Just wanted to say thanks for the advice. I combined the advice here with a lot of research and reading yesterday. The main takeaways from my research were:
- Most people are playing with a driver that is too long (Wishon Golf had a particularly good article about this.) I used my 3 Wood off the tee box 80% of the time as I was in the fairway a lot more often. Whereas the others in my foursome would have a testosterone drive contest to show off their new $300 driver every hole ending up in the woods 60% of the time. I was surprised to learn the majority of the players on the PGA are using a 44.5" shaft (0.5" less than standard) and Tiger has played most of his career with a 43.5". This makes sense to me as I was always amazed he was so accurate with that insane swing speed.
- Most people are probably playing with too stiff of a driver shaft. Again, it's all about the testosterone. It's more macho to have the stiffer shaft (no pun intended.) Most of the people I play with are hackers with deep pockets and they are most concerned about how their stuff looks and what the specs are. Sigh.
- I also read that for the novice (and most any golfer), the higher loft on the driver is more foregiving. Lots of posts in lots of forums of people that went from a 9.5 or 10.5 to an 11-11.5 and had much better accuracy. I'm lucky if my drives go over 220 with a 10.5 regular shaft. In some cases a 12, 13 or higher is recommended for beginners/hacks.
- I've got a very smooth (not jerky) medium swing speed. And 70% of the time that I not in the fairway, I'm fading or slicing it, not hooking. This is typically due to standing to far from the ball or not closing the face properly. But for my swing type and speed, the more flexible shaft should be more suitable and maybe help the fade a bit.
This is what I decided on:
Calloway Octane - 11.5*, Senior Flex, -1.0" off the shaft. The shortened shaft will have a little less flex, so I suppose I end up with something effectively between a regular and senior flex. The 11.5 loft should be well suited to me as being used to using a 3W, I wanted something inbetween a 3W and 1W loft and length. I can't say enough about that Calloway Pre-Owned site. Excellent prices - as cheap if not cheaper than E-bay (running 25% off the Octane this week too) and the guy on the phone upgraded me to 2-day shipping an no extra costs. Great outfit they are running. $100 shipped with shaft customization and brand new grip.
Adams Idea A1 3-4 Hybrid + 5-PW. Good condition. $119 shipped. (Ebay)
Putter - I really cracked myself up on some of the prices of these putters. What a scam (in my opinion). Geez, I'm usually in the top half of the foursome on putting (its what I'm best at) with this dull, crappy looking 15-year old Spalding blade that is probably worth $5. But I can afford a moderately priced used one. And I read the putter is the club that benefits the most from a fitting. I'm going with one of the Cleveland Classic models - hands down the best value out there from all reviews I read. I can't decide on the grey one or the bronze one with copper insert. I'll have to try. It does look like the copper insert pits easily if you have sand on your ball (maybe too soft?)
Sand Wedge - Jury is out on a new Sand Wedge. My old Spalding Legacy 56* looks to be in decent shape. Gain, the Cleveland wedges sound like they are well rated and a good value. But frankly a new wedge is probably going to put me in jeopardy of "over spending" The thing is though, a golfer like me rarely gets the ball on the green from more than 75 yards away (depending on the course.) So the sand wedge may be one of my most used clubs. So I'm contemplating whether something newer might make a significant difference? Any advise on whether worth it or not to buy a new wedge?