Jump to content

festivus

Established Member
  • Posts

    59
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by festivus

  1. festivus

    festivus

  2. Congrats man! Way to go! Working through a PhD in nutrition has taught me a few things after reading thousands of studies: adherence is the top predictor for success. Find something that works for you and your chances skyrocket. I don't even want to get into most of the hokum "science" that goes into most diet books - you are your own best feedback. Trust that.
  3. First, going to the gym for 2 weeks as the only change (as the OP describes) won't lead to that type of weight loss. Though you're right Pettersen's weight loss can change the swing for the worse (alter center of mass, center of pressure, and posture), the OP's situation is too fast for that. I don't know what people are doing for workouts so won't go farther into generalization except to say that a soundly constructed and executed workout before you play is very beneficial to golf. I've seen it with high-level collegiates and pros time and again. OP workout doesn't sound like it's something extraordinarily bad for the golf swing so I'd be surprised if it's the cause. I can't make a very precise response without knowing more about how things are being done. Agree with saevel to post swing vids for help.
  4. I'd opt for Orange Whip or Momentus. Being able to hit balls also has a downside. Folks will try to swing as hard as possible eventually, and do you want that much momentum taxing your rotator cuffs in the swing? Not me. It's nice to be able to hit balls but gotta keep the intensity lower.
  5. Yes but ethanol drives insulin through the roof. Any time you eliminate a major calorie source you stand a better chance of losing weight. That could be fat, protein, or carb. You can find a study or book or clinician who has success with any of those 3 plans. The key is to find one that works for you and be disciplined. Being disciplined is a heck of a lot easier when you're full! For a lot of people, carbs are extremely filling and high protein/fat makes them nauseous (I've found this particularly with east Asians and some of African descent). For others, like me (eastern European descent), I need protein and fat to have any chance of staying full. You get your mitochondrial DNA from your mother, so think about how she eats and functions and 8 times out of 10 that will help direct you.
  6. I will occasionally lay up to a yardage but that's usually in the case of a front pin with firm greens or a nasty lie for my would-be approach. Obviously, things like a water hazard will change the thinking. 20 yards in the water is not a great way to make birdie
  7. That's backed up by the PGA stat pack geek Richie Hunt who produces his yearly evaluations, pro golf synopsis. Last couple years he's made a case the FW wood is the key club on Tour because once you get within about 30yds of the green the birdie% increases exponentially. So guys with a great FW wood can get close to that green and bump their chances of scoring. Of course there are exceptions like Zach Jonhson's Masters win. But nearly anyone, barring yips, should get closer from 20 yds than 100 a huge % of the time.
  8. Just to clarify, and I agree on the knee essentially being a slave to the ankle and hip: the knee has a ton of soft tissue structure to stop lateral movement. I agree on initiating movement, the ITB and TFL chain aren't too hot with that. The only reason I bring this up is deceleration is at least as important as acceleration. When we're talking stable (not sure if that's what is being mis-stated as solid or not), deceleration rules.
  9. Erik - interesting thought. Reminds me of one of my favorite sayings: "coaching isn't about what you say, it's about what you can get your students to do." Seems Butch is pretty good at the latter, though I have seen a modest trend of his students with long-term injuries.
  10. If y'all are talking about head movement then to my knowledge Kenny Perry takes the cake for elite players: If it's early extension (diagnosed via the posterior) then Luke Donald is a pretty good example.
  11. I think the difference between firing at flags vs. trying to hole putts is actually quite large from a course management standpoint. IMHO we're talking about the value of picking a very specific target with a very firm directive. Related to ballstriking, that target could and often should be middle of the green or fat of the fairway...but the directive of "somewhere out there" is akin to the 3-foot circle in putting and in either case I don't think gives one the best focus or chance for improvement.
  12. Yeah - and you gave great advice! What I find funny is how many people start the game for social, exercise, or family reasons. They often start with such low standards and actually find reasonable results. Then the floodgates of expectation and score set in...it often gets ugly after that. At that point there is generally a fork in the road where you get obsessed or quit playing regularly. Some people do in fact derive a lot of joy from that competitive scoring aspect....more power to them. Again, what is the goal of the individual?
  13. Other books on this vein: Talent is Overrated, Colvin Bounce, Syed (the only one I know written by an elite performer himself) Outliers, Gladwell and so many more... One of the seminal original research papers by FSU professor Ericsson is actually quite a good read on its own. One thing often overlooked is the need to understand and value the "secrets in the dirt." Many golfers will come to start or improve from positions of relative wealth and power - they're used to getting what they want when they want it.
  14. I won't discount your experiences or advice but joint point out not everyone has the same goals. Some golfers play in 3 scrambles a year and just want to have fun, drink, whatever. For them going for the memorable shot is possibly the best choice on a regular basis. They my not be a huge segment of the marketplace but they'll buy a dozen balls each outing and the odd new driver. Others are obsessed with breaking 90 or 80 or 70. Yep, that's often course management, focus, etc. Your advice is terrific. In years of caddying and teaching I've also found a ton of golfers who SAY they want to break 80 or whatever but whose real goals are revealed by their actions. They want good times with friends, the odd hero shot to brag about, time away from work, etc. They can often end up miserable because they just won't admit to themselves that fun is the real point of the game for them. This causes so many to quit the game out of frustration. Nobody's right, nobody's wrong because the game has so much to offer...to each his/her own. So I'd add a preface to your post: think about what you want to get out of the game - that can change over time but at least give it a thought. Score is rarely the correct answer. Then go ahead and think about how to reach your goals.
  15. Definitely agree on the mentality. Some great research from Cook, Tanaka and a couple other groups on pressure's influence on putting performance. Pressure essentially puts the autonomic nervous system into "fight or flight" mode (sympathetic side). The decision to fight or flee is made quite quickly based on the brain's assessment of resources vs. demand. However, that can be consciously overridden with essentially what saevil is describing: self-talk. That pumps up your resources assessment. Tell yourself you're the best putter in the world (more resources), and yes you can putt angry (turn flight into fight). In both cases the image of making the putt and a tiny target is absolutely necessary. I have pdf's of many of these publications if anyone wants them...
  16. The key things that jump out to me are: 1) this swing has a head and postural change which suggests lots of timing required - not all bad but would promote streaky play. 2) worry about neck disc and rotator cuff issues down the road.
  17. I understand your frustration - grew up in New England and played important tournaments in bad conditions. The following things helped me: First, all your competitors are playing the same course. Let them worry about how bad the greens are. Meanwhile you can worry about how to beat them. It may sound cheesy but get your mind right that you'll get some bad breaks...the only thing you can control is how you react to them. I like the idea of flying the ball closer to the hole. With greens typically bumpy it often helps to place the ball a fraction forward so the arc is slightly more ascending on the ball. Our greens are really rough right now with bumps and the poa clumping while the bent settles. Important to get the ball up and riding on the surface ASAP.
  18. Don't follow a bad shot with a bad shot... Aggressive swings to conservative but specific targets... Agree with saevil on both putting and par 5's/distance. In order to get better you have to act like a better golfer. That doesn't mean trying to pull of 40-yard hooks over water out of the rough but it does mean trying to make 30 footers and advancing the ball strategically. Not all high handicappers have the same weakness. Completely agree on aiming at the middle of the green.
  19. Great advice. One area where seniors have an advantage is generally they have more time and opportunity to prepare the body for golf. Sometimes the body needs more time to warm-up, right? But pick a few things that you can do well and that will help keep you playing happily and on the good side of the sod.
  20. Thanks Erik - good stuff. An interesting thought that I might play around with on the force plates this week. FWIW if Dr. Kwon didn't have force plates he couldn't get torque - only movement and a crude estimate of angular velocity. On the timing, if your supposition proves correct then you could get 3 birds with 1 stone: alter deceleration, reduce torque and buy yourself a DS trigger.
  21. When talking about knee torque vs. actual passive support damage/injury you have to consider how much lead hip internal rotation is available to the golfer. Obviously some can handle the moments better than others. But there's a reason pitchers and golfers experience asymmetry between lead and trail hips (and shoulders for that matter). Did this study get published? I'd love to see it. Because you'd want to stratify by HIRD vs. not HIRD (hip internal rotation deficit)...otherwise it's not so helpful unless you track the people for a long time. Probably would want imaging as well since torque can be controlled by multiple strategies. Erik I appreciate your insight on this - I'm wondering if that little move you describe might also be a respectable timing mechanism, as some use re-planting the left foot, bump the left hip, etc. Thoughts?
  22. I think the issue is why does the foot change or golfer come out of his/her shoes? If you're gonna leverage the ground then the sheer momentum of the ensuing power can take people out of their original foot placement. I'll bet that's what led Hogan to that result. On the other hand if you're spinning and slopping around, especially with a bum knee or poor hip rotation, then that is symptomatic of less than stellar balance and ripe for problems down the road. I admit my question is not terribly easy to answer on a normal video analysis, but an important distinction to feel as an individual golfer. I personally find swinging back and forth with a light kettlebell helps distinguish between what is bolted/solid and what is just sloppy symptoms. The extra weight lights up the nervous system and helps awareness.
  23. My guess is the thumb in that instance will neutralize some of the leverage provided by the pinky, ring, and middle fingers. That co-contraction or antagonism is pretty likely to filter up to a couple wrist joints. It's almost like playing tug of war against yourself...lots of effort that goes nowhere. Just a guess but I'd imagine you could lose feel of the clubhead's weight as well.
  24. Sorry - sure. Toe touch is touching your toes with straight legs. Just a sign of how your body accepts and deals with flexing the trunk in general. It's not the be all end all but easy to relate to over the internet. By squat I'm talking about just a body-weight squat, thighs should pass below parallel to the floor with the feet flat. This tells you how the abdominals, hips and ankles function together. You needed it to learn to walk...you can add another challenge by holding a golf club overhead. Yes the lifter is wearing platform shoes but note the incredible difference in hip, ankle, shoulder movement and spinal stability between these two: One person is far more ready to keep posture under the increasing pull of centrifugal force in the golf swing.
  25. Thanks for clearing that up Mac - IMHO what happens at the head is just a culmination of many other things earlier in the chain. So early extension to me is classified at the center of the body. In the case of the head I do believe some movement is both natural and acceptable. You only get 1 spine - consciously locking things at the neck is an awfully risky proposition when things are moving at great force underneath.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...