Jump to content


Established Member
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


brocks last won the day on August 13

brocks had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

223 First-Ballot Hall of Famer

About brocks

  • Rank
    Long-Time Member
  • Birthday 11/30/1952

Your Golf Game

  • Handicap Index

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. brocks

    Tiger Woods Master Catch-All Discussion

    While it's true that Snead (and Hogan, and others) have been credited with official wins in events with as few as 15 or 16 players, while Tiger didn't get official wins for his 18-man event with arguably stronger fields, that doesn't mean Tiger has the record. The governing body determines whether a win is official or not, period. If the PGA says Sam's events are official and Tiger's aren't, that's it. And in fact, a review was done by the PGA in the 1980's, and some of Sam's Greenbrier wins WERE designated unofficial. Others were ambiguous, but they simply didn't have enough documentation to disallow them. Sometimes it works the other way. In the case of the British Open, several players got an unofficial win retroactively upgraded to official. Also note that last year, the Zurich was converted to team format, which disarms the people who complained about Sam (and Jack) getting credit for team wins. Jack also has an individual stroke play win that featured a field of 20. That one (the 1976 World Series of Golf) not only counted as an official win, but it paid him $100K in official money in a year when the British Open paid only $13,500 to the winner, and most PGA events paid $40K or less. Jack won only two events that year, neither a major, but that huge official check helped make him the leading money winner, which in turn helped make him Player of the Year, even though Ben Crenshaw won three events that year, and Hubert Green won three consecutive events. It would be inconsistent to say Tiger should have the wins record, while (for example) disallowing Jack's claim that he won the scoring title several years during the 70's when he didn't play the then-minimum number of rounds (although I do give him credit for two years during the 60's, when he did everything right, but was ineligible for the Vardon simply because he didn't have enough time on tour). So yeah, Tiger has the individual wins record, but that's not a thing. The official PGA wins record is what the PGA says it is, and the PGA says Snead has 82 to Tiger's 79.
  2. brocks

    Tour Poll Taken With Some Interesting Answers

    Absolutely. The career slam is a whole other thing.
  3. brocks

    2019 FedExCup Playoff Changes

    True, but Tom Brady isn't an independent contractor. Nobody is going to make Tiger or Phil play if they don't want to, and neither the Tour nor the sponsors want the Cup to be a joke, with some second tier player winning because most of the big names skipped an event --- or worse, were not allowed to play any of the four if they didn't commit to all four.
  4. brocks

    Tour Poll Taken With Some Interesting Answers

    I found a similar poll from last year. Back then, 72% said Tiger would never win another major. This time, 90% said he will. That should give him a lot of satisfaction. Hilarious how a significant percentage of players think others cheat or play too slowly, but exactly 0% admit to doing it themselves. Interesting that Trump lost 14 points of support since the last election, so that accords with more general polls. I was surprised only 56% voted for him, because these guys really care about taxes; that's why so many of them live in Florida (no state income tax). IMO the 10 events vs 1 major thing is totally dependent on context, i.e the player's record. If you're DJ, and already have over ten wins but only one major, another major is going to be more important. If you're Phil, ten wins would move you ahead of Arnie to 5th on the all-time wins list, which is a much bigger deal than having 6 rather than 5 majors. If you're Tiger, then he'd be an idiot to take one major over FOUR wins (assuming those are his only two choices), because the four wins would give him the all-time record over Snead, but one more major would still leave him second in that category.
  5. brocks

    2019 FedExCup Playoff Changes

    You have guys like Ricky and Rory this year, and Tiger and Phil other years, who don't play all four events even when eligible, so I doubt the players would go for that.
  6. brocks

    2018 BMW Championship - FedExCup Playoffs

    His stats at the BMW might be a bit deceptive, because the waterlogged fairways kept the ball from rolling very far, if at all. I remember seeing a couple of drives that plugged right where they hit, and would surely have gone into the rough with even a below average length roll. That said, he does seem to be swinging more smoothly with the driver, and his misses are not as wild. And even with all his putting and driving problems, he hasn't had a really bad tournament since June, and has had four really good ones, including two majors. I don't think it's overly optimistic to assume that between now and next year he can gain consistency in his driving and putting, and sharpen up his short game, especially his sand play. Doing that should be worth a couple of shots per round, and that's all he needs to win.
  7. brocks

    2018 BMW Championship - FedExCup Playoffs

    Yes, go here: https://www.pgatour.com/players/player.08793.tiger-woods.html/scorecards/r028 You can see them pretty much in real time during a tournament. Just go to the official PGA Tour leaderboard, e.g. https://www.pgatour.com/competition/2018/bmw-championship/leaderboard.html and click on a player's name in the standings. You'll see the expanded scorecard with shot tracker, etc. From there, click on "Full Scorecard" and scroll down past the scorecards to see the strokes gained stats for that event.
  8. brocks

    Spieth in Danger of Tour Violation

    https://qualifying.pgatourhq.com/static-assets/uploads/2017-18_pga_tour_handbookregs_final.pdf At the bottom of the "One New Event Played Per Season Requirement" it says, "NOTE: Regular Members (as defined in Article IX, Section A.1.f. through h.) shall be exempt from the provisions of this Regulation in the current season." It looks to me like that is something they put in for 2016, when the rule was first introduced, to give the players time to adjust their future schedules. They probably meant to take it out by now, but it's still there, so Jordan has an out. In the same pdf under penalties, it doesn't say how suspensions are implemented. If they just suspend somebody for the first three events of the season, like they do in football, it would be meaningless for Spieth, because he doesn't play the Safeway Open anyway. Anybody know how that works?
  9. brocks

    2018 BMW Championship - FedExCup Playoffs

    35 players have now finished their round, which means they can continue the tournament Tuesday if they have a weather stoppage today. If play had been stopped before half the players finished, they would have ignored today's play, and awarded prizes based on the 54-hole standings.
  10. brocks

    2018 BMW Championship - FedExCup Playoffs

    They have a week off before the Ryder Cup, so they would probably play Monday if needed. Now back to the 57 watch.
  11. brocks

    2018 BMW Championship - FedExCup Playoffs

    I hope Tiger continues his trend of having the first round be his worst.
  12. brocks

    2018 BMW Championship - FedExCup Playoffs

    I've made a birdie five years in a row.
  13. brocks

    2018 Dell Technologies - FedExCup Playoffs

    No, Koepka is still a lock for the PGA of America POTY (decided by a point system), and probably also for the PGA Tour POTY (decided by a vote). The only other player to win the first two FedEx Cup playoff events was Vijay Singh, in 2008. And he won the WGC Bridgestone earlier that same month. Under the rules of that year, he only needed to show up at the last two events to win the FedEx Cup, which he did. He was also the leading money winner for the year. In spite of that, POTY went to Padraig Harrington, who won two majors and nothing else that year. In fact, he didn't win again, on either the PGA or Euro Tour, for 7 years. And Vijay never won another official event on the PGA or Euro Tours, ever. It's tough to stay on top.
  14. brocks

    2018 Dell Technologies - FedExCup Playoffs

    Looks like there's a good chance we'll have Tiger paired with Brooks tomorrow.
  15. brocks

    2018 Dell Technologies - FedExCup Playoffs

    Great link, thank you. I honestly don't see what's wrong with my reasoning, but if my theory conflicts with results, I guess my theory's wrong.

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...