Jump to content
Note: This thread is 5941 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

Show me the perfect wrist angle at address. Should the wrists, hands and arms be straight in line with the club shaft? I just try to let my arms hang straight down naturally from my shoulders at address. This seems to promote a slight cocking up of the wrist at address. I would have to uncock and lift the arms a little to line everything up. Should I?

My Clubs
Nicklaus Progressive XC Irons: 3H,4H, 5-GW
Ray Cook SW & Gyro 1 Putter
Taylor Made Burner Driver 10.5
Taylor Made V-Steel 3 & 5 MetalsMy Home Course: Indian RiverMy Blog: Rant-o-Rama-Ding-Dong


Best advice I can give you is to go to the bookstore and pick up a copy of Ben Hogan's Five Lessons (or at Amazon ).

Your arms should not be in line with the shaft. They should be almost perpendicular to the ground. In your setup, if you have your arms down, your fingers should point at the balls of your feet. With longer clubs I tend to decrease my angle a little bit.

What you're doing is good, but I cannot stress enough that you should read up on setup position (from reputable sources of course). Leadbetter, Hogan and I'm sure others have other sources. Having a good setup will prevent and cure many problems. If my swing is off, the first thing I look for is whether I got lazy with my setup and I'd say 80% of the time this is the case.

Duh, I just looked at the swings about six pro players. All of them except one had the arms, wrists and hand pretty much lined up. There was not cocking of the wrist in any direction. But of course as you said, the club shaft is still at an angle to the arms.

My Clubs
Nicklaus Progressive XC Irons: 3H,4H, 5-GW
Ray Cook SW & Gyro 1 Putter
Taylor Made Burner Driver 10.5
Taylor Made V-Steel 3 & 5 MetalsMy Home Course: Indian RiverMy Blog: Rant-o-Rama-Ding-Dong


There's more than one school of thought on that subject (address position). Some teaching pros (the one I took my only lesson thus far from, for example) are of the school of thought that the swing becomes simpler and easier (more repeatable) if the position at address mimics the position at impact, so that the plane of the club doesn't have to be manipulated mid-swing.

At impact, the momentum of the club mean the shaft is much more in line (looking down the line) with the trailing arm than the traditional address position. So my teacher taught me to hold my hands much higher than the traditional address position, so that my hands were on a line from the ball to the center of my back (traditional has the hands on a line from the ball to the belt buckle). Also, at impact the hands should be slightly ahead of the ball on a good swing (all good golfers do this), so my teacher taught me to set up with my hands a little ahead of the ball.

So to summarize, the way I was taught to set up has the club shaft pointing to the left side of my ribcage, whereas traditional golf (Ben Hogan) has the shaft pointing to the belt buckle. It's the direction the shaft is pointing that defines the wrist angle, since the wrists have to angle the hands to line up with the shaft.

-Andrew

Duh, I just looked at the swings about six pro players. All of them except one had the arms, wrists and hand pretty much lined up. There was not cocking of the wrist in any direction. But of course as you said, the club shaft is still at an angle to the arms.

Yes, I guess the natural build of the human wrist make it look like they're in line. However, if you look at Tigers picture below his wrist are not in the natural, neutral position (which has almost a 70 degree angle with your forearm). You could call it de-cocked even.

I thought you wanted to have your arms be in line with the shaft, which would put your way to far away from the ball and would force you to bend over too much.. Sorry for the confusion.

Yes, I guess the natural build of the human wrist make it look like they're in line. However, if you look at Tigers picture below his wrist are not in the natural, neutral position (which has almost a 70 degree angle with your forearm). You could call it de-cocked even.

As I pointed out before, some instructors are advocating the position in this picture, which is further away from the ball and has the the arms (at least the right arm) in line with the shaft:

I learned this setup (that's not me in the picture, but it's what I was taught to do) from a PGA pro. He argues that it's simpler to swing the club starting from this position, because the orientation of the arms and hands doesn't have to changes as much during the swing. I'm not an experienced golfer yet, but his argument seemed logically valid and convincing to me. -Andrew

Well I went to the range today and took the wrist angle thought with me. I started a new thread in the Golf Talk forum called "Best Range Session Everrrr!" The wrist thing wasn't the only thing I did but that little change did wonders. Fat shots suddenly gone, apparently weight shift is not so much of a problem. Oh, I did think about swing path, hitting the inside part of the ball towards right field, and pulling the club down with my left arm/shoulder rather than throwing the right hand and shoulder at the ball. But having that wrist-arm alignment felt noticeably different.

My Clubs
Nicklaus Progressive XC Irons: 3H,4H, 5-GW
Ray Cook SW & Gyro 1 Putter
Taylor Made Burner Driver 10.5
Taylor Made V-Steel 3 & 5 MetalsMy Home Course: Indian RiverMy Blog: Rant-o-Rama-Ding-Dong


However, if you look at Tigers picture below his wrist are not in the natural, neutral position (which has almost a 70 degree angle with your forearm). You could call it de-cocked even.

I wonder about this myself. I do not fully "de-cock" my wrists at setup but sometimes tinker with that. I think it also depends on how far your arms are from your body at set up. I see suggestions all over the place. I would think that if you like your arms further from your body you would favor the "de-cocked" wrist setup and vice-versa.

I am more of a "arms-close / neutral wrist" golfer at address.

R7 TP 8.5* Fuji Speeder x-stiff (heavy,low,fade set)
975F 3W 13.5*
FX Tour Grind Nickel 3-PW +1/2", Rifle 6.5
Vokey SW 52*
CG10 LW 60* 3 dot (14* bounce) Tracy putter 35" (hit R but putt L)+ 1 club TBD...Past home courses: Unicorn GC (Stoneham, MA), Forest Creek GC (Round Rock, TX)Ball: Use...


I learned this setup (that's not me in the picture, but it's what I was taught to do) from a PGA pro. He argues that it's simpler to swing the club starting from this position, because the orientation of the arms and hands doesn't have to changes as much during the swing. I'm not an experienced golfer yet, but his argument seemed logically valid and convincing to me.

Interesting. Though, my address and impact position are not identical. My hips are square at address, but open at impact. This would pull my left arm back and I would either have to move my whole body forward to compensate, or somehow lean into the ball to not hit it off the toe or miss it completely.


My address position is what I consider conventional. With my irons, my arms and hands hang straight down, with about a hand width between the butt of the club and my body. I also set my hands a little ahead of the clubface. With my metalwoods, I reach out a little, with maybe a hand and a half clearance.

At impact, my hands are higher, but my left shoulder has turned some. These two differences seem to cancel each other out very well.

Interesting. Though, my address and impact position are not identical. My hips are square at address, but open at impact. This would pull my left arm back and I would either have to move my whole body forward to compensate, or somehow lean into the ball to not hit it off the toe or miss it completely.

Thanks for the response.

True, your hips are open at impact. But your shoulders should not be. If your shoulders were open at impact, that would indeed be pulling your left arm back, and it would produce a consistent slice. But during the backswing, the shoulders rotate much further than the hips. Then the downswing starts with the lower body, meaning the hips stay much more open than the shoulders all the way through impact. If you look at good players at the moment of impact, their hips are open but their shoulders are square (meaning they haven't pulled their left arm, which is why they're good players). If you don't believe me, look at Tiger's shoulders relative to his toes in these impact photos. His knees and hips are open, but his shoulders are totally square. Also, his shoulders, arms, and head are in the same position I set up in: -Andrew

If you don't believe me, look at Tiger's shoulders relative to his toes in these impact photos. His knees and hips are open, but his shoulders are totally square. Also, his shoulders, arms, and head are in the same position I set up in:

True.. I think it is just the awkwardness of the setup that is throwing me off. Bending over like that at setup would, for me, lead to a killer backpain. If it works, great, but not for me.


True.. I think it is just the awkwardness of the setup that is throwing me off. Bending over like that at setup would, for me, lead to a killer backpain. If it works, great, but not for me.

It is a little awkward at first, and I haven't really gotten past the "at first" stage yet, so I still spend a lot of time paused at address going through my mental check-list of whether I've gotten myself into the right position, and making little adjustments. But it doesn't cause me any back pain, FWIW.

-Andrew

Left wrist should be flat throughout the entire swing.

Right wrist should be cocked throughout the entire swing.

Reverse this if you are a lefty.


Now if you can tell me why at address you would line up differently than you want to return, then perhaps we would have something.

I can't for the life of me think of why you would want to do such a thing though.

Certified G.O.L.F. Machine Addict


As I pointed out before, some instructors are advocating the position in this picture, which is further away from the ball and has the the arms (at least the right arm) in line with the shaft:

This position looks a bit forced to me with very extended arms forcing quite a bit muscles to tension up, which you want to avoid.

Burner 9°
FW Burner 15°
Burner Rescue 19°
MP67 4-PW
CG10 50° CG12 DSG 54° & 60°


The entire idea is to hit down on the ball and I don't see how that is possible from that picture.

Every club in your bag except for your putter is made to strike downwards on the ball. Irons are actually supposed to hit the ball into the ground and trap it (in a way) if you hit them correctly.

This is why every pro's hands will be in front of the ball when they strike the ball.

I don't see how anything but sweeping the ball is possible from that distance away from the ball.

Certified G.O.L.F. Machine Addict


Note: This thread is 5941 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • Day 1: After a long practice layoff due to injury, vacation, winter darkness, and work stuff, I'm trying to start back up again. Today I just hit balls with keys from my lesson 6-ish weeks ago; neutral grip and centered turn. Gonna work with that for a few weeks, see how it goes, and then get a lesson scheduled.
    • It’s not live on free to air tv in the UK, and hasn’t been since 1995. ( I pay a subscription to Sky for generally good golf coverage). There are limited highlights on the BBC for some golf events, but that’s it. Are other/all PGA events on NBC?  Allowing ticket scalping is a systemic failure across sports and showbiz, which could be legislated against, but in the UK is not in any meaningful way. I don’t know much about the secondary market in the US or anti scalping measures.  Charging more to keep prices down is an interesting concept, in practice no doubt you are right even if It sounds a bit Catch 22  Do you think sports tickets and broadcast rights  should be sold on a purely capitalist basis, or is there an argument to say that some sports might benefit more from wider exposure and affordable access. ( golf in the US is apparently not one of these if tickets sold out at those prices so quickly)  Fans might benefit from cheaper tickets and in the UK at least, TV coverage that reaches a wider audience.     
    • LPGA Updates Gender Policy for Competition Eligibility | News | LPGA | Ladies Professional Golf Association Accordingly, under the new policy, athletes who are assigned female at birth are eligible to compete on the LPGA Tour, Epson Tour, Ladies European Tour, and in all other elite LPGA competitions. Players assigned male at birth and who have gone through male puberty are not eligible to compete in the aforementioned events.
    • Day 65 - 2024-12-04 Helped @NatalieB with her stuff on the force plates, then hit some balls working on the left wrist stuff. Picking up the club.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...