Jump to content
Subscribe to the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
Note: This thread is 5727 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

I’m looking to buy my first SW and I can’t decide which direction to go. I don’t want to spend more than $50 at this point because I’m just starting out. My dilemma is whether to buy a cheaper brand new SW, opposed to a used higher end club. Right now I’m looking into purchasing either a brand new Tom Watson wedge/Tour Edge TGS wedge for $40 or a used Cleveland CG10 for the same price. Does anyone have any opinions on buying used wedges? I’ve read that these clubs are usually the ones that get worn down the fastest. Also, any other ideas for a decently priced SW?
In My Bag:
Driver:MacTec NVG2 Draw 460cc
Woods:MacTec NVG2 3 Wood
Hybrid:Idea Tech A4 #3,Utility #4
Irons:MacTec NVG2 5-PW Steel, Regular FlexWedgesCCi Attack 50*CG10 Black Pearl 56*,60*Putter:C-Groove Valerie 34"

will you be using this club for anything more then chips and getting out of the sand? Will you use the club from 80 yards, etc? The reason I ask is because if you are you might want to pick a club that has some GI features. cavity back sandwedges do exist. I have a set of Acer XC wedges from Hireko that I absoulutly love. They have a traditional profile but have a small cavity type back that makes them more forgiving. My 56 degree sandwedge is my goto club inside of 80 yards and I probably use it 10+ times a round. You can have the club built to order on Hireko's website and should be able to get it for around $40.

http://www.hirekogolf.com/hireko/ord...1208/0/0/0/0/0

In my bag:

some golf clubs

a few golf balls

a bag of tee's some already broken the rest soon to be

a snickers wrapper (if you have seen me play, you would know you are not going anywhere for a while)

and an empty bottle of water


I agree that it depends on use. I bought a GI sandwedge and I never use it. I use my SW only for short shots (chips, pitches) and the giant, near hybrid size of what I got didn't work for me. I'm more of a slice through the rough/sand guy than power through.

You can get some used Titleist Vokey off Global Golf for pretty cheap..And that also what Callaway X Tour Wedges which are pretty decent.

  LaPuzza said:
I agree that it depends on use. I bought a GI sandwedge and I never use it. I use my SW only for short shots (chips, pitches) and the giant, near hybrid size of what I got didn't work for me. I'm more of a slice through the rough/sand guy than power through.

I would like to make it an all-around club. Play it from within 100 yards and out of the sand.

In My Bag:
Driver:MacTec NVG2 Draw 460cc
Woods:MacTec NVG2 3 Wood
Hybrid:Idea Tech A4 #3,Utility #4
Irons:MacTec NVG2 5-PW Steel, Regular FlexWedgesCCi Attack 50*CG10 Black Pearl 56*,60*Putter:C-Groove Valerie 34"

  mkrosal said:
I would like to make it an all-around club. Play it from within 100 yards and out of the sand.

are you a pretty consistent ball striker? Do you hit a pitching wedge decently? one thing to keep in mind is that a sandwedge will usually have alot of bounce on it, and it can be difficult to use it on full swings especially this time of year when the ground is hard (this is at least my finding). Its not impossible, but i don't generally take big divots to begin with either.

In my bag:

some golf clubs

a few golf balls

a bag of tee's some already broken the rest soon to be

a snickers wrapper (if you have seen me play, you would know you are not going anywhere for a while)

and an empty bottle of water


I have a Tom Watson 56 deg SW and like it pretty well. My only complaint is that the gunmetal finish came off more or less the moment I hit sand with it, but I'm not too concerned with aesthetics so I don't see that as a big deal. I love it for chipping, and full swings were really easy with it. I compared it with a new Cleveland wedge in the shop and liked the feel a lot better. It was fairly light, so I'd suggest at least hitting your options in a shop before buying if you have the opportunity.

In the bag:
FT-iQ 10° driver, FT 21° neutral 3H
T-Zoid Forged 15° 3W, MX-23 4-PW
Harmonized 52° GW, Tom Watson 56° SW, X-Forged Vintage 60° LW
White Hot XG #1 Putter, 33"


are you a pretty consistent ball striker? Do you hit a pitching wedge decently? one thing to keep in mind is that a sandwedge will usually have alot of bounce on it, and it can be difficult to use it on full swings especially this time of year when the ground is hard (this is at least my finding). Its not impossible, but i don't generally take big divots to begin with either.

I'm pretty decent for a beginner. I love hitting with my pitching wedge. I've been told to get something with a lot of bounce since i'm a novice. The Tom Watson club i'm looking at is 56.16 so its pretty high bounce.

In My Bag:
Driver:MacTec NVG2 Draw 460cc
Woods:MacTec NVG2 3 Wood
Hybrid:Idea Tech A4 #3,Utility #4
Irons:MacTec NVG2 5-PW Steel, Regular FlexWedgesCCi Attack 50*CG10 Black Pearl 56*,60*Putter:C-Groove Valerie 34"

A lot of bounce will help the wedge glide through the sand. However, a lot of bounce also can tend to make the club skip across the sand if it is thin and heavy. It can also make the club harder to hit off of thin lies when not in the sand.

I would say to get a SW with some GI features, around 54-56 deg loft, and an average amount of bounce.

Have you looked for the SW to match your set? I found one on EBAY for $30, used.

http://cgi.ebay.com/mactec-nvg2-macg...ec+Nvg2+phrase

Good Luck!

Gary

Nakashima HTEC 460 9.5, 65g Fujikura Motore F1 (s)
Speedline 3W, 70-gram Grafalloy Prolaunch Axis
SQ 2 18 Deg. Hybrid, stock stiff graphite
R7 irons, 4-LW, stock stiff steel
White Steel 2-Ball SRT PutterSunMountain MPB bagIGolf Neo


Thank you all for the advice. I ended up picking up a CG10 Black Pearl for 30 bucks in pretty good condition. Now on to my next club . . . 3 Wood. Any suggestions? are Tour Edge Bazooka's any good?
In My Bag:
Driver:MacTec NVG2 Draw 460cc
Woods:MacTec NVG2 3 Wood
Hybrid:Idea Tech A4 #3,Utility #4
Irons:MacTec NVG2 5-PW Steel, Regular FlexWedgesCCi Attack 50*CG10 Black Pearl 56*,60*Putter:C-Groove Valerie 34"

  mkrosal said:
I would like to make it an all-around club. Play it from within 100 yards and out of the sand.

your just getting started and you can hit a sand wedge 100yards...wow, thats raw power!

Driver: Tour Burner 10°5
3 wood Tight Lies 13°
Hybrid 3DX DC 23°
Irons: G5
Wedges: oversize 48°PW & 56°SWPutter: Anser 2Ball: TOURix

  mkrosal said:
I would like to make it an all-around club. Play it from within 100 yards and out of the sand.

You wanna play ur sw from 100 yards away? holy hell lol


A 100 yard SW is about average for a longer hitter. Mine used to go right at 100-105 yards. The harder I swung, the higher I hit it, but not really any farther. It seems to be going in the 95 range right now, as I have been trying to dial back my swing a little to start hitting my irons a little more consistantly straight, not just far. :D

Gary

Nakashima HTEC 460 9.5, 65g Fujikura Motore F1 (s)
Speedline 3W, 70-gram Grafalloy Prolaunch Axis
SQ 2 18 Deg. Hybrid, stock stiff graphite
R7 irons, 4-LW, stock stiff steel
White Steel 2-Ball SRT PutterSunMountain MPB bagIGolf Neo


  mkrosal said:
Thank you all for the advice. I ended up picking up a CG10 Black Pearl for 30 bucks in pretty good condition. Now on to my next club . . . 3 Wood. Any suggestions? are Tour Edge Bazooka's any good?

That was a good buy, imo. I was going to suggest buying a better grade, but used, club, so I'm glad you did. Should work for the majority of shots within 100 yds.

Now with the 3 wood... how much are you looking to spend? Will you be using this 3 wood off the tee at all, or just from the deck? Also, I noticed that your bag contains a 3 iron and a 4 hybrid, which are basically the same yardage... with the 3 wood being the only club between that and your driver. Have you considered an easier to hit 4 wood? Or are you planning to add a 5 wood or 2 or 3 hybrid later on? Give a little more info and we can help more.

  teamgs said:
A lot of bounce will help the wedge glide through the sand. However, a lot of bounce also can tend to make the club skip across the sand if it is thin and heavy. It can also make the club harder to hit off of thin lies when not in the sand.

That is what I was going to suggest.

I have struggled out of the sand and couldn't reliably use my sw around the green. When I bought my last set , I also got the matching GW and SW. It has saved me around 8 strokes.

  bIGwIRE said:
That was a good buy, imo. I was going to suggest buying a better grade, but used, club, so I'm glad you did. Should work for the majority of shots within 100 yds.

Well the way i'm building my bag i'm trying not to spend more on one club than i did for the set of irons, driver,hybrid, and putter which was only $125. so i'm thinking anywhere from $50-$75ish. Honestly right now i suck with the hybrid so i'm working on the irons. I'm thinking for right now I just want to get a 3 wood and maybe a 5 wood or 2/3 hybrid down the line. I've been talking to someone about a Tour Edge Bazooka HL 3 wood that needs to be regripped. He wants $35 for it but i'm sure he'd take less, imo thats a pretty decent deal for now.

In My Bag:
Driver:MacTec NVG2 Draw 460cc
Woods:MacTec NVG2 3 Wood
Hybrid:Idea Tech A4 #3,Utility #4
Irons:MacTec NVG2 5-PW Steel, Regular FlexWedgesCCi Attack 50*CG10 Black Pearl 56*,60*Putter:C-Groove Valerie 34"

Nakashima HTEC 460 9.5, 65g Fujikura Motore F1 (s)
Speedline 3W, 70-gram Grafalloy Prolaunch Axis
SQ 2 18 Deg. Hybrid, stock stiff graphite
R7 irons, 4-LW, stock stiff steel
White Steel 2-Ball SRT PutterSunMountain MPB bagIGolf Neo


I looked around a little on E-bay... I'm sure you could find alot of simmilar, but here are a few in your price range.

Callaway Diablo, Callaway 2008 X, Nike Sasquatch Sumo2, Callaway Diablo stiff flex, Adams rpm lp,

Just look around a little before you decide. The tour edge you're looking at is a pretty decent club imo, but I would still look around.

Note: This thread is 5727 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    TourStriker
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • Day 197 - 2025-04-15 Played 18 holes at Yeaman's Hall Club.
    • Day 13 (15 Apr 25)- late afternoon session with 6i full swings into the net and short pitches in the yard, before moving to Sw for controlled up and downs.  For kicks broke out the DCI 16° 1 iron and hit a few as into the net.  Definitely different beast. 
    • Day 24: Tax Day Stack Training Session for Full Speed Spectrum. Good session!
    • Very respectfully, I disagree.  I still believe there’s a small kernel of truth to my theory.  Hey, you, iacas and many others here are extremely knowledgeable, know the game inside out, know the tour inside out.  I’m just a schmuck who posted a take, admittedly unsupported and not up to reasonable high standards. There’s a background to my take - I’ll attempt to briefly describe it.  Back when Rory first came on tour, I thought he was great - most folks did, his talent was undeniable, and his youthful happy go lucky looking demeanor made him even more likable.  And he won early, fast - at the highest levels. And then the physical workouts started.  That was cool, man he’s looking good.  And as it went along, was even a bit shocking.  But all was still good in the Rory fan club. But as a few years rolled along and the majors stopped, folks like me started to question the effect of the physical build up.  (raising my hand here - - folks like me were probably concentrating 95% on the majors record, and failing to acknowledge his stellar play overall) The matches with Patrick Reed...  Somewhere around that time, Patrick became “the most hated man on tour”.  Raising my hand again, not sure if that timing is accurate, or even if that moniker was deserved.  But when Rory got into the screaming flex-off, it definitely detracted from the earlier Rory likability.  It’s kinda like he was lowering himself to Patrick’s level.  Not so great, for me at least. As the mid 2010s rolled along, and the majors drought continued, and the near misses at the Masters happened, the dreaded ‘choke’ perception inevitably raised its head and persisted.  I joined in with the chorus, not disliking Rory, but certainly questioning his ability to close the Masters or any other major.  Rightfully or wrongly, it was there. Then LIV came along.  As that developed, I saw the anti-LIV sentiment develop along with it, and I took offense to it.  My thought - these guys are being offered life changing $$, and the anti-LIV folks are trying to stop them from getting it. And then when Rory rose to ‘lead’ the anti-LIV sector, that really rubbed me the wrong way.  The press conferences, the parking lot shouting match - it just all seemed really distasteful to me.  And it seemed far far away from the early Rory, who I really liked. So all that (in my own mind) led me down the “Rory will never win.. yada yada”.  Not based on any real statistical analysis.  Not taking into account the incredible stats and winning record he had amassed. Purely based on perception and cultural silliness.  AND - the physical thing, which as I mentioned, I think there’s a tiny kernel of merit there. So - fast forward to Rory’s post win press conference.  THAT was the old Rory I remembered!  The totally cool guy, humble, forthright, honest, self deprecating.  He’s probably been like that all along.  And he’s certainly backed off the hard core anti-LIV persona, at least in public. That’s it.  Just a stupid unsupported take from a dumbsh*t golf fan.  For me, this was the most exciting major since the Tiger era. I really thought it would be a gladiator death match between Rory and Bryson.  I’m surprised that Bryson fell off - - I thought he was well-set-up to handle the pressure.  I’m sure he’ll be there many times in the future, along with Rory.
    • I've been watching golf for 35 years and I've seen my fair share of exciting events, but I cannot recall ever watching so much up and down in the fortunes of one player in one round of golf. How good the good shots were and how bad the bad shots were and how he was leading, then not, then leading again, then way clear, then tied, then behind, then leading, then in a playoff, then winning. Heck I aged just watching it on the TV - Rory must have gone through some stuff out there. Just incredible. Consider that Rory had two double bogeys, three bogeys, six birdies, and Rose made only 4 pars, 4 bogeys, and 10 birdies. 10! Round that place? Mind officially blown.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...