From my perspective when looking down at the club, the 58 seems to have the leading edge sitting up a bit when placed on the ground.
The only way to make the leading edge the first point of contact (to me, that is) was to move the ball a bit further back in my stance. In doing this, I change the trajectory of the shot drastically from the fairway, and that's my real issue.
There aren't any grass driving ranges that I am aware of in my area. Well, there is one at the local college, but it is primarily hard pan.
I liked the 58 TREMENDOUSLY from the rough around the green with the right lie, and it was amazing out of traps. Truly effortless.
The more I read the responses and ask around, I'm being told I"m really looking for a gap wedge.