I want to accomplish one thing in here, if anyone is on the fence about buying a GI iron for any reason whether that is they look stupid, don't want to look stupid, or don't think they hit the ball poorly enough to constitute using them, maybe this will help them feel better about it. I felt the same way for my entire life, it took me hearing accomplished PGA tour pros playing PING G15 irons to even put the thought into my mind. Literally the sole smartest decision I have ever made in my golf career was switching to PING G15 GI irons, even if that only means I hit 1 more green in an 18 hole round that means I save a stroke or 3 and that is the difference between winning and losing.
I've read so many posts like this over the past few years and so many comments from people who are not elite golfers telling other non elite golfers to go ahead and use a fancy club that won't help them. I couldn't take it anymore!
If the club looks nice to you at address you're not going to hit the ball any better, confidence isn't going to prevent you from going over the top, hitting it 1 mm off center and it certainly wont prevent the ball from fading 10 yards, being short 10 yard and it wont prevent that missed green from turning a 2 putt par into a 2 putt bogey or double bogey.
Like I said, I think PING is ugly, I hate that it's not a nice shiny chrome, I have how fat the club looks at address, but I will smoke you on the course.
No one really cares that Rickie Fowler looks pretty ridiculous when he golfs (much less now than 3 years ago) because he can play. But when you are at a pub links and see someone head to toe in orange with a flatbill you're going to think it's a terrible golfer / poser, but if you see someone with blades you're going to assume they are a good golfer, until you play with them and they shoot an 85 on a 5800 yard course.
Buying golf clubs is not any different than basketball shoes. Sure, if you wear a pair of Jordan's or LeBron's you might look cool, you might even feel good about yourself and even if you think deep down it will make you play better it wont. Even if it raises your confidence a little it's not going to make you have better shooting for or in the case of golf hit more consistent shots.
What the majority of people don't realize is that pro basketball players get their shoes made to the specifications of their foot, LeBron James once threw his shoes into the crowd after a game only to have someone chase them down a few minutes later and get his orthotics out of the shoe first.
The exact same goes for golf clubs, take the KJ Choi going to Golf Galaxy in Dublin Ohio and buying some Mizuno clubs off the shelf which he played all 4 days of the Memorial that year. He tried several sets of Mizuno and bought the only set which had the exact swing weight of each club.
Rickie Fowlers Scotty Cameron which he used to win the Players, looks like any other GSS Cameron except there is the ever so slightest modifications that would be almost unnoticeable to the eye.
You can go buy the Bubba Watson Pink G30 driver, but you're not going to put 13 wraps of tape on one side and 11 on the other hand.
My point is that even your good amateur golfer probably doesn't have the proper grip size, proper wraps of tape, proper loft and lie adjustments done and their clubs wont have consistent swing weights. Unless you plan on doing ALL of those things, stay away from blades unless you're a +1 handicap.