bllleeehh... I have to partially agree with this. I'm a fourth year university student, two semesters from obtaining my teaching license in the state of Kansas. I come from a family of educators, and through my professors, family, and fellow students, this topic comes up a lot.
While I think that labor unions have done, and continue to do, great things for this country, I have mixed feelings about teachers unions. They do serve a genuine and responsible purpose. Teaching is a profession with many variables and requires a lot of flexibility and freedom, and tenure protects and enables good teachers to be able to find the most effective ways to teach. But tenure is also abused by many teachers as well, and I don't think anyone could disagree with that.
Research has shown that the most significant factor in a quality education is the effectiveness of the teacher, but the problem of poor teachers in the US does not rest solely with the teachers unions. Most of the top performing countries are even more heavily unionized than they are here. To elevate education across the board, we need to elevate the profession. We need to attract better applicants to university programs and make obtaining a teaching license harder. Teachers also need to be paid more,
not by merit pay
, but by the amount of training one has.
And I hate the back and forth over education funding. The US already outspends tons of other countries on education, and we still do worse. The problem is not that we don't spend enough on education, it is that we don't spend the money well. Throwing money at our current system might make a little difference, but it will do nothing to improve it to a level to make us competitive.
That being said Republicans, doesn't mean we can cut funding to public schools and invest all our money private schools, that doesn't do us much better. The solution with the money thing is to apply it more evenly to public schools. Some schools are great, others are crap, and it has to do with the distribution of funds. Everyone deserves a good education, and it's really not fair to the students that their level of education is based on how much money their parents or neighbors have.
The fact is, most great education systems around the world are
public and unionized
.
I support unions on the basis that I support increased workers rights, but I really don't know enough about how other unions operate so I'll have to stop my comments here. I know your beef is with organized labor and you were just using teachers union as the spotlight, so I'll agree with that part, the teachers union really grinds my gears sometimes. I wish we could have the conversation about unions without including teachers unions in the debate... the union is definitely needed, but every now and then I just want to scream "f*** you, teachers union!"
Sorry if my education rant was off topic, lets get back to fighting along party lines again