• Announcements

    • iacas

      Visit FlagstickRule.com   03/13/2017

      Visit the site flagstickrule.com to read about and sign a petition for the USGA/R&A regarding the one terrible rule in the proposed "modernized" rules for 2019.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Abu3baid

Relationship of flat left wrist vs. flipping to club path?

9 posts in this topic

This question has popped into my head a few times over the past couple of weeks, and I looked around trying to find an answer with none satisfying my query (if this has been discussed please merge if necessary).

I am not really sure what the answer is, but the situation is this and I'm trying to understand.

My friend flips the club no problem, and when we look at his swing it is obvious that he has a swing path that is in-out (he still has a two way miss where he will miss with an overdraw one day and a slice the other).  However, it is not just my friend I have seen other videos here of players that say they hit push draws and draws, but when I see their video they are flip city.

My self on the other hand I feel like I have a pretty flat wrist, however my big issue has always been (and is slightly changing with the irons, but not the Dr & 3W) swinging around my body and thus an out-in at contact or as I have heard coming across the ball causing the right curving shot (mostly push slices with the long clubs & fades with the irons).

Do people who flip just have an easier time swinging out because of all the time they give themselves and their body doesn't really move forward enough, while the others who might have a flat left wrist end up going around their body because their hips have no where to go since they have moved their weight way forward, and now the hips just pop open and bring the club with it?

Another issue is should this person who does flip start working on getting his hips forward and more of a flat left wrist at impact expect that his push draws will most likely turn to push slices and fades now?

Thanks

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Do people who flip just have an easier time swinging out because of all the time they give themselves and their body doesn't really move forward enough, while the others who might have a flat left wrist end up going around their body because their hips have no where to go since they have moved their weight way forward, and now the hips just pop open and bring the club with it?

Generally people who flip would have a harder time swinging out because when the club "overtakes" the hands, the path is rotated less right/more left.

Another issue is should this person who does flip start working on getting his hips forward and more of a flat left wrist at impact expect that his push draws will most likely turn to push slices and fades now?

Maybe. The issue is probably more of an arm sequencing problem or even the head going forward from A4-5....or both.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Lots of discussion of flipping in this thread here.

http://thesandtrap.com/t/38588/flipping-at-impact-master-thread

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abu3baid

Do people who flip just have an easier time swinging out because of all the time they give themselves and their body doesn't really move forward enough, while the others who might have a flat left wrist end up going around their body because their hips have no where to go since they have moved their weight way forward, and now the hips just pop open and bring the club with it?

Generally people who flip would have a harder time swinging out because when the club "overtakes" the hands, the path is rotated less right/more left.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abu3baid

Another issue is should this person who does flip start working on getting his hips forward and more of a flat left wrist at impact expect that his push draws will most likely turn to push slices and fades now?

Maybe. The issue is probably more of an arm sequencing problem or even the head going forward from A4-5....or both.

It took me a long time to understand this.  I am not sure why, maybe instinct was telling me differently.

@Abu3baid , take a club in your hand and mimic a slow downswing until the hands are getting close to impact.  Stop the hands and slowly flip the club.  You can see that as soon as the club head passes the hands, it will start to move left, unless your body alignments were extremely closed.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

It took me a long time to understand this.  I am not sure why, maybe instinct was telling me differently. @Abu3baid , take a club in your hand and mimic a slow downswing until the hands are getting close to impact.  Stop the hands and slowly flip the club.  You can see that as soon as the club head passes the hands, it will start to move left, unless your body alignments were extremely closed.

Yup, good observations. Here's how I think of it, at least academically. The farthest the clubhead gets from your hands occurs when you have a flat left wrist. This is because you hold the bottom of the handle with your left hand. So if you swing the club with just your left hand, you'd swing down when your left wrist is bowed, hit the apex of the arc at a flat wrist condition, and swing up when your wrist starts to cup (flipping). And since we know the golf swing is on an inclined plane, swinging down is out, and up is in. Voila, flipping causes an inward (leftward) swing path.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

This question has popped into my head a few times over the past couple of weeks, and I looked around trying to find an answer with none satisfying my query (if this has been discussed please merge if necessary).

I am not really sure what the answer is, but the situation is this and I'm trying to understand.

My friend flips the club no problem, and when we look at his swing it is obvious that he has a swing path that is in-out (he still has a two way miss where he will miss with an overdraw one day and a slice the other).  However, it is not just my friend I have seen other videos here of players that say they hit push draws and draws, but when I see their video they are flip city.

My self on the other hand I feel like I have a pretty flat wrist, however my big issue has always been (and is slightly changing with the irons, but not the Dr & 3W) swinging around my body and thus an out-in at contact or as I have heard coming across the ball causing the right curving shot (mostly push slices with the long clubs & fades with the irons).

Do people who flip just have an easier time swinging out because of all the time they give themselves and their body doesn't really move forward enough, while the others who might have a flat left wrist end up going around their body because their hips have no where to go since they have moved their weight way forward, and now the hips just pop open and bring the club with it?

Another issue is should this person who does flip start working on getting his hips forward and more of a flat left wrist at impact expect that his push draws will most likely turn to push slices and fades now?

Thanks

I am no expert but to me it sounds like you are casting the club from the top. Especially if "around your body" means a shallow back swing and you are out to in coming through. Obviously I don't see your swing so just throwing something out there to check but I am pretty sure you can flip and get inside the ball if the swing path is pushing the club head to the right at the point of impact.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had a flippy swing last year and got my handicap down to 4.5.  It's the wrong way to golf, but I made it work with good timing.  If your timing is off... you're screwed!  You will hit the ball higher and lose a club in distance.  I was doing it to save rounds.  I would just take a weak grip and flip.

My flipping was from early extension.  I would stand up on my downswing and have to throw the club at the ball.  If my club face was open, I would push it.  If it was closed, I would hook.  I weakened my grip and hit it straight.  Spine angle is very important.  I used to try to force lag, but keeping your spine angle keeps lag.  You lose the lag when you early extend and throw the club at the ball.  This is from my experience anyway.  Everyone is different.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Apparently having the ball too far back in your stance can also lead to flipping, which is what was pointed out as one of my issues along with an overswing. I'm curious if these are typical causes for a flip, overswing and ball placement too far back.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Apparently having the ball too far back in your stance can also lead to flipping, which is what was pointed out as one of my issues along with an overswing. I'm curious if these are typical causes for a flip, overswing and ball placement too far back.

Interesting.  I've never heard that.  Getting the club stuck behind you causes it, I know.  You have to get out of the way of the club, so you stand straight up.

I know Jack Nicklaus always lined the ball up with his left ear on every club.  I feel like most irons are lined up with my left eye (I'm a northpaw)  and wedges in the middle with my nose.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    Leupold Golf
    Snell Golf
    Talamore Golf Resort
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • No, not exactly...just a general or rough definition of "in the vicinity" will do. Not all of us are 1.5ers. 
    • Which range in the US, the piece doesn't say. Trackman Range is basically setting up multiple radars, 3 for example, so that it can provide numbers for a range of a given length, like 130 yards in the example here and everyone on that range in selected spots basically has radar. Here's the piece that talks about the setup some more plus putting. The new ability to measure putt related data is interesting as well, wonder what it'll add in addition to SAM Puttlab. 
    • Well,  you said for most people,  and I do not have a large sample size to draw from in my own experience in golf so... I draw from my own personal experience.    As a player there was a time when I wanted to change the shape of my swing very badly in a certain way.  I have found that when I tried to do that and hit a ball at the same time it was too much for my brain and I would find contact with the ball over making the change or the change I saw on video would be miniscule if present at all.  I found though that if I removed the ball I was able to make changes.  Now,  obviously this was making an air swing that might not even hit a ball on the ground.  No accuracy,  but that's the point!  Free the brain from having to put clubhead on ball for a minute and focus on something else to harness it a bit!  I removed all intention of a precise strike or clubface control by doing this.  I am talking now seriously make a swing or two look at video...most times exaggerate the move even more...look at video.  Repeat repeat repeat.   Same exact video angle all the time!   This is not a fast process I am just explaining what I was doing.  Backyard was perfect for this feel vs real experimentation feedback loop I was working on.  The only purpose of this was to develop a way I could learn to somewhat repeat what I was looking for.  Stage two would be targeting a tuft of grass and doing it again video.  Stage three would be maybe going out to the range and like you said rehearsing a few and then bringing in the ball and striking it. For me going out and shanking and slicing a bucket of balls working on a change costs money and it's hard to convince myself it's a success regardless of what I see on video.  I've done it several times. So,  before I did the whole air swing thing I hit many buckets and basically it was not effective at anything except maybe excercise and grooving compensations to the point I built myself a nice yip impact block on full swings.  Yes I admit at first I thought I could beat golf by athletic ability alone like every moron high cap that beats balls ingraining moves that need to be eliminated if they are ever to improve.  Without a couple simple workable concepts imo hitting balls is really the worst thing to do for a relatively inexperienced player.  So,  that's my take. For background info on me I played tennis in college and it was sport of focus from maybe sixth grade on and I took proper instruction with one coach for quite a while.  I feel I maximized my potential there.  Often in college I would surf in the morning early (skipping class obviously) and then for the afternoon travel for matches and play my singles and a doubles match.  My coach seriously used to ask me if I surfed that day because he said I played better when I did! I have a lot of experience in teaching athletics of various sorts  including surfing and soccer and I have been told many many times by many people that I have a natural affinity for teaching in a minimalistic simple fashion.  I succeeded in many ways in athletics but for me it was always a personal focus on technique that led to success.  Growing up I could never jump high or run very fast or lift heavy weights,  but I developed a pretty good jump shot in hoops.   I could kick a ball far and score goals in soccer. I am just not one of those naturally athletic fearless types who as a kid could jump their bike real huge or Ollie a skateboard a couple feet into the air or do a tuck flip off a diving board into a pool without thinking a bit how they did it.  I can identify those types and imo there's something happening there most of the rest of us ain't got!  Sure I could flip but it was an extended body flop of sorts lol.  In tennis I got decent,  but it was from good instruction,  good practice, an absolute ton of hours of hard work,  and if I might say so very good technique.  In golf I can't break par so I don't really ever bother people in swing threads unless I can speak from personal experience.  I realize I am not qualified to develop a swing to say a par shooter,  so I don't try to.   I think I might have some thoughts relative to some though.  Sorry for boring those who have read this but I must say I value my time spent on this site highly;  most sites are crud these days filled with Internet warrior liars who don't offer much true Quality.        
    • Yeah, I dunno about any of that. There were almost 150 women playing in this tournament (28*5, right?), no doubt many of them using the restroom during a round, yet only two used a cart to get there. 
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Golfgirl10543
      Golfgirl10543
      (43 years old)
    2. jkettman
      jkettman
      (28 years old)
    3. old man1953
      old man1953
      (64 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon