I like Heartland Crossing in Camby, about 10 minutes southwest of Indianapolis. The course offers a good challenge, but will reward you for good shots. I've played it about 10 times, and it's always been in great shape.
Favorite holes:
#4 - 320 yard right dogleg par 4. You have 3 options off the tee: a long iron to the dogleg with a full wedge in, a fairway wood carry over two large bunkers leaving a chip to the green, or for the big hitters you can go for the green which is protected by three traps.
#9 - 425 yard par 4. A long drive in the fairway is crucial as this green is heavily protected by sand. The green is very large with plenty of undulation.
#13 - 500 yard par 5. Off the tee, there's trouble on the left with trees, and trouble on the right with heather. Your second shot is uphill, almost blind. Going for the green in two is nearly impossible with the bunkers that surround the green.
#15 - 385 yard par 4. This hole curves right around a lake. A long, straight drive will give you a wedge shot to the green, which is slightly uphill and heavily protected.
I give it a 5.