I am prepping for a golf trip in two weeks and the group is having a hard time pulling their stuff together as far as handicapping rounds. We just have a foursome but we are rather scattered in skill. Our top player is an 8, followed by a 12, 14 and a 24. We try to keep things simple, even and fun. Before we go out the card gets marked up to show how many strokes player A gives to B,C,D. The way it has worked in the past is player D is 16 shots diff from player A so he gets a stroke on the hardest 16. Player C get strokes on the top 6 holes and player B gets a stroke on the top 4. This seems simple enough and we have done it like this for years but now player A says he is getting jobbed for strokes.
Full disclosure, the handicaps will move a bit on our trips as people are playing good or bad. We play some low dollar games the first day (36) and set finals hancicaps for the last two days were we do a match play with some other side games. Player A has never won the match play and I see his point about having the deck stacked against him giving up a stroke on 16 holes. Player D is the kinda guy that will run off a string of pars and have an absolute blowup to sink the scorecard.
I guess what I am asking, is ther a more equitable solution or,does it sound like we are doing it right?
Thanks