TheSandTrap.com  ›  Blog  ›  Thrash Talk  ›  Golf Strategery 

Golf Strategery

Jul. 31, 2014     By     Comments (12)

Golf Instructional books are undergoing a fairly major shift towards common sense on how to get better faster. I take a look at this new trend and what it means to you.

Thrash TalkGolf is hard.

Add to this the fact that most instructional golf books are not worth the paper they are printed on. Most players trying to learn how to play the game from a book have so many swing thoughts they're unable to take the club back. They stink.

Until recently, most golf instructional books were written to either help you improve your swing or trying to help golfer on the mental side of golf. The problem is that it's quite difficult to learn and build a golf swing from a book. Sure, they have pictures and illustrations, but how much can aspiring golfers learn from looking at a static picture of Tiger hitting a 300-yard drive? More importantly, how much can they teach themselves from staring at a picture of Tiger Woods?

Recently, though, the trend in instructional books seems to have shifted a little. Now you are starting to see books that help golfers from more of a statistical point of view. Recent books from Mark Broadie, Every Shot Counts, and Erik J. Barzeski and David Wedzik, Lowest Score Wins, are some examples of books that take a fresh approach using statistics to help you focus in on how to get better faster.

Lowest Score WinsYou might be asking what statistics have to do with getting your ball into a tiny hole hundreds of yards away. This is what I like to call the "old" or even "stupid" way of thinking, and helps to explain why so few books on golf strategy have ever been published. Jack Nicklaus's book Golf My Way and Tiger's book How I Play Golf offer golfers little insight on how to work your way around the course. These books offer no strategy, no plan for you get better. Listening to Jack and Tiger tell me that I need to have a good grip does not do much to lower my handicap or get me around the course in fewer strokes.

These new books shed light on how to make the best use of the limited time that most of us weekend warriors have available for golf. Take for instance that Lowest Score Wins tells us that we should not bother practicing fifteen to twenty-five foot putts. It alludes to, but doesn't say completely, that the types of putting practice we most commonly do is, for the most part, a waste of time. Holy smokes! Had I known that growing up my life would have been very different. I listened to the codger-y old men tell me to "drive for show, putt for dough." I now would have told them "Nonsense! I am headed to the driving range to practice my driver." In reading Mark Broadie's book one can most likely reach the same conclusion. Neither book says that putting is not important, but do illustrate that there are better ways to spend your time. As a golfer with an extremely limited practice budget (in more ways than one), this was groundbreaking news.

Books like this are going to be the new norm in my opinion. Golfers will learn to plot their way around the course based on their "Shot Zone" (a term from Lowest Score Wins). One of the many eye-opening parts of Lowest Score Wins is that your typical shot landing area may be a little right or left (and long or short) of your target. This can help you to aim at the right spot when facing a trouble shot with water on the right or left.

The point is to improve where you are likely to lose the most strokes. Like avoiding fairway bunkers because they basically cost you a shot. Details like this to help you chose driver or three-wood off the tee, which makes more sense.

Phil Mickelson

The only book I have found that even resembled topics like this was written was Butch Harmon's Playing Lessons. This book went through a number of famous holes and Butch outlined a strategy for a 90s, 80s and 70s golfer. This was a very good book at the time. The challenge with this book is that it never offered any concrete reasons for why we should follow the recommended strategies. It never offered suggestions on where to improve but was more of a "hit your three wood to the left side of the fairway, hit in the bunker, blast out," then followed with a bunker tip that could be found in Golf Digest. It has the makings of a really great book, but missed the target on how to make me a better player.

Lowest Score Wins directs you to work on aspects of your game that will help you get better faster. For example, it tells us that most players should aim at the center of the green when more than 60 yards from the hole, then provides sound data on why this is true. It helps golfers like us turn three strokes into two over enough samples. Another? If you're in a greenside bunker, the first priority is to get the ball on the green, not to worry about where the hole is cut or getting close. This is very valuable, for both a new golfer who is just starting in the game and even an old dog such as myself.

I look forward to seeing more books written like these books where we can look to get better by analyzing where I should spend my time practicing or telling me to aim at the center of the green, even the detail of how to aim away from trouble effectively. Golfers are only going to benefit.

Photo credits: © Zimbio.

Discussion

  1. dc3032 says:

    If you only had time to read one of these books, would you start with "Lowest Score Wins" or "Every Shot Counts"?

  2. Lowest Score Wins. More on how to get better faster. Broadie's book doesn't offer much in where to practice to get better.

  3. dc3032 says:

    Ok thanks... don't take this personally, but I have to ask in the sake of full disclosure... do you have any connection with Lowest Score Wins or the author or are you a 100% independent reviewer?

  4. Rip24 says:

    why isn't this book on amazon? I read Every Shot Counts and was blown away.

  5. dc3032 says:

    Rip24... that's exactly why I asked the question. It seems very odd that you can buy it off a blog site, but can't get it on Amazon, because, you know, EVERY BOOK KNOWN TO MAN is on Amazon.

  6. cipher says:

    Rip24, it will be on Amazon, it just is not on there yet. Coming soon.

  7. dc3032 says:

    And there you have it... Erik Barzeski - one of the co-authors of "Lowest Score Wins" - also owns TheSandTrap.com... otherwise know as THIS SITE!

    If that's not a 100% biased opinion, I don't know what is. "Every Shot Counts" is on Amazon and has a 4.5 star rating. I think I'll be getting that one first. Not saying LSW isn't a good book, but it leave a sour taste in my mouth when I have to find out the interconnections and conflicts of interest though my own research. There should be a disclaimer at the very beginning of this article.

  8. dc3032 - I know that you would love to find a conspiracy here that you have uncovered but sadly you will not.

    First off this is not a review of either book, but rather a discussion on the change in the way golf instructional books are written. Until now there have not been clear paths on how to get better. There were idioms like "secret is in the dirt", "work on your short game", etc. that were not helpful. These new books study where you will get the most bang for your buck. I think this is awesome no matter who the author is.

    I will not make anything if either book sells. I had to pay for both books just like you or anyone else would. No one asked me to write anything, I wrote it because I am excited about the change as I mentioned above.

    You asked me to pick one, but my recommendation is to read both.

  9. liquor box says:

    The best golf book I have read was Jack Nicklaus' "Playing Lessons"

    It is in an illustrated comic style book that has simple lessons that show you why a ball slices or hooks, how to control it and most importantly basic course management tips.

    These are really simple things like when walking down a fairway look through the trees to the next fairway so you know where the pin is exactly rather than guessing from 150m out.
    Another good one is on par threes using an iron always use a tee, why would you choose to play from anything but a perfect lie?

    currently less than $2 on amazon http://www.amazon.com/Nicklaus-Playing-Lessons-BOWDEN-NICKLAUS/dp/B000PJ9TT4/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1406972559&sr=8-2&keywords=playing+lessons+nicklaus

    I read this when I was about 15 and learnt a hell of a lot

  10. JP Bouffard says:

    Lowest Score Wins is a great book. It isn't about strategy per se, it is about scoring. It is based on sensible research. The writing is concise, simple, and persuasive. Barzeski and Wedzik explain very directly exactly what you must do to score low in golf. The answer is BOTH technique and strategy, and the way in which the authors have laid out the proportional importance of all phases of the game is, I think, brilliant, and very original. The concepts of "separation value" and "decision maps" are unique, intuitively compelling, and immediately helpful to any golfer of just about any skill level. I highly recommend the book. I also urge the authors to make a kindle version available.

  11. Sorry to disappoint you, dc3032, but I had no clue that Michael was writing this article prior to him saying "I have an article ready."

    It's not on Amazon because we don't want to list it on Amazon (yet). We're quite content to ship it ourselves until our publisher picks up the publication and shipping.

    I recommend golfers read both, but if they only have time to read one, the book I co-authored is better, hands down. And yeah, obviously I'm biased, but that also doesn't mean I'm wrong, either.

    P.S. My name's all over this site and the LSW site. It's not like this was a secret. :)

  12. snowman0157 says:

    I've read both books… You get More Meat in Less time with LSW. If you are a stats geek, Broadies book has more stats, but really less practical advice in my opinion.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.