15 is easy. 19 is a little harder. Most conferences will have 12 games the way it's headed so for these instances let's assume a 20 game season for the NCG teams. This means, if the tourney started around the time the bowl season does, kids would be getting shipped all over the country for 1-8 weeks missing not only family holidays but who knows how much school.
Say:
Team A plays Team B in Atlanta on Dec 17th. Team A wins.
Team C plays Team D in Madison on 12/17. Team D wins.
Team E plays Team F in Dallas on 12/17. Team E wins.
Team G plays Team H in Detroit on 12/17. Team H wins.
Team A plays Team D in Columbus on 1/1, taking the next weeks off for the Holidays. Team A wins.
Team E plays Team H in TN on 1/1. Team H wins.
Team A plays Team H on 1/8 in State College, PA for the NCG. Team A wins it all.
Teams A and H played 12 reg seasons games and 3 post season games b/c an 8 team playoff was decided.
Sounds awesome, right? What if Team G is undef. TCU and H is undef. Boise State? Team I is a 1 loss LSU, J is a 1 loss Nebraska, K is a 1 loss Texas, L is a 1 loss South Carolina, etc. Teams I-L then campaign for a 16 team playoff system. 8 isn't good enough. The 1 loss SEC teams should have gotten a bid over TCU and so on and so forth.
Nothing has been accomplished and college
kids
have ran all over the country while trying to maintain grades and a family life.
This isn't the pro's...and I for one prefer to keep it that way.
Ohio State is Team A in this scenario by the way. Why? Because I wrote it and I get to pick.