Jump to content
IGNORED

Should the act of "dropping" be eliminated in favor of always placing?


bkuehn1952
Note: This thread is 2818 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Replace Dropping With Placing?  

55 members have voted

  1. 1. Should the act of "dropping" be eliminated in favor of always placing?

    • I am okay with replacing "dropping" with placing in all instances
    • I think "dropping" should continue
    • Other - please explain


Recommended Posts

Other than on the green, is it fair to say:

  • one drops a ball when a decision is made to move the ball (or it is in a water hazard) because of a condition or feature making play of the ball more difficult or impossible, 
  • one places/replaces a ball when an outside agency or someone other than the player/partner/caddie moves the ball and the spot is known

I am looking for a "rule" that easily tells me when to place and when to drop.  Similar to the short cut "rule" of  "2 clubs when penalized, 1 club when free relief."

Brian Kuehn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I vote no dropping is great it gives a chance for a lie.

sometimes I dont take a drop because I know the lie will be bad

a good example is water in a bunker, a drop will certainly plug the ball and playing in water is not difficult with a bit of practice.

another it a cart path surrounded by big rough.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


3 hours ago, bkuehn1952 said:

Other than on the green, is it fair to say:

  • one drops a ball when a decision is made to move the ball (or it is in a water hazard) because of a condition or feature making play of the ball more difficult or impossible, 
  • one places/replaces a ball when an outside agency or someone other than the player/partner/caddie moves the ball and the spot is known

I am looking for a "rule" that easily tells me when to place and when to drop.  Similar to the short cut "rule" of  "2 clubs when penalized, 1 club when free relief."

Place the ball if the spot is known, or if it's on the putting green (relief on the putting green is the point that is nearest where the ball lies that gives relief which still makes it a precise point for placement - no additional clublength like you get through the green).  

Rick

"He who has the fastest cart will never have a bad lie."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Does anybody remembering playing Microsoft Golf?

You could hit it into the water and take a drop.  But they were a little loose on the drop rules. You could literally drop the ball 300 yards further on the hole and right next to the pin.

Birdie the easy way.

Tony  


:titleist:    |   :tmade:   |     :cleveland: 

Link to comment
Share on other sites


16 minutes ago, pumaAttack said:

Does anybody remembering playing Microsoft Golf?

You could hit it into the water and take a drop.  But they were a little loose on the drop rules. You could literally drop the ball 300 yards further on the hole and right next to the pin.

Birdie the easy way.

Not in the later versions after Microsoft took over the Links franchise.  There were still some oddities about the drops, but they were never closer to the hole.  

Rick

"He who has the fastest cart will never have a bad lie."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

1 hour ago, Fourputt said:

Not in the later versions after Microsoft took over the Links franchise.  There were still some oddities about the drops, but they were never closer to the hole.  

I only remember PGA Tour golf on the Sega Genesis where if you hooked your drive on 18 at Sawgrass into the water, it dropped on the edge for you, but gave you a perfect "Jesus" stance right on top of the lake. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I voted no because of all the times I end up in a divot or other indentation (possibly an old divot that grew back a little). It's cheating to move the ball unless governed by a rule, so placing the ball is kind of like doing that.

My actual preference is to play as it lies, except where prohibited like flower beds, staked trees, environmentally sensitive areas, etc. One playing partner told me I had to take a drop from a red hazard, but I noted that as long as I don't ground the club I can play it out of a hazard. He was busy looking it up while I made my shot. :-P

:ping:  :tmade:  :callaway:   :gamegolf:  :titleist:

TM White Smoke Big Fontana; Pro-V1
TM Rac 60 TT WS, MD2 56
Ping i20 irons U-4, CFS300
Callaway XR16 9 degree Fujikura Speeder 565 S
Callaway XR16 3W 15 degree Fujikura Speeder 565 S, X2Hot Pro 20 degrees S

"I'm hitting the woods just great, but I'm having a terrible time getting out of them." ~Harry Toscano

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I voted drop should stay the same.  Doing a proper drop is an art to get a better lie, as well as sometimes it's better to play as it lies as the drop could be worse.   The drop requires you to think, if you just place it, you could end up with a better lie than someone who hit it in the fairway or not as far off line

-Jerry

Driver: Titleist 913 D3 (9.5 degree) – Aldila RIP 60-2.9-Stiff; Callaway Mini-Driver Kura Kage 60g shaft - 12 degree Hybrids: Callway X2 Hot Pro - 16 degree & 23 degree – Pro-Shaft; Callway X2 Hot – 5H & 6H Irons: Titleist 714 AP2 7 thru AW with S300 Dynamic Gold Wedges: Titleist Vokey GW (54 degree), Callaway MackDaddy PM Grind SW (58 degree) Putter: Ping Cadence TR Ketsch Heavy Balls: Titleist Pro V1x & Snell MyTourBall

"Golf is the closest game to the game we call life. You get bad breaks from good shots; you get good breaks from bad shots but you have to play the ball where it lies."- Bobby Jones

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

12 hours ago, Mike Boatright said:

Dropping the ball is almost always for relief in pga tournaments the players drops it twice on purpose then places his ball it's stupid. Hitting a great tee shot down the middle and find it lands in a divot full of sand is bad luck but is also been up for discussion for a free drop because hitting a fairway shouldn't penalize you. Assume your getting relief from a cart path then it should be relief not have it fall in a small gopher hole impression. The only time golf is play is at it lies is in the fairway and rough in play where you don't get relief only and in the summer no winter rules. Trust me guys the game is hard enough why do people insist on making it harder.

I hope your other 399 posts indicate a better understanding of the principles behind the Rules of golf. (Hint, read Tufts.) 

"Age improves with wine."
 
Wishon 919THI 11*
Wishon 925HL 4w
Wishon 335HL 3h & 4h
Wishon 755pc 5i, 6i, 7i, 8i & 9i
Tad Moore 485 PW
Callaway X 54*
Ping G2 Anser C
Callaway SuperSoft
Titleist StaDry
Kangaroo Hillcrest AB
Link to comment
Share on other sites


7 hours ago, bubble said:

I vote no dropping is great it gives a chance for a lie.

sometimes I dont take a drop because I know the lie will be bad

a good example is water in a bunker, a drop will certainly plug the ball and playing in water is not difficult with a bit of practice.

another it a cart path surrounded by big rough.

Yes, you're already getting relief plus you have the option not to take it. Already seems pretty fair.

Kevin

Link to comment
Share on other sites


In a practice or casual round I place. When I'm playing in a competition I drop.

Julia

:callaway:  :cobra:    :seemore:  :bushnell:  :clicgear:  :adidas:  :footjoy:

Spoiler

Driver: Callaway Big Bertha w/ Fubuki Z50 R 44.5"
FW: Cobra BiO CELL 14.5 degree; 
Hybrids: Cobra BiO CELL 22.5 degree Project X R-flex
Irons: Cobra BiO CELL 5 - GW Project X R-Flex
Wedges: Cobra BiO CELL SW, Fly-Z LW, 64* Callaway PM Grind.
Putter: 48" Odyssey Dart

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

23 hours ago, Fourputt said:

Not in the later versions after Microsoft took over the Links franchise.  There were still some oddities about the drops, but they were never closer to the hole.  

 

Damn, why did they have to fix that bug?!

Tony  


:titleist:    |   :tmade:   |     :cleveland: 

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • 4 weeks later...
On 3/15/2016 at 8:57 AM, Golfingdad said:

Consider this:  A close match comes to the finishing hole tied and Player A hooks his tee shot OB.  He gets to re-tee (perfect lie), and plays that ball to a par for a double-bogey finish.  Player B hits two perfect shots and then a decent third that is about to land on the fringe 10 feet from the hole but it hits a sprinkler head, bounds over the green, and OB.  Now he has to drop near his previous shot and cross his fingers and hope that it doesn't bound into a divot hole.  If we were judging who's more entitled to a better lie there, I don't think anybody would choose Player A, so it's not really about entitlement.

In your cart path example, though, I kind of agree.  I could see people gaming the system with being allowed FREE placements.  Part of what goes into deciding to take a cart path (or similar) drop is the lie vs. the possible upcoming lie.

While admittedly not being a rules expert or an expert on the principles either, I think I would advocate for replacing penalty drops with places, but requiring that free drops remain drops.  You're taking a gamble on a better lie, you shouldn't be guaranteed one.  With the penalty drops, there is no such gamble.  You're forced to drop after having already been punished.  (So I voted "other")

I agree. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Practice, casual rounds, do whatever you like.  Tee it up in the fairway.  Have fun.

Tournaments, etc?  No reason to change this rule.  Sometimes it's a bit silly, but that's part of the charm of trying to stay true to 'hit it as it lies' - a drop simulates a landing better than placing it.  Frankly, we should throw it down at the ground if we really want to meet the philosophy.....  ; )

 

 

(it's weird though, but my very BEST games/best scores, without exception, ever have been days when I played absolutely true to the rules - when you are hitting clean, it's kind of neat how you can still hit a good shot from odd lies as long as you maintain form and focus......there's a lesson in there somewhere)

Bill - 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I voted for #1--okay with eliminating dropping.

I admit, this is probably contrary to the basic principles of the game, one of them being that we have uneven, random playing fields and you have to deal with whatever you get.

But overall, I think this is one aspect of the game where changing would do more good than harm.

Yes, we would lose a bit of the randomness in these circumstances. But drops occur infrequently among the total number of strokes made, so it really doesn't decrease the randomness of the game overall by MUCH.

The benefit would be that it speeds up play to a degree when we are talking about drops on slopes....avoiding the multiple-drops-then-place scenario.

Placing the ball ALL the time (i.e., rolling it over in the fairway, etc.) is too much, and it removes an element of skill, so I'm not advocating that in any way.

But placing a ball in the penalty situations....you are already being penalized....and there are still restrictions on where you drop, so placing the ball doesn't necessarily guarantee you can get a perfect lie every time. You may be placing on hard pan or in clover or in some sort of condition you don't think is ideal.

And it's not like there aren't already situations where we make exceptions to the total concept randomness. We allow local rules of lift/clean/place under certain circumstances. When conditions are wet, for example, lift clean and place is used because we do NOT want the chance that something random like a mud-ball on a drive in the fairway will unduly affect the outcome of a competition. And everyone gets to clean their ball on the putting green, again something that goes against randomness, for a good reason. We are allowed to fix pitch marks on a green, even in our line, etc.

In all I think it would be a good move to eliminate dropping and just place the ball.

Edited by Big Lex
  • Upvote 1

JP Bouffard

"I cut a little driver in there." -- Jim Murray

Driver: Titleist 915 D3, ACCRA Shaft 9.5*.
3W: Callaway XR,
3,4 Hybrid: Taylor Made RBZ Rescue Tour, Oban shaft.
Irons: 5-GW: Mizuno JPX800, Aerotech Steelfiber 95 shafts, S flex.
Wedges: Titleist Vokey SM5 56 degree, M grind
Putter: Edel Custom Pixel Insert 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Golf isn't supposed to be easy. Placing in the rough is a bit like teeing it up. You could get a better lie in the rough then someone who hits it on the fairway. Rough is there for a reason. So I voted for 'let it be the way it is'

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Really...

I think dropping should continue and more.  I am of the opinion that golfers should be blindfolded and spun around before dropping -except that this would take more time- since often they try to cheat.  Sometimes they don't like the lie and try to do the drop such that the ball rolls into the cart path, etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


2 hours ago, Howling Coyote said:

Really...

I think dropping should continue and more.  I am of the opinion that golfers should be blindfolded and spun around before dropping -except that this would take more time- since often they try to cheat.  Sometimes they don't like the lie and try to do the drop such that the ball rolls into the cart path, etc.

In accordance with the principles, I do not disagree with your (albeit tongue-in-cheek) suggestion. The drop was always intended to give the same random result as the result of a stroke.

Some interesting bachground from ruleshistory.com:

The method of dropping a ball had a few early variants: 
1754 throw it at least six yards; 1776 Edinburgh Burgess throw it over your head; 1809 HCEG, 1830 Montrose, 1839 Royal Perth and 1812R&A, face the hole, and drop over the head; and the latter to be adopted over the shoulder from Perth 1825 and Blackheath 1828. 
When the 1899 rules came into force, the procedure was well detailed: behind the hazard, face the hole, stand erect and drop it from your head on a line from the hole.
In 1908 the new procedure of dropping over the shoulder introduced. It lasted until 1984, when the present method of dropping at arm's length was introduced.

Edited by Martyn W
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Note: This thread is 2818 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...