Jump to content
burr

changing balls during play

28 posts in this topic Last Reply

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, iacas said:

@Lihu, you're making several assumptions here:

  • That people are capable of putting the line exactly on the top of the ball.
  • That people are capable of lining the line up exactly where they want to hit the ball.
  • That people are capable of lining up a line on the ball to their putter.
  • That people then don't change their minds after the line is there re: where they want to start the ball.

In my experience, ALL of those are met an incredibly small % of the time. The second one, in my testing, 90% of people can't point the line on a ball into the hole (any of the 4.25") from 10'.

People can't do it.

Lines are pointless. They waste time, and they don't help.

And, consider the basic geometry. Even if you can put the line on the top of the ball… if your eyes are not directly over it, the line will be curved.

#StopDrawingLines

In addition, won't the ball axis tilt if there is any break/slope to the putt?  I think I recall seeing this on the Aimpoint express video.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Want to hide this ad? Register for free today!

3 hours ago, DaveP043 said:

I have conflicting concerns about this.  I agree that scores posted for handicap should be played under the Rules of Golf.  This means you can't substitute a "putting ball" when you get on the green.  On the other hand, the current USGA Handicap Rules require you to post your score whenever you play, as long as you play with someone else, play a minimum number of holes, etc.  So to knowingly break a rule by substituting a ball, and then not post a score because you didn't play according to the Rules, should bring you to the attention of a diligent handicap committee.  I'd rather have a player post the score, even with a relatively minor transgression like this, than to not post.

This is an interesting point.  Let me get your opinion on a scenario that I see on a regular basis, and also participate in myself:

Me and the guys I typically play with call them "practice rounds".  For example, we would go to the course after work knowing that we probably aren't going to get 9 holes in before dark, but have no intention of playing for a score.  Instead, we use it as a chance to work on our game, or maybe to test out a new driver shaft or different balls or something like that.  We might hit several tee shots off the par 4s and par 5s, or hit a few approach shots into each green.  Depending on what I'm working on, I might not even putt...just fix my ball marks, pick-up and head to the next tee.  Basically it's similar to what the Tour guys do on Mon and Tues of a tournament.  Hitting balls on the range is great, but hitting shots on the course is different, so it's something I do on a regular basis.

What are your thoughts on this as it relates to posting scores for handicaps?

(Just to be clear, this is done during non-peak times when the course has few players.  We fix our divots and ball marks, and don't hold anyone up.  Often times one of the pros might be playing with us, but if not, they know what we are doing...it's not something we are trying to hide or not get caught or anything)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

1 hour ago, 1badbadger said:

This is an interesting point.  Let me get your opinion on a scenario that I see on a regular basis, and also participate in myself:

Me and the guys I typically play with call them "practice rounds".  For example, we would go to the course after work knowing that we probably aren't going to get 9 holes in before dark, but have no intention of playing for a score.  Instead, we use it as a chance to work on our game, or maybe to test out a new driver shaft or different balls or something like that.  We might hit several tee shots off the par 4s and par 5s, or hit a few approach shots into each green.  Depending on what I'm working on, I might not even putt...just fix my ball marks, pick-up and head to the next tee.  Basically it's similar to what the Tour guys do on Mon and Tues of a tournament.  Hitting balls on the range is great, but hitting shots on the course is different, so it's something I do on a regular basis.

There's nothing in the Handicap Manual that I've ever found that addressed practice on the course.  The rules simply require that you post scores that are played under the Rules of Golf.  The problem comes with enforcement by the Handicap Committee.  The Committee generally has to reconcile the records of who has played on which days against the scores posted by those players.  The expectation is that if you went out to play, you should post a score.  Consequently, it becomes a record-keeping issue to keep track of who is playing golf, who is playing alone, and who is practicing.  Then there arises the issue of a player who ends up having a really good (or really bad) round and deciding partway through that its a "practice day" in order to avoid posting the score.  I have no problem with people practicing on the course like you describe, it just makes things more difficult on the handicap committee, and that's a pretty thankless job already.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

The line is on the ball is important to me. I aim it at a blade of grass, pitch mark or whatever i find that is on line with where i want to start the ball. I line up else everything off that. What @burr mentions is pretty unusual, but if it makes him enjoy the game more then have at it. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Groucho Valentine said:

The line is on the ball is important to me. I aim it at a blade of grass, pitch mark or whatever i find that is on line with where i want to start the ball. I line up else everything off that. What @burr mentions is pretty unusual, but if it makes him enjoy the game more then have at it. 

I'll tell you what makes me enjoy the game MrGrouchO, hitting it in the screws and knocking down the flag.  I dont know what might be so unusual about asking a rules question and a short description of a reason for the question, go figger

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, burr said:

I'll tell you what makes me enjoy the game MrGrouchO, hitting it in the screws and knocking down the flag.  I dont know what might be so unusual about asking a rules question and a short description of a reason for the question, go figger

Pay no attention to old @Groucho Valentine, he's a New Jersey curmudgeon.  And just a little tip, when you want to mention someone by name, type the @ sign, followed by the first first letter of the name, and then pick the name from the list of members that pops up.  That member will get a notification that you've mentioned them.  And welcome to TheSandTrap! :beer:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

7 hours ago, iacas said:

#StopDrawingLines

This. I have.

A couple of years ago, I casually mentioned to my instructor that I thought I was lipping out a lot of putts and he watched me line a couple from 15 feet and lipping them out (on a straight putt) and then told me: you're lining up the line at the edge of the hole, not inside it. Stop using the line and just put down the white part of the ball (no logo, no marking), pick a dimple to look at, and let your body/mind do all the alignment and other work to get the ball to the hole. Results are much improved since then!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

On 21/02/2018 at 2:44 AM, NM Golf said:

FWIW, those lines are not all that helpful as it's basically been proven that people are notoriously poor at actually getting them aimed correctly.

TRUE -  I once tried it. I drew lines on my ball and just to test my eyesight, I lay down behind the ball for a three footer and made sure the ball was perfectly in line. When I stood up and addressed the putt, lining up the line with the putt, it would appear that I was 8 inches to the left of the hole - and that was from three feet!  It's amazing how the brain can adjust for what you see and what you think you see.

Edited by Shorty

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On 2/20/2018 at 12:15 PM, iacas said:

@Lihu, you're making several assumptions here:

  • That people are capable of putting the line exactly on the top of the ball.
  • That people are capable of lining the line up exactly where they want to hit the ball.
  • That people are capable of lining up a line on the ball to their putter.
  • That people then don't change their minds after the line is there re: where they want to start the ball.

In my experience, ALL of those are met an incredibly small % of the time. The second one, in my testing, 90% of people can't point the line on a ball into the hole (any of the 4.25") from 10'.

People can't do it.

Lines are pointless. They waste time, and they don't help.

And, consider the basic geometry. Even if you can put the line on the top of the ball… if your eyes are not directly over it, the line will be curved.

#StopDrawingLines

I know this post is a month old @iacas, but I definitely agree with you. I draw a line, but mine is more for identification than anything, and it's probably not straight. I line up my putts to a spot a foot in front of the ball anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

When I putt I place the ball so that I'm seeing nothing but white. No thanks to the line. Besides, how many putts are actually dead straight? Hit it too hard it goes above the hole....too easy and it rolls below the hole. In the case of a putt hit with improper force, the line is nearly unimportant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now




×

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...