I understand that hes ranked 20th in the world now but you can't tell me that doesn't mean he'll be there for long. Could he continue to move up, absolutely. But he could just as easily not touch a top 20 for a few months and be back outside the top 20, heck the top 50. My point is prove it over the long haul, not over a 7 month period when most of the big boys were at home sitting on the couch. No body is calling Russell Henley a top 5 golfer or even hinting he'll be in that upper echelon and he just won last week and has multiple victories and a well known college and amateur career.
Golf is such cyclical sport. Its a fascinating sport to me because you can get to know a guy in one weekend, root for him to win the tournament and then never hear from him again on tour(or hear very little). There are so many examples of this. You don't just become a top 5 player in the sport by winning a few tournaments in under a year. You can't just say that and disrespect all the other guys who have been on Tour for much longer who have done the same things as you if not more accomplishments while staying relevant at the top of the game.
Golf is humbling and I think Zinger said something about this on twitter after Reed's comments saying basically, let reed have his time cause we all know the wave comes crashing down again, just a matter of if he can get back up and ride. So basically he'll falter at some point when in contention (maybe soon), he'll probably get hammered for it in the media and will he be able to get back up and get back into contention again in the future. Its happened to every pro and some have and others haven't. (hey Mr Duval hope ESPN pays well)
Its very different to be a hot player in a short amount of time rather than a consistently top 5 or top 10 player in the world.
Just look at recent examples within the last couple years of guys who climbed to the top and couldn't stay there. Where's Luke Donald these days? What about Lee Westwood? What about Martin Kaymer? All were former number ones in the game and all are very much doing what these days? Westwood hasn't won on the PGA Tour since 2010 and hasn't won worldwide since 2012. Donald hasn't won on a major tour since 2012 and Kaymer has done nothing of note in over 2 years. Sure they are still competing in high level tournaments but they are exactly the example to show how easy it is to fall from the top of the game and how hard it is to get there and stay there.
Remember Billy Horschel and his run last spring. He was a walking top 10 and I don't think missed any cuts till after the US Open and had a break through win at Zurich. In fact I believe he made 23 straight cuts. Since his high finish at the US Open he's done nothing of note at all. He looked like a lock to get a spot on the Presidents Cup team and surely was touted as one of the better young Americans. I believe he's only had one top 10 since his T4 at the US Open.
Golf has more flashes in the pan than any other sport and too me right now I don't think its fair to guys that have been out there for years and years to call Reed anything other than that till he proves it over a long stretch of time.