We will have eventually a printed version (in fact this is how this whole thing started), it should be ready by the time we finish beta testing.
I am not very familiar with shotbyshot.com, but from what I can see there are many differences, most obvious is the price :-), however most importantly is the philosophy, UltimateGolfStats.com is about capturing the quality of your shots as it relates to you, so that you can tell how you are playing, and not what the score says. Here's an example, say you hit your driver way to the right on a par 4 and the ball lies on the bushes right behind a huge tree, you have no shot to the green, in fact, just finding the fairway will be tough. You take out your PW and hit a super 60-yard chip that puts you in the middle of the fairway, granted still 120 yards from the green. Was this a good shot or a bad shot? Most (if not all) statistics tracking products will tell you everything is bad, you missed the green, now go scramble from 120 yards which you may not. However, for you, this was a great save, right? UltimateGolfStats is about capturing that great chip from behind the tree...
UltimateGolfStats is about capturing statistics that are meaningful to amateur players, yes, scrambling % is great, and of course we capture that as well, but what about the things that happen to us (amateurs) in real life? How many times do I hit which clubs fat? What wedge is best from which distance? What are my tendencies when putting? Am I short, long? How about when chipping?
Wow, sorry for the long post, I got carried away :-) (I could keep going)