this probably isn't the type of answer you were looking for, but i'm a big weight weenie, and will normally carry anywhere from 1 to 8 clubs when walking, which is about 90% of my rounds. (no bag at all if playing only one club, of course). i pretty much only use the full set when i'm on a cart.
that said, i still haven't found a bag other than the hoofer that i really like. i've had a few of them through the years, and the small weight penalty is totally worth it in ease of use and durability if you ask me! i focus more on keeping a minimum amount of stuff in the bag. only the clubs i need for the particular course plus like 4 balls, 2 gloves, and a couple tees. i'm much happier to leave a club at home than carry a bag i don't like, or that i'll be fiddling with all round.