Jump to content
Check out the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
IGNORED

Bowls or Playoffs?


Note: This thread is 6771 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

0  

  1. 1. Which do you prefer: Bowls (BSC) or playoffs to decide your national champion?

    • Bowl Games (BCS)
      12
    • Playoff system
      40


Recommended Posts

Posted
Based on the discussion in this lively forum , very simply, do you like the current bowl system (BCS) or would you prefer a playoff system (like NCAA basketball)? Why?

I would like a playoff system as the current system has too many flaws (potential for multiple undefeated teams = no true champion, etc.) and rewards mediocrity with .500 teams being rewarded or eligible for a bowl.

Alan Olson

Follow The Sand Trap on Twitter!
Check out our Facebook page!

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
I would hate to see the bowls go, especially the older and more prestigious ones, because they are a part of college football. If you're in the SEC, you dream of going to the Sugar Bowl. If you're in the Big 10 or Pac 10, you dream of going to the Rose Bowl...and so on. Plus, the indecisiveness of the bowl system always provides fodder for off-season (and in-season for that matter) discussion and debate.

I wouldn't mind seeing the +1 playoff system that's been batted around. Maybe with some modifications, but a 16-team playoff might be a bit much. Bowls are cash cows but they do offer college kids on a mediocre team the chance to play in a "bowl" game before they graduate and move on.

Scott Sandlin
ROLL TIDE!

Driver: Taylormade R7 425 10.5 deg, Stiff
Fairway: Taylormade R7 Steel 13 deg, Wilson Deep Red II Distance 18 deg, StiffIrons: Titleist 735.cm 3-PW, DG S300, +1.5", +4 deg upWedge: Titleist Vokey SM 53 deg and 59 degPutter: Scotty Cameron Santa Fe 33"Ball: Titleist...


Posted

There definitely has to be some way to implement a playoff system for the top teams while maintaining the current bowl system for other teams.

People always talk about the loss of money if bowls were eliminated, but I disagree with that as well. I think the idea of a playoff system in itself would sell to the general public just as much. And surely they could somehow keep the top 6 or 7 bowls set aside for a playoff system.

They could start the second to last week in December with the top 8 teams. I know 8 would be subjective as well, but if you can't get into the top 8, then try again next season. That would be four games right there (Cotton, Gator, Sugar, Capital One for example). The top four would advance to play two more semi-final bowls (Orange and Fiesta for example). The winners of those games could play in the finals the first week in January in the Rose Bowl. The top four bowls could switch from year to year if need be.

That would take up seven bowls right there. I know athletic directors around the nation would be whining at how their teams have to play more games, but the system would at least crown a true national champion.

You could always sprinkle in the other bowl games throughout those three weeks as well, giving other teams a shot at a bowl game.

The hype and excitement would be at an all-time high if you ask me. TV ratings and everything else would be better as well because there would be more teams (along with their fans) involved in the national title scene.

In case you are wondering, I'm for the playoff.

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted

Wouldn't miss the BCS as it sits, not AT ALL

I'm sure Al's suprised by that LoL

In My Bag:

Taylormade: Superquad 9.5 Aldila VS Proto 'By You' 70-S
Sonartec: SS-07 14.0 Aldila NV 85-S
Cleveland: Halo, 3i UST Irod 83-SPing: i-10 4-UW AWT-STitleist: Vokey Design Spin Milled 54.10 & 60.08Slighter: Handstamped Tacoma, 350G in Black Satin w/Sound Slot

Posted

Four of the top seven bowls play the saturday before New Years. The next week two more bowl games and then the third week the championship game. Only six spots reserved for conference champions plus the top two at large based on BCS system. Top six conferences would be SEC, PAC 10, BIG 10, BIG 12, BIG EAST, ACC. If you don't gurantee the six conferences a shot they will never go for it. The main problem is that Notre Dame or a one loss, none conference champion, major conference school could be shut out by say Boise state, playing a weak schedule,so strength of schedule needs to really count. Rose, Orange, Sugar, Fiesta, Cotton, Holiday,rotate for the first two rounds and rotate the championship among other sites. Seven games over three weeks the money and ratings would be huge.
I can dream can't I.

1W Cleveland LauncherComp 10.5, 3W Touredge Exotics 15 deg.,FY Wilson 19.5 degree
4 and 5H, 6I-GW Callaway Razr, SW, LW Cleveland Cg-14, Putter Taylor Made Suzuka, Ball, Srixon XV Yellow


Posted
Here's an idea, use the English system for Football (soccer). One elite leauge, 'The Premiership Leauge', each team plays every other team twice over the season once at home and once away, three points for a win, 1 point for a draw, team at the top of the leauge is the champion for the season. In addition we have special cups to play for eg. The FA Cup open to every team in the country, via rounds going to the quatre finals, semi finals then the final to decide the winner.

Or stick with your systems which obviously work, but the playoffs sound better choice.

Posted
Here's an idea, use the English system for Football (soccer). One elite leauge, 'The Premiership Leauge', each team plays every other team twice over the season once at home and once away, three points for a win, 1 point for a draw, team at the top of the leauge is the champion for the season. In addition we have special cups to play for eg. The FA Cup open to every team in the country, via rounds going to the quatre finals, semi finals then the final to decide the winner.

There are over 100 Division one teams, playing a maximum of 13 games, the recovery time needed from game to game for American Football is

at least 5 days due to all the hitting. So I don't think your suggestion would work here.

1W Cleveland LauncherComp 10.5, 3W Touredge Exotics 15 deg.,FY Wilson 19.5 degree
4 and 5H, 6I-GW Callaway Razr, SW, LW Cleveland Cg-14, Putter Taylor Made Suzuka, Ball, Srixon XV Yellow


  • 1 month later...
Posted
I'd have to go with Bowls. I hate admitting that, but it's the only way crappy little schools have a chance at anything TV-worthy. If they did a plyoff system, littler schools like Boise State and Auburn wouldn't get anywhere. The Bowl system at least sets up the rivalries and school spirit, since a lot of teams go to some kind of bowl. With playoffs, who would watch their Alma Mater if there was no way they would make any kind of Bowl or playoff? I bet it would be few. Their season would be over after it was evident they couldn't win their conference championships.

So, as much as I hate to admit it, the Bowl system is better in my opinion. Their are some major kinks to work out in the BCS, but overall, it's giving the nobody schools a chance to build their programs, have some fun, and build school spirit. (And contrary to what announcers and analysts believe, it is all about school spirit and fun. Ask the fans and boosters!)
"Hit 'em hard - they'll land somewhere." - Stewart Maiden

In the Bag:

Driver: R480, 10.5*, Graphite5 Wood: R540 XD, 17.5*, GraphiteIrons: Big Bertha 4-10 + GW, SSWedge: 56*, Chrome, SSPutter: White HotBall: HX Hot

  • 5 months later...
Posted
There is a playoff system currently employed but it is in Division 1aa. I am a junior at Appalachian State University and have had the enjoyment of watching our team win back to back championships over the last two years. I can tell you personally there is nothing more excting than a 16 team playoff in december to decide the true national champion. Even though it is one division down we are still able to compete with many BCS teams and still average over 30k in attendance per game. Look out for the three-peat this year.
Posted
I don't believe a playoff would solve the controversy in crowning a D1 champion. I live in a DII college town that belongs to arguably the best DII conference in the country, every year the gulf south conference will be paired against one another in an early round, eliminating a powerful contender. If these sort of things happen at the DII level can you imagine the mess ESPN and the national sports media would create with the system to select DI playoff teams and pairings.

The +1 is the only viable solution I see. I hope the current bowl system stays in place, we get to see alot more football this way.

  • 5 weeks later...
Posted
I voted BCS but think there should be changes. Playoffs were not well defined enough for me. Are we talking about the top twelve? ten? 4?

  • 1 month later...
Posted
i like bowl games. it's what truly separates college football from the NFL, but I think that we need to do away with the BCS and go back to the old days.

dmz

In My Bag:
Driver: 975J, 9.5, Grafalloy ProLite 3.5+ (tipped)
3 wood:
F-50, 15, True Temper Dynamic Gold S300 Irons: TA3 Form Forged, True Temper Dynamic Gold, 3-PW Wedges: Tour Action REG. 588, 51 & 60 RTG, 56 Chrome Putter: Studio Style, Newport 1.5 Ball: ProV1*


Note: This thread is 6771 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • The first post is here:   Do you have an overly long backswing that ruins sequencing and leads to poor shots? In nearly 20 years of teaching, I've found 5 common faults. You don't have to swing like Jon Rahm, but a shorter swing will probably help you #PlayBetter golf. Which is your fatal flaw? #1 - Trail Elbow Bend Average golfers ♥️ bending their trail elbows. It can feel powerful! Tour players bend their trail elbows MUCH less. A wider trail elbow creates a longer hand path and preserves structure. It also forces more chest turn; not everything longer is bad! Overly bending your trail elbow can wreak havoc on your swing. It pulls your arms across/beside your body. It requires more time to get the elbow bend "out," ruining your sequencing. The lead arm often bends and low point control is destroyed. The misconception is that it will create more speed, but that's often the opposite of what happens. Golfers often feel they swing "easier" but FASTER with wider trail elbows. Want to play better golf with a shorter backswing? Don't bend your elbow so much. #2 - Hip (Pelvis) Turn I see this all the time: a golfer's hips are only 5-10° open at impact, but he turns them back 60°+ in the backswing. Unless your father is The Flash, your hips are probably not getting 40° open at impact from there! That's more rotation than Rory! Golfers who over-rotate their pelvis often over-turn everything - trail thigh/knee, chest/shoulders, etc. They have more work to do in the same ~0.3 seconds as a Tour player who turns back ~40° and turns through to impact 40° or so. Want to shorten the pelvis turn a bit? Learn to internally rotate into the trail hip, externally rotate away from the lead hip, and do "less" with your knees (extending and flexing) in the backswing. Learn some separation between chest and pelvis. #3 - Rolled Inside and Lifted Up Amateurs love to send the club (and their arms) around them. You see the red golfer here all the time at your local range. The problem? Your arms mostly take the club UP, not around. Going around creates no height until you have to hoist the club up in the air because you're halfway through your backswing and the club is waist high and three feet behind your butt! 😄  Learn to use your arms properly. Arms = up/down, body = around. Most golfers learn how little their arms really have to do in the backswing. The picture here is all you've gotta do (but maybe with a properly sized club!). #4 - Wide Takeaway Width is good, no? Yes, if you're wide at the right time and in the right spots. Golfers seeking width often don't hinge the club much early in the backswing… forcing them to hinge it late. Hinging the club late puts a lot of momentum into the club, wrists, and elbow just before we need to make a hairpin turn in transition and go the other direction at the start of the downswing. When you're driving into a hairpin curve, you go into it slowly and accelerate out of it. Waiting to hinge is like coasting down the straightaway and accelerating into the hairpin. Your car ends up off the road, and your golf ball off the course. Give hinging at a faster rate (earlier) then coasting to the top a try. You'll be able to accelerate out of the hairpin without the momentum of the arms and club pulling in the wrong direction.   #5 - Sway and Tilt Some sway is good but sometimes I see a golfer who just… keeps… swaying… Their chest leans forward a bit for balance, resulting in a whole lotta lean. The green line below is the GEARS "virtual spine." Pros sway a bit, but stay ~90°. This sway often combines with the extra pelvis turn because this golfer is not putting ANY limits on what the "middle of them" (their pelvis) is doing in the backswing. These golfers spend a lot of energy just to get back to neutral! The best players begin pushing forward EARLY in the backswing. Often before the club gets much past their trail foot! Pushing forward (softly) first stops your backward sway and then begins to get your body moving toward the target. Push softly, but early!  
    • I  no longer spend the time and effort trying to sell something I no longer need. Instead, if the clubs are in good condition, I go to my local golf shop or even Dicks Sporting Goods. Trade the clubs in for store credit and pick up something I need, like a hat. Cause you always need another golf hat!
    • Day 205 3-10 Wider backswing, reconnecting arm in downswing/arching wrist through. Also worked on less pause at the top. Recorded and hit a few foam balls. 
    • I really enjoyed this episode with Nick from Callaway. I didn't know the problem with swing weight and female golfers, but it makes sense. I actually think swing weight might not matter that much. If everyone senses the club differently, then wouldn't it mean that people might feel swing weights differently? Swing weight is a way to classify how heavy a club feels during the swing. Yet for a 70-year-old golfer, a D0 might feel like a D4 for a 25-year-old golfer? I think stronger people would consider higher swing weights lighter. Maybe a C8 equals a D2 in terms of feel?   
    • Wordle 1,725 3/6 ⬜🟨⬜🟨⬜ ⬜🟨🟩⬜⬜ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.