Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
dedalus101

Why 2 stroke penalty for hitting flagstick?

Note: This thread is 1077 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

78 posts / 7825 viewsLast Reply

Recommended Posts

42 minutes ago, SG11118 said:

I'm not going to definitively say the pins caused the ball to deflect this far, but perhaps some combination of the hole adding energy to the ball and the stiff pin deflecting most of that energy might have resulted in the ball ending up further away than had the pin not been there?

Highly unlikely.

  • Even if the flags were rubber, the ball will deflect with less speed than it had going in.
  • Holes can't "add speed" to the ball - for every bit of energy gained by dropping into the hole, the speed is scrubbed off when it comes back out. For a ball to exit the hole with more speed than it entered you'd need to enter at the uphill part and exit at the downhill part and/or have a really rounded lip at the exit point. That's really rare.

I'm not saying your old flagsticks weren't less accepting than the new ones you've got, but no flagstick can really "add" speed to the ball. In virtually all cases the physics works out simply so that the speed taken off is more than enough to offset the reduction in distance (or time) that the ball has to fall in the hole.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Register for free today and you won't see this ad spot again!

56 minutes ago, SG11118 said:

 but perhaps some combination of the hole adding energy to the ball .

I'm afraid the physics doesn't work that way. Collisions do not add energy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why so complicated?

If there was no penalty for hitting the flagstick, you could lay it down just behind the hole,

perpendicular to your putting line and use it as a backstop.

Discussion closed? ;-)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, SamSnead said:

If there was no penalty for hitting the flagstick, you could lay it down just behind the hole, perpendicular to your putting line and use it as a backstop.

Kinda. That's a bit different than leaving it in the hole.

Welcome to TST.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

30 minutes ago, SamSnead said:

Why so complicated?

There are very few topics that the users of this forum can't disagree on and dissect into the most minute subtopics, and this is just one of them.  For better or worse, we can make anything "complicated", and I put myself right in the middle of that, this isn't aimed at "those guys".  But that's part of the fun of the conversations we have here, and for the most part we manage to keep our disagreements civil and respectful.  Welcome to TST, I hope you enjoy it just as much as I do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

4 hours ago, iacas said:

Highly unlikely.

  • Even if the flags were rubber, the ball will deflect with less speed than it had going in.
  • Holes can't "add speed" to the ball - for every bit of energy gained by dropping into the hole, the speed is scrubbed off when it comes back out. For a ball to exit the hole with more speed than it entered you'd need to enter at the uphill part and exit at the downhill part and/or have a really rounded lip at the exit point. That's really rare.

I'm not saying your old flagsticks weren't less accepting than the new ones you've got, but no flagstick can really "add" speed to the ball. In virtually all cases the physics works out simply so that the speed taken off is more than enough to offset the reduction in distance (or time) that the ball has to fall in the hole.

It was probably more perception than reality.  A lot of times the ball didn't seem to be rolling very hard, and it would hit the pin and run 8 feet away.  Your high side / low side example was one I wasn't thinking of.  I was thinking that what might be happening is the ball is rolling across the ground, hits the flag where it was tapered enough to transfer some of the horizontal energy into vertical energy to have the ball bounce across the green where it is subject to a smaller amount of friction and then have the potential to travel further than if the ball had continued to roll.  Its maybe possible, but a little far fetched, and probably only applicable on very slow greens.  You guys are probably right that it really isn't happening.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, SamSnead said:

Why so complicated?

If there was no penalty for hitting the flagstick, you could lay it down just behind the hole,

perpendicular to your putting line and use it as a backstop.

Discussion closed? ;-)

If it was only a 1 stroke penalty, there are quite a few longer putts I would be willing to take the penalty and lay the stick at a 45* angle to my line making a guide to the hole almost ensuring a 1 putt +1. 

Welcome to the site. :beer:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

7 minutes ago, CarlSpackler said:

If it was only a 1 stroke penalty, there are quite a few longer putts I would be willing to take the penalty and lay the stick at a 45* angle to my line making a guide to the hole almost ensuring a 1 putt +1. 

Welcome to the site. :beer:

What about 2 for a breach of 8-2b

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, SG11118 said:

It was probably more perception than reality.  A lot of times the ball didn't seem to be rolling very hard, and it would hit the pin and run 8 feet away.  Your high side / low side example was one I wasn't thinking of.  I was thinking that what might be happening is the ball is rolling across the ground, hits the flag where it was tapered enough to transfer some of the horizontal energy into vertical energy to have the ball bounce across the green where it is subject to a smaller amount of friction and then have the potential to travel further than if the ball had continued to roll.  Its maybe possible, but a little far fetched, and probably only applicable on very slow greens.  You guys are probably right that it really isn't happening.

If the flagstick is angled down and the ball is rolling slowly, it can't add speed because it would deflect it down into the lip of the hole.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

So, here's a fun video for this topic. A shot from a tournament I was at today that I just happened to catch. Obviously not a situation where the option of removing the flag stick comes into play, but I have a hard time believing the ball would have come to rest closer to the hole had the flag stick not been present...

Note: These are very hard, stiff pins, that taper from the middle out (up and down).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Isn't this a proposed rule change?   I believe one of the proposed USGA rule changes is that one can now putt with the unattended flagstick in the hole.   No penalty. 

I like it, because for the average player, it could speed up play.  

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

31 minutes ago, Marty2019 said:

Isn't this a proposed rule change?   I believe one of the proposed USGA rule changes is that one can now putt with the unattended flagstick in the hole.   No penalty. 

I like it, because for the average player, it could speed up play.  

 

 

It is yes. But I doubt it will make it into the final rules in 2019 due to the issues discussed in the rules proposal threads.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

2 hours ago, Marty2019 said:

Isn't this a proposed rule change?   I believe one of the proposed USGA rule changes is that one can now putt with the unattended flagstick in the hole.   No penalty. 

I like it, because for the average player, it could speed up play.  

It would hardly speed up play at all. Quality of play and golfers just playing slow account much more. 

Imagine you are sitting in the fairway and you see a guy put the flag back in. It would take them what, 20 seconds at most. That's an extra 6 minutes on a 240 minute round. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

2 hours ago, saevel25 said:

It would hardly speed up play at all. Quality of play and golfers just playing slow account much more. 

Imagine you are sitting in the fairway and you see a guy put the flag back in. It would take them what, 20 seconds at most. That's an extra 6 minutes on a 240 minute round. 

 

Now that I think of it, you're probably right.   I'm just desperate for anything that would speed up my own regular group.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

On 1/30/2017 at 7:12 PM, dedalus101 said:

Sorry that does not explain the rule. The only evidence I have ever seen for being "statistically" more likely to make a putt by hitting a flagstick was a Pelze study that was frankly very poorly designed since it used putts that would have gone 3 feet past, 6 feet past and 9 feet past the hole. Of course a backstop like a flagstick would help if you are banging putts that hard but for anyone who actually has speed control the flagstick is an obstacle not an aide and I have never seen any evidence to the contrary thus why the penalty?

 

I've been gone for awhile and saw this thread.

I began playing a certain way, which has greatly improved angular accuracy.  (1) I would allow myself only one putt on the green (once I got on).  (2) I would leave the flagstick in (not in a tournament and I am no pro).  (3) The object was to hit the flagstick, or have the putt go about 5 feet past the hole (but not more than 5 feet).  At first this had little effect, but after awhile I began hitting the flagstick.  The ball would typically not drop but the flagstick acted like a break, leaving a very short putt back (but per my conditions would not make another putt).  After awhile I could regularlly hit the flagstick.  I think pro's would be even more clever and would take advantage of this to an extreme.

I still suck at pace.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Note: This thread is 1077 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2020 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    FlightScope Mevo
  • Posts

    • Day 84 Planemate advanced protocol impact position drills this afternoon after work. 
    • For me, I play anywhere from 5900-6400 given the choice. Average decent contact drive is somewhere between 230-250 now (which I am really happy about), but I still have a decent amount of "power fades" and cold tops/sky balls. We do have a course locally which is something of an executive course. I actually still enjoy it from the middle tees at 5100 yards, as opposed to the back tees at 5400. This is still a par 71 course. It still feels like I should be playing from the middle tees, even if my scores are absurdly better than they should be, with my best being a +5 (+5 front even back), but the holes still feel right for where each set of tees are. For me, as long as I'm not playing for something special (tournament or local money game where certain tees are mandated), I play as short as feels reasonable and fun. I don't often play "forward" (seniors', juniors', women's, whatever it may be)tees, sticking with mostly the "members" tees if I play somewhere new. If the course is exceptionally long, I may move up. Sometimes it depends on the group that I am playing with too. Had a situation last year where a guy got matched with my buddy and I, and he wanted to play the tips (7k yards or so), whereas we wanted to play 2 tees up (6400 yards). Ended up splitting the difference at 6700 yards from the second back tees. The guy we were paired with struggled very bad, and my friend and I didn't fair much better. TLDR: Don't be afraid to play "shorter" tees, and go have fun.
    • Muni is Chinese Paige Spiranac....though Muni has her LPGA card/membership....Paige is simply a Instagram golfing POSER....and whiner...just sayin. Ok...Muni is an Instagram POSER too. I hope I can attend the 2020 CP CWO here in Van City and chat up a fellow countrywoman. I didn't know who she was back in 2012...but Muni use to play out of Swaneset here in La La Land...a 36 hole facility that I play often in the summer with 2 tough tracks. He's a video of Muni as a kid at Swaneset.....Muni needs counselling...her favorite player is the The Phony Pink Diva...WTF.   Ai-Chan and Lorena are two of the most classiest and approachable LPGA pros. Both always so engaging and polite. If a fan asked Lorena for an autograph she always thanked that fan for coming out to watch. I don't like Wie...big snob....if there was a needle mover on the LPGA..... it was Wie...Wie never really like engaging with the fans...she like some other pros know when the cameras are nearby.....BJ is a MARKETING GENIUS...conning everyone that Michelle would be the 'chosen one' in woman's golf....LMAO
    • Went to Minneapolis for a bachelor party in the Summer. The group might have gone with this course but the price scared us off after currency conversion and how expensive the trip already was planned to be. We ended up playing Keller and still loved our pick.
    • These climbers are like human Spider-Man. The Invisible Man. Birdie. Loosely based on HG Wells’ story, this movie was tense, scary and layered. 
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. bmartin461
      bmartin461
      (48 years old)
    2. Judah Ben-Hur
      Judah Ben-Hur
      (58 years old)
    3. WonIron
      WonIron
      (62 years old)

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...