I was a member of RotarySwing.com for about 2 years. I implemented the swing and built it like the site said and went through the "program." I thought it was good. But as we all do, we try to learn more and his instruction over the course of 2 years became of a lesser quality than when I first joined. Now that I know what Alison has said I know why. It became more of an opinion and less about what the body is supposed to do. Before I read all of Alison's posts on CQ taking her stuff I stopped my membership. When he first "started" the Rotary Swing Tour his instruction was pretty good, but now it is very flawed. Just like any "method" you can choose camera angles, draw lines and show video to make your point. He didn't do this at first. Now it's all over his website.
This isn't intended to be a RotarySwing bashing post, just what I have experienced and my review of it.
In summary, I thought it WAS good, now just a bunch of thrown together swing thoughts, not a system.