I've recently moved from Mizuno MP-37 to Titleist AP2
I have to say the only reason i switched irons was because the AP2s had project x shafts as oppose to my MP-37 with R300 in.
My driver swing speed is roughly 112-114 mph therefore needed a change (both these sets of irons were bought 2nd hand)
I have always played blades since i got to single figures as a teenager
Gave up golf for 8 years and when getting back into it over the past few months, it happens i have grown some muscles hence moving from a regular to xstiff shaft
Whilst i hit a solid ball with both blades and cavities, I was surprised at the consistency the AP2 gave me with mishits whilst still giving me a "players iron" look
So time to get to the point of my post!
It sounds to me like you are looking for a similar performing club with a more appealing look to it
I would suggest looking at a forged cavity set - AP2, Cobra AMPs, TM R11 for example
They will give you a nice look and feel without compromising much on workability
Talk to your pro/coach about what they recommend as well - for instance i like the project x as they help me with keeping my hands inside through my downswing
If you have the cash, fitting with a seasoned club maker is the best money you will ever spend when it comes to your clubs
If you can find an ex-staff manufacturer fitter they have a lot of experience fitting on tour -I am lucky and have an ex-taylor made technical director who fits my clubs at an extortionate rate (but damn does he know his stuff!!!)
Best of luck