Plus with some of the tournaments like last years British Open, you had guys hitting their 5 iron 200 yards and then with roll they was going 300+  cuz the fairways were so dry...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So my curious question is ... Is Jack talking about in the olden days of persimmons woods and balatta balls?     if so then i could see how the pro's only hit it about 230.. cuz they probably not swinging 100% and just trying to hit the ball perfect everytime..

I mean I am a high teen handicap golfer and i know i hit the ball with carry 230..  as for roll i think it depends on the course.. probably 95% of all public courses, you might get 5 to 10 yards of roll, unless you always hit a low shot...  why?  because the fairways are so soft..

I mean depending on the tournament and course and weather... yes the pro's are going to average 300+ in just carry... and then you have roll...  which is why you see a lot of pro's hit their 3 wood.. cuz they are going so far with their driver, they end up in that " in between " 2nd shot to the green...

Plus with some of the tournaments like last years British Open, you had guys hitting their 5 iron 200 yards and then with roll they was going 300+  cuz the fairways were so dry...

The OP is referencing a book that Jack wrote 40 years ago.  That's why the numbers bear little relation to current day......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

some pros carry it farther than others.  of course, the fairway conditions help, as i have seen balls bound and roll 40 yards sometimes at these tour courses.  even in the middle of the summer, we get a 5 foot bounce on our drives up here in NY.

also, they hit the sweet spot practically every time.  better contact will usually out-distance a faster swing with worse contact.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Simply put, Jack Nicklaus said that he could carry about 260 swinging as hard as he could. He rarely hit over 300 unless he has a tailwind, downhill, and dry fairways. I'd say the same for pros nowadays. They don't carry 300 yards unless they're going downhill, downwind and on dry fairways. Most of them carry about 230 (estimate) and it rolls about 50 yards. These courses that  the pros play on are dried out hard and fast. No wonder they hit it so far! Also these courses have a lot of wind. If they have a headwind, they merely hit it lower. If they have a tailwind, look out there's going to be some bombs, especially if it's downhill and the fairways are hard. I hit my drives about 200 carry and if I had these conditions described here I could hit it 270 (maybe 250) No wonder it doesn't look like they're trying. They let the course take care of distance for them.

Also, Jack also said that a course he had a hand in designing called harbor town,  there was a hole in which there was a creek separating two fairways and he said that it carried about 230. But he also said that he couldn't carry that spot unless he hit his absolutely best shot. He said that if he hit it even just a bit thin, he wouldn't be able to carry, no matter how hard he swung. This makes sense because most of us only drive about 230 on average, but we play on slow courses and we don't swing very hard. I swing all out and I still can't get it past 220 on the range, but on a fast course I can get it to 280. So generally, this is my opinion on how the pros hit it so far.

Another factor though, is how strong these guys are; they swing so fast because of their strength. So if you want more distance, work out. Simple as that.

That's my opinion.

Sources: Jack Nicklaus' Book Golf My Way and my own logic

Comment freely. Thank you for your concern, and I appreciate your responses

Have a nice rest of your week,

Xerex250 (pastaman)

Colt Knost was ranked dead last in carry distance for 2013 and his average carry distance was 251.9 yards. The longest was Nicolas Colsaerts at 302.1 yards.

Sure, there's some courses where these guys get 50 yards of roll, but even then, they're carrying it far past 230. At my home course there's a bunker on one of the Par 5's that is 250 to carry. I can carry it when I'm hitting the ball well. When I'm not, I have to aim away from the bunker. It cuts 20-30 yards off the 2nd shot if you carry the bunker.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Agreed.  Today's pro's carry the ball way further then 40 years ago.  New technology.  New fittness routines.  New game.  My million dollar question is how to "learn" to swing faster?  I asked my teaching pro at my last lesson and he wouldn't give me a direct answer.  The hook to keep me coming back.

Club manufacturers are promoting LAUNCH as the medicine for carry.  But if my swing creates undue backspin, then high launch will balloon and my ball will go nowhere.  So many elements at play, but how would one train to swing faster AND under control, with the driver?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@xerex250 - A genuine curiosity question: why don't you ever seem to respond to the threads you start?

At least this one's not about how you just need to clear your mind of clutter and swing instruction and you'll suddenly shoot 67, but still, the pattern seems to repeat with you: you post something, people disagree or point out flaws, or share their opinions on what you've shared, at least - and you go away.

Why? Why on earth would you claim that modern PGA Tour pros carry the ball 230 yards when you can just look that stat up: http://www.pgatour.com/stats/stat.02409.2013.html ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

You have some points I agree with about rollout. Where I play there is no rollout (maybe a bounce or two if you are lucky). You are also way off on the carry distances the pros have.

Hell, I'm not even any good, and certainly not the in the top three in distance where I play, but 230 is a 5 wood for me all day long.


Maybe I am off on the carry. Still, I think that most of the distance they get comes from roll and tailwind, elevation (as someone here said) and dry, downhill fairways. Maybe they do carry at least 260, not 230. maybe even 270. But rarely does someone carry 300. But most of the time they hit the ball extraordinarily far. This was just my views on it. I guess they do carry a little longer than I said, for example maybe 270, which of course, is impossible for most of us (not all of us though) Though we can increase our distance by having these factors. I don't know, but before I wrote this thread I had looked up the average carry of pros on multiple sites and it averaged about 230-240 carry. Guess I was mislead. Still, I'm probably the shortest hitter on the planet, averaging 190 on my drives to 210. My longest carry was 250. What's the average distance someone like me should have with driver? I'm 17 and been playing for about 3 years. also, I have about a 18 handicap and I don't swing too hard. any ideas?

Xerex

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Originally Posted by MS256

You have some points I agree with about rollout. Where I play there is no rollout (maybe a bounce or two if you are lucky). You are also way off on the carry distances the pros have.

Hell, I'm not even any good, and certainly not the in the top three in distance where I play, but 230 is a 5 wood for me all day long.

Maybe I am off on the carry. Still, I think that most of the distance they get comes from roll and tailwind, elevation (as someone here said) and dry, downhill fairways. Maybe they do carry at least 260, not 230. maybe even 270. But rarely does someone carry 300. But most of the time they hit the ball extraordinarily far. This was just my views on it. I guess they do carry a little longer than I said, for example maybe 270, which of course, is impossible for most of us (not all of us though) Though we can increase our distance by having these factors. I don't know, but before I wrote this thread I had looked up the average carry of pros on multiple sites and it averaged about 230-240 carry. Guess I was mislead. Still, I'm probably the shortest hitter on the planet, averaging 190 on my drives to 210. My longest carry was 250. What's the average distance someone like me should have with driver? I'm 17 and been playing for about 3 years. also, I have about a 18 handicap and I don't swing too hard. any ideas?

Xerex

You need to also take into account that the pros hit with 80% effort. I'm sure on the driving range any of them could hit close to or more than 300 carry.

Look up this thread: http://thesandtrap.com/t/64681/handicap-versus-clubhead-speed-driving-distance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

You need to also take into account that the pros hit with 80% effort. I'm sure on the driving range any of them could hit close to or more than 300 carry.


True I guess for some. Jack Nicklaus said he went full out on every shot and could carry 260. That was with the old equipment, though I don't see much difference between the old clubs and balls as compared to the modern stuff. If the pros are using 80%, then they must be some huge guys. On tv they look small, but I've seen Bubba Watson's arms and they are larger than most. He also uses leverage very well. Most of these guys are huge, like 6' and 240 pounds. I'm only about 170 pounds and 5'4". Any other ideas on how they hit the ball so far?

Thank you for your concern,

Xerex

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lihu

You need to also take into account that the pros hit with 80% effort. I'm sure on the driving range any of them could hit close to or more than 300 carry.

True I guess for some. Jack Nicklaus said he went full out on every shot and could carry 260. That was with the old equipment, though I don't see much difference between the old clubs and balls as compared to the modern stuff. If the pros are using 80%, then they must be some huge guys. On tv they look small, but I've seen Bubba Watson's arms and they are larger than most. He also uses leverage very well. Most of these guys are huge, like 6' and 240 pounds. I'm only about 170 pounds and 5'4". Any other ideas on how they hit the ball so far?

Thank you for your concern,

Xerex

As for your second question,

Look up this thread: http://thesandtrap.com/t/64681/handicap-versus-clubhead-speed-driving-distance

There's a plot from R&A; that shows driving distance versus handicap.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Note: This thread is 1329 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • Support TST Affiliates

    SuperSpeed
    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    Whoop
    FlightScope Mevo
    Use the code "iacas" for 10% off Mevo
  • Posts

    • Wow, super lucky to be able to crawl out of that wreck. If he went unconscious it would be all over. It's not hard to get knocked out. 
    • Official F1 video doesn't allow embedding: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQ7_En2xEm4 (Graphic content as a near-death occurs)  
    • We don't do breakfast balls. But the other two @woodzie264 described are pretty much winter rules. I used to play a lot of tournament golf, so im just conditioned to play the game under those circumstances, even when im playing a game with a group where they are different rules agreed to. But the rule I and my regular group let slide most often is re-teeing or replaying after a lost ball or OB. We just agree on a general place to play the next from with whatever penalty the shot usually is. Speeds things along and doesn't really effect the outcome of our money games too much. 
    • When I’m playing a non-handicapped round, I don’t follow a lot of rules. I’ll toss em around if I don’t like a lie or line, pick up once on green and/or within like 6ft, and hit several mulligans. Honestly when not keeping a handicap, play in any way that makes you happy, so long as it doesn’t effect pace of play. 
    • Rule 3 - The Competition Notes as follows. These are notes, not a recap or a summary or anything like that. I didn't do a great job of just writing the NOTES for this rule, instead I just kinda summarized it, particularly the match play part. I'll do better for rule 4. 3.1 - Central Elements of Every Competition Match play, stroke play, or other forms of stroke play determine some rules outcomes Match play is against the opponent, without as much care for "the field" Also have to know if you're playing against an individual or partners Finally, gross or net? 3.2 - Match Play Three ways to win a hole fewer strokes than opponent opponent concedes opponent incurs general penalty You can tie, too: same number of strokes someone makes a stroke on the hole and the players treat it as tied (kinda like a mutual concession) Three ways to win a match: More holes up than remain opponent concedes opponent is DQed Extending a tied match: sudden death, continuation of the same round (so no switching equipment, etc.) holes played in same order unless Committee determines a different one Result is final when something is done as set by the Committee, such as final score posted on a scoreboard, etc. Players may concede the next stroke, hole, or match. Concessions made while ball in motion apply to the next stroke unless it goes in the hole. If knocked away while in motion it has to be obvious that the ball doesn't have a chance of going in. (Spieth in the Ryder Cup.) Concede a hole at any point before the hole is completed (even before it's played), 6.5. Concede a match at any point before it's completed/decided. Concessions are verbal or by an action If a player lifts his ball due to a reasonable misunderstanding that something was conceded, he can replace with no penalty (14.2) Handicaps in match play… DQed if player says handicap too high and doesn't correct before next stroke. If too low, plays off the lower handicap. Given by hole, lower net score wins. If tied match extended, same holes get the same strokes as in regular round. If players mistakenly apply handicap to a hole, result stands unless it's corrected in time. Responsibilities: Player can ask the other how many strokes they've taken at any time, other guy must respond with correct number. Failure to reply is treated as giving the wrong number of strokes. Wrong number is general penalty unless he corrects before asking player makes another stroke, or if after a hole, before anyone makes a stroke on the next hole or before the match is final (exception if the right score doesn't affect the outcome of the hole). Must tell an opponent about the penalty as soon as reasonably possible, even if the player is unaware of the penalty (because players are supposed to recognize when they've breached a rule). Otherwise, general penalty. Exception: no penalty when opponent knew of player's penalty (such as when seeing him take penalty relief). Know the match score. If players mistakenly agree on wrong match score they can correct it before a player makes a stroke to begin another hole or before the match is final if it's the last hole. If not corrected, it becomes the final score. Exception: when player requests a ruling. Protect your own rights and interests. You're not protecting the field here. Players may act on or ignore breaches by opponent. Cannot deliberately agree to ignore breaches, DQ if so. Players can ask for rulings under 20.1b. 3.3 - Stroke Play Winner finishes in the fewest total strokes, net if handicap. Player's score kept on a scorecard by the marker. Marker(s) certify hole scores with player, sign. Player certifies, signs, and returns scorecard. Breach anything here, DQ. Exception: no penalty when marker fails, such as marker leaving with player's card). Wrong hole score: higher stands, lower is DQ. Exception: just pretend you're unaware of a penalty. Stupid. Then the strokes are just included. Player responsible for his handicap being listed on the scorecard. Too high or not shown and affects # of strokes given, DQ. Too low, plays to it. Player not responsible for addition or applying handicap. Player must hole out each hole. If not corrected in time, DQ. Rules 21.1, 21.2, and 21.3 for other forms of stroke play.
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Darkfrog
      Darkfrog
      (43 years old)
    2. Jrock817
      Jrock817
      (40 years old)
    3. Leonclum
      Leonclum
      (48 years old)

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...